Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
58/100
Data Completeness
56/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
Contact Information
📍
Address:
Fifth Avenue, San Mateo
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
306
Google reviews
I got a kale and chicken pizza- it was great! A little spicy, lots of toppings, interesting pine nuts added. A unique pizza that hit home! The bottom wasn’t burnt but there were burnt crumbs, so it seems like maybe they could clean their ovens more frequently. As someone who grew up on the east coast, I approve this place.
Read more
Google
Amici's pizza never disappoints! They always have the best pizza options. The crusts are some of my favorites. I dined outside with my pets. The staff was so friendly and attentive (they even brought out water bowls for my cats). They gave great recommendations. I am looking forward to returning!
Google
If you New York style pizzas (very thin crust), this is the place. They are on the pricier side but it is well worth the extra bucks. The pastas, salads and desserts are good but nothing special. This location is in downtown San Mateo which means street parking can be difficult. My suggestion is to park in the public parking garages. Both indoor and outdoor seating are available. Definitely go for the pizzas.
Read more
Google
Audrey was very friendly and efficient as both a hostess and server. I ordered olive oil and vinegar with sourdough bread along with the Michi combo pizza. Both were very delicious and the bread was hot and fresh made... So be careful you might burn your fingers with that lol... The pizza was very flavorful and of course old world brick oven cooked... I was very excited about that fact... And the price was reasonable especially for the high quality food that you get. Overall, I would highly recommend this place to anyone and everyone who gets the chance.
Read more
Google
Ordered a family-sized chicken Caesar salad at $25 + tax only to discover it was the size of a regular clear plastic to-go container. In addition, they left out the chicken and I had to return to the busy downtown location on Father's day evening to have them correct the order. 15 minutes for them to add the missing chicken with no apology.
Read more
Google
I looooove the pizza here an the service is so nice they check in with u and give u space when needed and make u feel super welcome kinda pricey but well worth it. If I lived closer that would be the only pizza I'd go for broke for
Google
UPDATE: manager reached out to apologize/try to resolve issue. Haven't gone back yet...
Every Flipping Time.
So there is one pizza that my mom really likes at this place. That's why we go. Everytime she orders it, we specify no parsley. Everytime it still comes with parsley. It doesn't matter what proactive steps are taken. This time there was even a note on the receipt to have it inspected by a manager. Either they didn't check or didn't care. #fail. Thankfully it's just a flavor thing and not a food allergy issue...
Photographic evidence included.
Read more
Google
I am a pizza lover, this is far from being considered a good pizza, they want to eat a good pizza, I present the dinapoli or Round table, the pizza comes with a lot of filling, with a lot of pineapple and a lot of turkey, place! 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤢🤢🤢🤢 disappointment result!
Google
Explore more in San Mateo
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: