I had noticed this place when it opened but hadn't gotten there till yesterday. I had the Italian meatball sub. It was pretty good, I should have asked for extra cheese. The place was clean and the staff was nice. It is likely I will return to try other subs there.
Delicious local subs! Made fresh to order. Some yummy treats as well.
I was very happy with my experience at New York Super Subs. In I had the best cheese hoagie since I moved on this side of the river, with a good roll from Breadworks and quality meat. They also had some good looking bakery items. The only reason why I did not give it 5 stars is that the menu is a little confusing and fails to note that a 6" sandwich is available.
A wonderful and clean small space with HUGE subs for an excellent price. I randomly drove by this place for a while until I stopped and I’m very glad I did. Their subs are delicious and the meatballs excellent. Awesome sides like potato salad and desserts... best cannolis I’ve had!!! Plus lots of chocolates inside the store to choose from. This is definitely my favorite sub joint and blows chains like Subway out of the water by a mile.
I cannot say enough good things about New York Super Subs. My husband has gotten their catered subs for his job which then made us order them for our gender reveal. We had gotten the veggie, Italian and turkey....We didn't have ANY leftovers, our guests were so pleased. Today we went in to get the chicken cheesesteak and pastrami along with a side of their hashbrowns with cheese. Besides the food being DELICIOUS, the customer service is what hits home the most. It felt so warm, welcoming and a sense of family. My husband is from Philly and this is the closest we've come to subs from home. We will be lifelong customers! Thank you
Covid has put a strain on so many places. Glad to see New York Super Subs has been able to keep up. Employees are super friendly and the food is great. Haven't had the desserts but they all look phenomenal! Half of any of the subs is a great value, because you're not leaving there feeling hungry.
Loved this restuarant, I ordered a full size sub, and was greatly surprised with the size, the ham in the sub was delicious. The lettuce and tomatoes were super fresh and ripe, the staff was super friendly, and although I didnt buy them, the bakery goods at the end of the counter are a great dessert option. NY super subs is definitely a new favorite of mine
Today was the first time I've eaten here and I'll definitely be back. The food was delicious and fresh. You can tell everything is homeade, definitely no shortcuts. The service was awesome too. Whoever was working was so so friendly. All around great experience. I'm excited to try the desserts and their gourmet chocolates in the future. Awesome food and awesome people!
Ran into NY Super Subs, after a VERY long day, at medical appointments, and my son's PT, in Fox Chapel. Start off, with we have always heard amazing things. I ordered a Reuben, asked for extra 1000 island on the side, (I secretly want to dip every bit in the Xtra sauce!) The owner was amazing, and kind made 2 sandwiches quickly for a mom ready to head home, and relax after a long day! I would have loved 1 more Xtra sauce, but I'm not complaining. Amazing Reuben. Full of meat, krauat, etc; grilled to perfection. Thank you for our wonderful experience! I will suggest your place, to anyone I can. Thank you, for your service!!!!
Ordered a Reuben, went to pay and it was $16. Was pretty shocked at the price for a sandwich. Got to my car to see what $16 gets you and ate it in the parking lot. I will pay $16 again for this sandwich. It was Amazing
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pittsburgh
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes