Review The Wagner - Penn Yan

Came here for lunch on Wednesday and had the buffalo chicken wrap. It had a more sweet flavor then what I am used to with buffalo chicken but it was still so delicious and good. I got it with ranch on the inside instead of blue cheese. And I got fries as well. Very impressed and I would recommend and come back another time.

Great location for breakfast. Service was really good. Food was great! Open early. I would definitely recommend this place.

We had a large group. The service was great. The food came quickly and was delicious!!

The Wagner is a local favorite for a reason! The service is always quick and friendly, with very attentive wait staff. The food comes quickly with generous portions and you'll likely be offered a drink refill before you've even had a chance to empty your cup. This is my go to for breakfast and I've never been disappointed!

It's been a long time since I was there last. So I had a few beers and a burger n some mushrooms. So the burger was great full of flavor and most of all it wasn't messy (luv a good cook) the fried m ushrooms were very good and cooked perfectly. The service was absolutely great.

Steak was correct temp. Server was very efficient and food came out very quickly. Also, if you look at the photo quickly, it kind of looks like a monkey's face. And that's just a little bit of good old fashion clean fun for everyone. Men's room sink faucet is detaching from the porcelain, FYI 🤙 🎶🎶Got me dirty dancing while they call me Gravy Swayze🎶🎶

Got the steak and eggs for breakfast, I've had worse cuts of meat at 5 star steak houses. Absolutely delicious! Our server was definitely on top of keeping an eye out for my coffee refills. Definitely a "small town" vibe. overheard a lot of blue collar/fishing banter 9/10!

Good food, fast service, and large dining space. Perfect if your visiting for the weekend!

Breakfast is good and plentiful. Service very good, atmosphere a little dated but if you like being where the locals go this is a good choice.

It has become our go-to when we are going toward Penn Yan. The food is good, the staff are friendly and the prices are good.

Unbelievable restaurant! Went on a Sunday morning. Place was packed full. We got a table tho right away. Server was awesome, was there as we sat down. Had our drinks immediately and ordered then. Omg less than 10 minutes she brought our breakfast. Food was hot and best breakfast i have had out in years. Great pancakes, cooked perfectly. Staff all very friendly and courteous. Never had to ask for coffee refills. Prices amazing also. Our server was a petite very pretty long hair blonde. Wish i had her name to mention. I can't wait to go again as we live 45 minutes away. But definitely worth the drive. Kudos to the breakfast cooks, great job!!

You think the food at Wagner's is nothing like the food showing here that my dear and wonderful daughter made. You try it, you may just love it. God Bless everyone! 🙏🐒🤗👍

Had a quick breakfast there for the first time recently. My girlfriend and her family have always talked this place up and it lived up to the hype! Quick and courteous staff, excellent food and big portions at a good price - which is quite rare these days.

Best steak I have had in a long time, Finally someone that know what medium well means!

Great breakfast place! Fresh food, affordable prices, friendly atmosphere

One of our go to places for breakfast or lunch! Good food, consistently good service.

Good food, excellent service, decent prices and breakfast is the best. We always go here and will continue doing so.

My husband & I don't visit the town often, usually just passing through. We decided to stop for dinner at Wagners. Both ordered meatloaf. (Note: not recommended for those monitoring sodium intake) There was a short wait, and the portions were better then expected! Waitress was the daughter of the owner & friendly. Answered our questions promptly as well. We'll be sure to stop again, while in town.