Sluurpy
Reset

There are 5 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Sandwiches in Penn Yan

There are 5 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Oak Leaf Cafe
87/100 (533 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Cafe
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Cafe
Soups
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Lunch
Brunch
Greek Wrap
Breakfast Burrito
Cheesesteak
Toasted Bagel with Cream Cheese
Mocha Java
Cinnamon French Toast Limited Amounts
Zucchini Panini
Baked Oatmeal
Paninis
Zucchini Chowder Soup
Iced coffee
Sandwiches
Chocolate Mousse Latte
Turkey Sandwich on Cheesy Bread
Side Salad
Tuna Salad Sandwich -Half
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Spinach Salad
Breakfast Panini
Cajun Chicken Wrap
Iced Latte
Decaffeinated Coffee
Salad
Sit down
American
Soups
Café
Parking Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Brunch
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"Stopped in for breakfast while camping in Keuka State Park. Amazing fruit smoothies, the raspberry was delicious! Even stopped in again for breakfast..."
poisoned_record
"Highly recommend!!! Love the zucchini panini and we tried the zucchini chowder soup ☺️ plus my husband enjoyed his mocha..."
Jennifer Conway
"I loved this place! The food and coffee were very good, the service was fast and the people friendly. After breakfast we shopped around in the..."
Holly Pealo
"This little store and cafe is always a delightful experience! It’s wildly popular for good reason, always clean and bright and busy! It’s located..."
Brittany Moore
"I ordered the July Special, Peach Panini. It was super good!! I was a little skeptic at first, but thought I’d give it a try since it is very..."
Curtis Cressman
"Everytime I visit Watkins Glenn I always start my day at Oak Leaf Cafe. The food and coffee is absolutely exquisite. A must have. I always feel like..."
Justin Conner
"Had Buffalo Chicken wrap. It's very good. Not too spicy, yet there's enough spicy there so the sandwich is not..."
Laurie Mathews
"Great little grocery store and cafe. I frequently stop here when in the area. Normally it's a great experience and I enjoy the Cafe immensely. This..."
John Butler
"It was definitely worth the try,the service and food were really good. Will be going back again..."
Zak Keller
"I have had trouble with gift cards for a couple years there but food and service is very..."
Donna Vozenilek
"Maybe one of my favourite spots to eat in the Finger Lakes area. If I could I would fly up every morning( home is Austin) to grab a freshly made..."
taylor franklin
"I LOVE it here :) Best coffee in town. The girls are lovely. They are polite, knowledgeable and work really hard! It's always clean and..."
Bev Cummings
"A very quaint cafe and bake shop with a very not so quaint , quite amazing grocery store attached. Food at the cafe was great. Staff were..."
Erik Stoneham
"Came all the way to Seneca from Cambridge UK for a holiday, and I'd definitely come back. Good food, good price and great..."
Geoffrey Smith
"Very clean place with friendly staff and good..."
Brittany
"I was surprised, I expected the usual country store fare, farmer style. When I walked in, it reminded me of a high end sandwich shop like one would..."
Buddy Chasteen
"Delicious food. Ham & potatoe chowder is so good. Chicken salad sandwich was perfection. Enjoyed the store. Bought alot of goodies. Going to get back..."
Marlene Greenall
"We occasionally come to Oak Leaf and order from the menu….. they have a short menu, but it’s the right amount to choose from. I love their..."
Cheryl Ambrosone
"My wife, daughter and I dined in with picky snacks from general store and a fry pie from the bakery, which was the BEST baked good I have ever had...."
John Coppa
Timmy G's
83/100 (591 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Pasta
Salad
Mac and cheese
Salmon
Lasagne
Sandwiches
Burger
Shrimp
Beef
"Excellent dinner - meatloaf dinner with garlic mashed potatoes & French chit pork chop with melted cheddar-jack cheese with garlic mashed potatoes ..."
Sue Porubek
"One of the best crab cake sandwiches I've ever had, at an unbeatable price. The entire menu is incredibly priced, with plenty of options. The staff..."
Kyle Sanson
"Expected better as the prime rib dinner didappointing. Very fatty and chewy and tough. Garlic mashed luke warm, salad sad. Other meal was Chicken..."
Cheryl Rogers
"Got the bacon burger and fries. So delicious! My burger was cooked to my specifications and the staff is really nice and friendly! Would highly..."
Ashley B.
"The other local places I normally go when passing through were closed, but I was parked here already and saw lots of people going in, so I did as..."
Karen Lee Marzak
"Nice place for lunch. Food well prepared and hot. Coffee is fresh. My favorite is the potato soup, and they have a tasty assortment of sandwiches..."
Stephen Hartman
"Great food & Great service. Quiet atmosphere and relaxing! We were impressed with the menu and could not decide on our dinner because there were so..."
Travel Gypsy
"Valentine's Day lunch date with the hubby. Beautiful atmosphere. Fantastic food. Even heard out of towners behind us raving that "whoever's in the..."
Karen Wagar
"It was very busy when we showed up, and we had to wait a few minutes for a table, but it was worth it for the food in Penn Yan. Our salads were..."
Allison Kirsch
"Great food and attentive service! From starters to dessert you won’t be disappointed. Highly recommend the tomato gouda soup, Cobb salad, Philly..."
Kelly Hamula
"Today is my birthday, the cook,who spent many nights sry my house with my older boy....you made my birthday special, thank you so much for all 3 that..."
Lena Bean
"Best steaks and prime rib in town. Friendly efficient staff. Tim the owner is very friendly and helpful. There specials on the menu are a surprise..."
Karen Rasmussen
"Best meal I have had in forever! Had the Chicken French and my son had the Seafood Macaroni and Cheese. Both were phenomenal! Really loved it, not to..."
Candice M
"The Cobb salad is great, daily quiche specials, prime rib, local wines, great service. Something for everyone on the menu - even for the kids! They..."
Jennifer Clancy
"Nice variety of food choices at good prices. Great service. Was with a party of six and all of us thoroughly enjoyed the food. We all agreed we would..."
Michelle Sanney
"Great place! The food was awesome and the staff was very friendly and accommodating. The cocktails were spot on as well. Would definitely recommend,..."
FireflyFarm,LLC
Tavern Restaurant
82/100 (1066 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
American
American
Bar
Pub
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Shrimp
Salad
Wings
Sandwiches
Burger
Sit down
Bar
Pub
American
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Full Bar
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Stopped in for lunch while my dad was at the dentist. Great selection of beers, nice variety of food across the menu. Cozy family atmosphere and..."
Diana Wright
"The Tavern was a nice break from the breweries in the area. Offered your genuine bar vibes and activities which I enjoyed while I drank. Offers two..."
Matthew Cotter
"Stopped here on our way back to Buffalo from Watkins Glen. Food ordered was a burger and a ham and cheese sandwich. The food was very good. And they..."
Michael Bordonaro
"Decent drafts, good food, reasonable prices. The cheesy bread that comes with the salad is excellent. I’d definitely..."
Steve W
"Great food and service. Just a neighborhood bar We go there often after..."
Patrick Grimaldi
"Great local place. I had a grilled chicken cordon bleu sandwich that was delicious. Other patrons were..."
Paul Schieb
"The Tavern is my favorite place to go for lunch or dinner! The atmosphere is fun, the music is the perfect volume, the staff are always attentive and..."
Brittany Moore
"We like going here. The food is better than most bar food. They have a separate dining area from the..."
KC Corbitt
"The Chicken Pesto sandwich with red pepper and spinach is my ultimate fav here, it tastes like it was grilled outdoors! The homemade fries taste like..."
Rebecca FA
"James is an extraordinary cook! Big time customer service! Thank you..."
Mike Whyte
"Lively place, mostly bar type menu, very inexpensive but good portions. Juke box, billiards, fast table service. True modern day..."
Robert Lustbader
"Great beer selection! The food was ok bar food. The girls behind the bar were friendly. Love this "locals" bar. They made you feel..."
Sharon Nassar
"The best restaurant in town & great..."
Charlie Mercado
"Great spot for one of the best burgers I've had in a..."
Steve Bell
"Did not eat but a fun local bar. The people were..."
Dave Bacon
"Good..."
Rubi Bravo
"We went there randomly and were really pleased by the food and service. Everything is very authentic, this place totally deserve a visit ! Special..."
serge D'Haeyere
"Great food atmosphere was..."
David Perry
Keuka Restaurant
81/100 (1992 ratings)
Restaurants
Pub
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Bar
Pub
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Haddock
Bacon Cheddar Fries
Crab Legs
Ribs
Shrimp
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Shrimp Fajitas
Little Neck Clams
Chicken Sandwich
Lobster
The Keuka Burger
French onion soup
Pasta
Single Order Wings Medium
Cakes
Salad
Bluff Point Smoked Brisket Sandwich
Pesto
Wings
Concord Grape Salad
Fish
Mac and cheese
Crab
Southwest Steak Salad
Pork
Scallops
Crooked Lake Quesadilla
Ribeye steak
Tuna
Sandwiches
Cold Brook Fish Sandwich
Onion Soup
Beer
Salmon
Burger
NY Strip with Onion Rings
Potato Skins
Disaronno Amaretto
Chicken Parmesan
Crab Cake
Reuben Sandwich
Sit down
American
Bar
Pub
Serves Alcohol
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Television
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Reservations
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"First of all, we love the restaurant and have been many times. The food is excellent! However, this review is for their catering service, which is..."
Doug Burr
"Arrived in town late in the evening, lucky to find an eatery open at that hour. Staff was friendly and attentive. Wide selection on menu. The pulled..."
Daniel Bechard
"Lobster bisque was delicious. Chicken fingers were nothing to write home about, fries were good but the pulled pork sandwich was huge and..."
Mary Krencik
"WOW!! We went here for dinner last night and couldn’t have asked for a better place to go! The service was fantastic and the dinner was..."
Tim Herriven
"Best Reuben sandwich ever and huge, and I asked for a large bowl of coleslaw which was wonderful. I paid with Visa, but they do offer a 4% discount..."
Edwin Presley
"I went here a couple nights on a row because I was visiting from out of town working at the nearby power plant. I had a great time here. The food is..."
Mike O
"Ate here two years in a row while in town on vacation. First year had takeout, second year ate in person. Both experiences solid and everyone was..."
Matthew Hiserodt
"I went 2 nights in a row and everything was excellent! The service, the food, the drinks... I highly recommend! I had the French onion soup, the..."
Laura Grimme
"Great place to get a higher class meal in Pennyan! I had the salmon with horse radish sauce.😋🤤🤤Perfect combination of fish and horse radish...."
Jesse Hoover
"The lobster bisque was fantastic! Great, quick service. Our waitress was extremely..."
Roy G Biv
"I have to give five stars all around. There are not many places offering all you can eat crab legs. My friend and I each had the crab legs, and they..."
Vince Tersegno
"I genuinely cannot remember ever having a bad experience here. I always order the same thing, and it's always fantastic! This is one of the few..."
Benjamin Simpson
"Great meal! One of the best I've had in a while! Our server was excellent as well. We will definitely be..."
Nikki Lee
"First time here and we were very happy. It was Labor day and they were a bit busy. The staff was great! Food was very good. Got the Reuben sandwich..."
Sue Bills
"The prime rib was amazing and they piece was Definitely bigger than the 22oz I ordered so that’s a big win on my end, and the storm chips intrigued..."
Joshua Kobielski
"We had modest expectations going in as we were traveling and had to grab a bite to eat on the road. The atmosphere was like a good hometown..."
Kenneth Pace
Top Of The Lake
80/100 (1015 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Bar
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Shrimp
Alfredo
Beef
Meatballs
Lasagne
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Scallops
Calamari
Calamares
Salmon
Sandwiches
Cheeseburger
Burger
Chowder
Filet Mignon
"Its been a long time coming for Penn Yan but we are on the rise for "the place" to go for exceptional dining and the Main Deck is another "feather in..."
Chad Peek
"We have been there twice and we enjoyed it both times. The general manager Brad, manager Will and bartender Ryan were welcoming and friendly. The..."
Brenda Pugliese
"Beautiful day to have the option of sitting outside. Nice selection of local wines and microbrews. Service was great, food was good. Wife had Fish..."
Jim Ketcham
"Nice menu and very good food.Not gourmet but nice atmosphere with reasonable pricing. They do have a deck outside with view of the lake which is very..."
Scott Lewis
"We (group of 4) got there 15 minutes before afternoon kitchen closing but hostess greeted us warmly and seated us. Waitress was prompt and gave us..."
Glenn De
"We ate here (group of 8) the night before my wedding as a family celebration. Reservations were required, as there was a sign when we arrived for..."
Kayla Hodge
"We were invited to a soft opening. This place is fabulous. The service was awesome so friendly and capable. The food was great and so tasty. The..."
Al Troisi
"Beautiful views and great atmosphere at sunset. Nice selection of local wines by the glass. The salad was limp and sad, though. My conclusion: come..."
L Wilson
"Perfect spot to stay if you are going to a WVU 🏈 game. If not, avoid it on those weekends. Rooms were spacious with full fridges and comfortable..."
Sally & Keith Prather
"Drove up from Dryden and stopped for lunch yesterday and like most places they were short staffed. We sat on the deck and the waitstaff was..."
Charlie D
"My wife and I dined at Top of the Lake for dinner on July 3. First thing first - the food was fabulous, it was so good - (we both had the Caribbean..."
Brian Tomcik
"Service was 5 star... Prices were incredibly inexpensive... Million dollar view!!!... And lastly the food was..."
Andrew Hassell
"My honey and I were traveling through the area for business and stayed at the Hampton Inn next door to the Top of the Lake Restaurant. We had been..."
Linda Sawtell
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use