Sluurpy
Reset

There are 3 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Ice Cream in Penn Yan

There are 3 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Spotted Duck
96/100 (1305 ratings)
Dessert
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Full House
Ice Cream Sandwich with Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Cookie Monster
Dried Garlic
Frozen Custard
Ice Cream
Dairy Free Ice Cream
Ice Cream Flight
Pizza
Ice Cream Sampler
Affogato
Duck Egg Ice Cream
Flight of Custard
Monster Sundae
Flight of Four Different Custards
Custards Similar to Ice Cream
Frozen Custard Flight
12 Scoop Flight
Chocolate and Cookies and Cream
Chocolate Chip Cookie Blueberry Lavender
Duck
Custard Cone
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Very cute spot for frozen custard! Made with duck eggs and the ducks are on site. Lots of tables and available seating! They had dairy free options..."
Laura Potter
"Since gaining national fame (probably international at this point), there isn't much more I could personally add as a review that isn't already..."
Cassandra Elizabeth
"This was our first time at the Spotted Duck and it was so worth the drive. As a family of 6 we got two of the large Seneca flights so we could all..."
Erica Slater
"I think I have had ice cream in every state and abroad but this was unique, smooth, creamy and just plain delicious. Served 4 kinds in glass..."
lee c
"My family heard about this place from some friends, and we were in the area for other business. Very nice little spot off the highway with decent..."
John-David Rocha
"This place was quite an experience and totally was worth the 2 hour detour our trip from Boston to Niagara Falls. Their custard was fantastic. I was..."
Daniel Kraus
"A unique experience eatting custard made from Duck Eggs. Gave the custard a richer flavor and texture. We appericated the beautiful view, variety of..."
Alexandria Jones
"We waited in line for 45 mins on a Sunday afternoon but it was overall worth it. Because of the huge crowd, some flavors weren't available. The..."
Yupawadee Galasong
"A neat little ice cream shop off the road, and it's good. Some flavors really pop for me like the coffee, chocolate, and this blue on that they have...."
Dave Ruan
"Delicious custard! They have so many fun flavors that rotate seasonally. Many flavors are gluten free. I really love the flight options so you can..."
Alyson Collins
Seneca Farms Ice Cream
91/100 (2646 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Salad
Grilled Chicken Sandwich with Potato Wedges
Pumpkin Ice Cream Sundae
Soft Ice Cream Cone
Ice Cream
Cracked Egg
Fried Mushrooms
Hot Fudge Sundae
popcorn
Corn Fritters
Chicken tenders
Chicken Wings
Shrimp
Bacon Bleu Burger
Strawberry Cheesecake Sundaes
Custard Twist
Fried Chicken Dinner with Hush Puppies Macaroni and Cheese Mashed Potatoes and Gravy
Peach and Blueberry Flurru
Burger
Caramel Craze Sundaes
Philly Cheese Steak Less Onions and Pepper
Fish Sandwich N Mac N Cheese
Sit down
American
Drive Thru
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Delicious chicken!!! Very juicy meat, crunchy flavorful crust. Loved the corn fritters, too. Dinner was great. We must be spoiled in Wayne Co,..."
Meddy Jacques
"Best fried chicken in the area. Everything is fresh made and of high quality. You walk in and get the old nostalgic feeling. Ice cream is some of the..."
Buddy Chasteen
"A fun little place apparently known for their fried chicken and ice cream. They offer a small dining room with eat it or take out, they also have..."
Brad Golden
"We vacationed at the Finger Lakes in mid-October & were lucky enough to hit this place a few days before it closed for the season. We had read great..."
Kristine Crocker
"Great food and delicious ice cream. Very busy but worth the..."
Jo “Sweetjo”
"Always a good visit. Fried chicken and ice cream, what could go wrong? Fritters are a nice local ish..."
Josh Wright
"Great place to stop and grab some lunch or dinner ! Great selection of food way more then just chicken (chickens awesome tho) I love the fried claims..."
Robert Druker
"Love this place so much. Have been coming for years every summer to go through the drive through for ice cream. Just this year tried the fried..."
Bergen Nelson
"The sign says, "If the colonel knew what we know, he'd be a general." True words. First of all the kids (most under 25) running the place seemed to..."
Shawn Garman
"Awesome fried chicken, mac and cheese! So much h good food. Then go to the front for delicious homemade ice cream..try the Deer Tracks!!! Finish by..."
K OBR
"Ridiculously great fried chicken!! and other things too. The hotdogs snd burgers were great too but the chicken is top notch! The ice cream and..."
Marion NYC
"We are visiting the area and stopped in for ice cream. There were 10 of us and we all agreed the ice cream was good and the customer service was..."
Kelly Diss
"Cute icecream shop on our way back to our lake house. The icecream was awesome and the staff if very friendly. If we discovered this sooner, we would..."
Yvette Cordone
"Line out the door that went quickly, ice cream was..."
Mary Krencik
"Great ice cream. Wasn't crazy about the chicken. I was hoping it would be amazing but found it didn't have much flavor, and the white meat was very,..."
Steve Bell
"That's the best fried chicken I've had in a long, long time. The ice cream is very good too. The two halves are separated, with the dining in the..."
Don Barnes
"Delicious ice cream parlor. Highly recommend. Great service. The kids serving were friendly and quick to serve. There were many people there when we..."
Thomas Lederach
"Excellent ice cream. Awesome place,plenty of outdoor seating with coverings to keep off the sun. Very clean and very friendly staff. We'll definitely..."
Steve Bagnato (nissanlord)
Mac's Dairy Bar
83/100 (516 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Ice Cream
Sit down
Takeout
Wheelchair Accessible
Cheap Eats
"Fabulously rich Hershey’s ice cream. All the standard flavors plus wild concoctions like Banana Peanut Butter Moose tracks which is as yellow as..."
Josh Wright
"We love getting ice cream and playing putt putt at Mac's. If you're headed to Oak Hill, be sure to add Mac's as a stop. It's less than 5 min up the..."
Tai Jackson
"Great place to get ice cream or play miniature gulf! Plenty of sitting..."
Chris Roosa
"Their ice cream is always so divine and there are many options to choose from! I love how it's away from the town and more secluded with decent..."
Andi
"Mac's has Hershey ice cream, great selections. And a small but really quite fun mini..."
Steve Delahunty
"This is an amazing place! We enjoyed the Strawberry Dole Whip! Will definitely go back..."
Joe C.
"It was wonderful, a beautiful sitting area under the shade trees, staff is very sweet , and the ice cream is awesome, of..."
Glorianne Schuttler
"Hands down this is one of the most adorable ice cream shops you can go to. Where else can you see the Amish come by in a buggy while you're getting..."
Lisamarie
"Great hometown ice cream. The prices here are great. They only take cash. They do have an ATM on site in the ATM only charges a $1 fee which is..."
Caleb Bulriss
"Definitely a local favorite and the ice cream is very..."
David Perry
"Cash only but there are lots of options and the ice cream is..."
Addison Dodge
"The best ice cream in Yates Co. You get your money's worth..."
Colleen Riviello
"There are so many options for ice cream, sundaes, or even milk shakes. They only take..."
Mackenzie Dodge
"The pumpkin ice cream is outrageously delicious!! Tastes like very cold pumpkin pie on a cone. (My "4-legged child" loved it too! She is a..."
Renate Eichelberger
"I grew up going to Mac's ice cream. I visited recently and man has it changed on the outside. There is plenty of parking spots, picnic benches to sit..."
Rebecca Anderson
"Excellent place to stop for ice cream. We always stop when we are in the..."
John Reynolds
"Cool little place that had a ton of flavors and vegan options (dole). Right by the town and friendly..."
Matthew Moll
"Fun-shaped building? Got it. Ice cream for all tastes and diets (including vegan/dairy-free)? Got it. Play area for kids? Got it. Mini putt-putt?..."
A Place for Little Sprouts to Grow
"We really like their monthly custard flavors. Good outdoor seating. If you time it right you can watch the kids across the street playing games at..."
Rhonda Pennington
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use