Sluurpy
Reset

There are 3 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Breakfast Sandwich in Penn Yan

There are 3 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Flour Shop Cafe & Bakery
90/100 (317 ratings)
Bakeries
American
Cafe
Lunch
Breakfast
Salad
Breakfast Sandwich
"Friendly Staff. Great Food and Coffee. A Couple Tables outside, We sat..."
Joseph Rutkowski
"Stopped in on Monday and got a latte and a breakfast sandwich. Food and coffee were excellent, service was..."
776football
"Excellent, friendly service and fantastic food!! My wife and I had panini sandwiches: She had the tomato and mozzarella with pesto on ciabatta. I had..."
Randy Knapp
"Had the Greek breakfast wrap and it was awesome! My daughter was bummed that they didn't have any regular cinnamon rolls left until she realized that..."
Jennifer Clancy
"Friendly small-town atmosphere. Excellent bakery items. I highly recommend the cinnamon sugar donut muffins and the huge cinnamon buns with maple..."
Linda Berger
"There aren't enough positive adjectives to describe this cafe/bakery. The available baked goods rotate regularly, always giving you a new, fresh, and..."
Mark Detwiler
"This place is a little different with their sandwiches. In a very good way! I ordered a Turkey, cranberry mayonnaise club. It was delicious. I have..."
Joan Watson
"The cinnamon rolls on Saturday are to die for! Make sure you get there early, especially in the summer, or else they're gone. I wished they'd make..."
Manda Willette
"We always love this little cafe - a truly local business that takes good care of its customers. Great coffee, great sandwiches, and the best..."
Brian Shoemaker
"The Flour Shop make my wedding cake and cupcakes for our wedding. The cake (chocolate with vanilla cream cheese frosting) was the best cake I've ever..."
Jeanine Almon
The Olney Place
87/100 (609 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Breakfast Sandwich
Sit down
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Waterfront
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Great food and a little bit of everything . Staff is delightful . Easy in and out for boat fuel..."
Tia Bliss
"Great grocery, deli, and taphouse. In the back there is a bar area with a great selection of beers, with beautiful views of Keuka lake and Tvs to..."
Kapil Bhanot
"Great spot. Whole crew stopped by to grab some sandos. Heard from another guy this was the happening spot. Well, I got the Mustang and I'm here to..."
Roadblock Thompson
"We docked and got gas, then food at the Olney Place and we were delighted with both. The interior is very nice, with a good beer selection and a nice..."
Jacob Snavely
"Great spot to stop along Keuka Lake for a snack, a souvenir, a game of cornhole, a smile, or a souvenir tshirt. Nice vibe along the peaceful..."
Kevin Markman
"Sandwiches were absolutely delicious and exceeded expectations. Shop was quaint and service excellent with indoor and outdoor..."
Chris P
"I'm not sure how to categorize the Olney spot. Is it a convenience store with a bar? A general store? A deli with beer? It's hard to say. Thanks to a..."
Tyler Lund
"Our go to place on the lake for breakfast. The sticky buns and breakfast sandwiches are a staple and a must have. Very friendly and nice staff. Some..."
B.D P
"Lovely view of Keuka Lake! This store had the best potato salad EVER which was being handmade by the owner Seth when we walked in. Friendly staff,..."
Robert Faith
"This place is awesome beyond description. The food selections are good and healthy. The staffs are very welcoming and friendly towards the guests. I..."
Aji Maimaiti
"Great spot for sandwiches, souvenirs, groceries, and..."
Nick Paladino
"Came to Keuka for my birthday, as always. Decided to stop in (first time ever) for some coffee. They made me a homemade breakfast sandwich on Gluten..."
Karen Lee Marzak
"Always our favorite spot to visit every year. Consistently great food and amazing service. The owner Seth Olney knows what seems like everyone who..."
Matt Wilkins
"The first thing we do when we get to the lake is stop at the Olney place for sandwiches. We always get the Rachel aka the Turkey Reuben. Seth is..."
Zach Corum
"It’s the Olney place you need to go! It advertises as a grocery store but it’s oh so much more! The beer tap room in the back, best egg..."
EJ Plimley
"Easy to spot from the road but if you're going the speed limit you'll drive right buy it. This is my go-to place to get the best sandwiches on Keuka..."
Richard Yhip
"Craft beer, general store, great sandwiches and wraps and more. I ordered the Rachel sandwich and it was the best sandwich I've ever had, washed down..."
Andrew Little
"Exceptional service, beer selection and great sandwiches, quick and inexpensive. A great view over looking Keuka Lake on their deck. Perfect stop by..."
William Lagasse
"Best customer service on the lake! My family had to throw together an impromptu party and I reached out to Olney Place for some help. They put..."
Brian Young
Penn Yan Diner
83/100 (1223 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
American
Diner
Vegetarian Friendly
Diner
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Lunch
Brunch
Cakes
Burrito
Eggs Benedict
French Toast
Toasts
Burger
Omelette
Breakfast Sandwich
Corned Beef
Waffles
Waffles & Crepes
Pancakes
Biscuits and gravy
Sit down
American
Diner
Seating
Table Service
Highchairs Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"What a great find!! Beautiful homey little Diner right in the Village, with great food and most likely the best Eggs Benedict I have ever had!! The..."
Gary Rosbrook
"We had the breakfast sandwich with home fries - real potatoes, not frozen. Breakfast was great. Coffee was very good. Excellent service and a great..."
Catherine Joseph
"Sunday 12/17/23 What a charming place! We ate at the bar and watched our meal being made. Everyone was smiling and so pleasant. Our breakfast..."
Rebecca Caudle
"Super cute for a 98 year old diner! Their omelets were good. Very cozy and antique..."
Veronica Kelly
"All the dishes we had were outstanding! The server was attentive as well. It's a retro diner as advertised and I thought it was well done and..."
Michael Schipani
"Got the Banana Crunch French Toast, food and service was excellent. There was a debate among the locals on what was better The Diner or The Wagner..."
Leigh Everett
"A small diner with terrific food, service and old time feel! We sat at the counter and had a Birds Eye view of the cooks! They do an amazing job in..."
Tim Herriven
"Great food, and super friendly staff. Well worth the stop. The only downside is that this place is SMALL. A lot of side stepping and squeezing..."
Jason B
"Such a cute place! Worth the experience and history! Food was delicious and service was good! Place is a bit crowded feeling because it's small but..."
Ashley B.
"A wonderful bit of old fashioned Americana right smack in the middle of the computer age! It was Sunday morning, we went in, they took my cell number..."
Mike Stoebe
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use