Review Keuka Restaurant

Doug Burr

First of all, we love the restaurant and have been many times. The food is excellent! However, this review is for their catering service, which is ALSO excellent! The pic is one of our table setting for a special event. The food was superb. That's the main reason we went with them for our event. We knew the food would be top notch. The price was better than we thought it would be. The service was above and beyond- to the point of leaving after delivery to get a last minute change by us and bring it back. Wow! They had everything covered and took a lot of worry off our "plate" for the evening. We cannot more highly recommend this place for your event. You won't be sorry.

Daniel Bechard

Arrived in town late in the evening, lucky to find an eatery open at that hour. Staff was friendly and attentive. Wide selection on menu. The pulled pork sandwich was a monster! Delicious.

Mary Krencik

Lobster bisque was delicious. Chicken fingers were nothing to write home about, fries were good but the pulled pork sandwich was huge and delicious!

Tim Herriven

WOW!! We went here for dinner last night and couldn’t have asked for a better place to go! The service was fantastic and the dinner was delicious! I had the Keuka burger and it was delicious. Cooked to the way I ordered it and had onion rings with it! Hard to find good onion rings and these were perfect! We started dinner with potato skins and those were fresh and delicious as well! The portion size was very good too! I would eat her again in a heartbeat! Thank you for the great experience!

Edwin Presley

Best Reuben sandwich ever and huge, and I asked for a large bowl of coleslaw which was wonderful. I paid with Visa, but they do offer a 4% discount for cash. I will definitely recommend this place to others and have already

Mike O

I went here a couple nights on a row because I was visiting from out of town working at the nearby power plant. I had a great time here. The food is really awesome and I like all the servers. This is the first place I've ever been to that actually has "all you can eat crab legs"... Usually places say this and are stingy about them. Here they brought me two more plates after I said I was good. I ate crab legs until I felt like I was going to die. 🤤😁 I highly recommend this place. I would be a regular here if I lived here. Thanks.

Matthew Hiserodt

Ate here two years in a row while in town on vacation. First year had takeout, second year ate in person. Both experiences solid and everyone was happy with their food which is tough with a large extended family of some picky eaters. I personally had the brisket sandwich which was huge and a nice blend of flavors. Son had a salad which looked awesome. Big kids meal portions as well. Bar area looks welcoming. Overall a good place for a meal.

Laura Grimme

I went 2 nights in a row and everything was excellent! The service, the food, the drinks... I highly recommend! I had the French onion soup, the steak with the balsamic crust and blue cheese baked on top, and mini desserts the 1st night. The second night I had the BBQ wings, the Shrimp in a creamy Alfredo type sauce, and the mini desserts. So good!!!!

Jesse Hoover

Great place to get a higher class meal in Pennyan! I had the salmon with horse radish sauce.😋🤤🤤Perfect combination of fish and horse radish. Not to hot for any but the weakest palate!

Roy G Biv

The lobster bisque was fantastic! Great, quick service. Our waitress was extremely attentive.

Vince Tersegno

I have to give five stars all around. There are not many places offering all you can eat crab legs. My friend and I each had the crab legs, and they were sooo sweet tasting! We had a very nice waitress. She made us feel at home.

Benjamin Simpson

I genuinely cannot remember ever having a bad experience here. I always order the same thing, and it's always fantastic! This is one of the few places I have gone that will send out a truly rare steak when ordered that way. They also have the best sauce for their clams of any local joint. Staff, service, atmosphere, food, and cleanliness are always spot on.

Nikki Lee

Great meal! One of the best I've had in a while! Our server was excellent as well. We will definitely be back!

Sue Bills

First time here and we were very happy. It was Labor day and they were a bit busy. The staff was great! Food was very good. Got the Reuben sandwich and it was the size of almost 2!!

Joshua Kobielski

The prime rib was amazing and they piece was Definitely bigger than the 22oz I ordered so that’s a big win on my end, and the storm chips intrigued me so I ordered them OMG I am for sure getting them as an appetizer next time I go. Also had French onion au gratin which was very good.

Kenneth Pace

We had modest expectations going in as we were traveling and had to grab a bite to eat on the road. The atmosphere was like a good hometown place. The servers were attentive and very pleasant. We were delightfully rewarded with some very very good food. I started off with an Irish coffee that had a little kick to it. My entree was the Fish Fry. Tasty and a great portion. The cole slaw was good as well. My wife had the shrimp scampi. We have had many shrimp scampi on the road and have been disappointed over and over again. Not here.. Not this time. The shrimp were freshly prepared and tender. The pasta cooked to near perfection. And the sauce had just enough balance of garlic, butter, wine, and with a hint of lemon to delight these diners. Also the sauce adhered to the pasta with just the right consistency. It wasn't too sticky nor too thin. Highly recommended Thanks for a wonderful meal that capped a good day of exploring the area around Penn Yan.

Review Keuka Restaurant - Penn Yan