Teresa's Brick Oven Pizza & Cafe

Realized how much I missed this place when I recently stopped here for a slice and a Grilled Chicken Italiano Sandwich. Their sandwiches are absolutely amazing and I have always had a very positive experience. I really hope they continue to stick around after COVID because my lunches would not be the same without them. The best part is that they are more than willing to customize the sandwich without any fuss. Love this place so much!

Teresa’s has the best vegetarian pizza. When I last visited NYC, I remember it was raining a lot so we stopped by Teresa for some food and stay dry. The staff was very friendly and kind and had some good recommendations. The pizza was fresh and delicious. We will definitely make a stop by Teresa’s again on our next visit- rain or no rain!

Has to be the best pizza we had while in NY and we had a LOT!!! Staff are spot on, they clearly get a lot of tourist, so are really great in helping you on how the ordering is done etc. The seating area is small, but like most Pizza/Deli places, the majority take out, so seats do become free. Great value for Money as well, and as a Brition, not use the the real American slice, one proved to be more than enough! Would recommend this place to any friend or family member visiting, extremely welcoming to all, and a fantastic choice of pizza, cakes, etc

Not too shabby. Great location. Everyone was friendly. Wondered into this place for a quick slice of pizza for lunch while sightseeing in The Big Apple. Service was quick. Seating is extremely extremely limited otherwise you gotta stand and eat. Pizza was yummy. Bottled and canned drinks. No more expensive than every other place in NYC. Variety of pizza as well as deli sandwiches.

What an awesome and unassuming find. We were hankering for some quality NYC pizza and walked around aimlessly trying to find something authentic. I saw some reviews and made a B line to Teresas. On entering I knew this would be good. It's old school American Italian with decor that hasn't been updated for years but a hustle to let you know you have hit across a hidden secret. There is a large array of Pizzas on the left, simply choose whatever flavour takes your fancy and it will be heated on the spot, take the ticket to the register and pay. They will call out when your slices are ready straight from the oven. This is no fuss and to the point service but boy oh boy did I love the pizzas. The base was delicious with just the right crispness and crunch. The toppings are on point, not overloaded and not too skimpy and everything tastes oh so good. Seating is limited so be prepared to get in and out or eat at the stand up bar by the window.

I was here for a quick lunch and discovered and actually very good pizza. The crust is very good and there's a good choice of toppings. Not much of seating inside but the hot pizza from the stone oven is well worth the wait during the hectic lunch time. You make an order, then go pay, then go back and show your receipt to get you order. Easy.