Sammys

We are headed to the seafood festival and were reminded of our wonderful experience last May during the annual music festival. The drinks and beer taps are tops, but we were hungry too! Unquestionably, the best fish and chips ever! Need I say more? Obviously, after partaking of the seafood fare at the fest, we will have to revisit Sammy’s on our next trek to Montauk. This place is a standout in the area. Updated August 2023. Place is empty at 530pm for dinner! Table of 6. On porch. The fish and chips were below par. Halibut fresh. Disappointed. Better options from here on in.

My husband and I reached out to Sammy's to host our 25 person wedding and could not be happier with our experience. Sammy's was so easy to coordinate our date, time, and menu with. On the day of our event Sam, Ginger, and Jamie were all so attentive to our needs and kind to us, our guests, & their children. They took the time to set up the private room for us with nice flowers, printed menus, and the perfect table layout. The food was outstanding with generous portions and fresh ingredients. We ordered a lot of food and everything was served hot and timely. Many of our guests returned to Sammy's throughout the weekend for lunch and dinner. We will definitely be returning to Sammy's everytime that we are in Montauk.

This review is for Sammy’s to Go (the food truck). Amazing place to get reasonably priced delicious takeout breakfast or lunch. And… you can sit on the beach and eat it! I can only speak about the fish tacos (I ordered 2 and they were delicious), and the fried flounder sandwich came on a toasted potato bun with delicious tartar sauce on the side. Perfect breading. Great quick lunch with a view! :)

Absolute - Hands-Down Best Restaurant in Town. THE FOOD IS OUTSTANDING. If you truly want the "Montauk" experience, than Sammy's is a "Must." Sammy is a local and so is the staff. His mom the Montauk School Kindergarten teacher for years. (Mine Too) The best kept secret in town - where the locals go to eat.