Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Milwaukee

williang503

T A

Gary Schabel

Eddie Thomas

Cranky Al's Bakery

88/100 (1639 ratings)

"I took the family here because I read all the great reviews online, and who doesn't love pizza?? So we ordered, and the food had come. Between..."

Nick Robinson

"I came for the gluten friendly donuts. I haven't had a donut since going GF a year ago. I did pre-order them and when I got there, they were being..."

Malea Lynn

"I love Cranky Al’s. It’s my happy place. Great donuts and the best coffee. And the counter people are not cranky..."

Jody Olinger

"GF donuts are the best! I drive in from Germantown just to be able to have a fresh GF donut and then I bring some home because they freeze well...."

Mary Warren

"Great bakery and hot breakfasts. Personally, I'd lose the honey wheat tortilla for the breakfast burrito, as it smells like the overpowering maple..."

Richard Shupe

"We moved into the neighborhood a few years ago and Cranky's quickly became our go-to family spot for Friday fish fries and whenever we need a donut..."

Jennifer Lynn

"Doughnuts were great, waffle bites were good and the breakfast pizza was amazing. Cute place for a..."

Zha-Tsee Kiatoukaysy

"Being chicagoans we know pizza and this was good pizza! Easy parking, super friendly staff and the pizza and donuts were..."

Lisa Batcheller

"It was a very busy morning at the store but the staff acted like I was their only customer as I picked up donuts for my coworkers! Great staff and of..."

Lisa Stoel Carstensen

"Always yummy. Excellent Sunday morning incentive for good behavior in Church. Excellent pricing. Friendly, "salt of the earth" service. Go here,..."

Evalyn Martin

"This was our first time visiting Cranky Al's and we were very pleased. We'll be back again. It was well worth the..."

Patty Mackey

"Love this place! What kids are picky about donuts? Well, mine are and this is the only place they want them from. :) Love the pizza also. Great..."

Tracie Marks

"Cranky al's is the BEST donut shop ever! So yummy, great service and the pizza in the evening is good..."

Jami Markov

"Thanks for the tip on reheating pizza! I just enjoyed tasty leftovers with a crispy..."

Marcia Clifford

"I rented an Airbnb a few doors down from Al's. They recommended I get to Al's before 8 am. I was there before 7 and there were 3 people in front of..."

Jenny Infosino

"I have had Cranky Al donuts, but this was the first trip to the actual store. Nice folks with a excellent selection of donuts. Each of the donuts..."

Scott W

"This place has my heart. Breakfast pizza is one of my favorite foods in the world and it is so hard to find, but they have it and theirs is divine...."

Catrina Gilbert

"Visited on a busy Saturday morning. Despite the long line it moved fast. Got classic donuts and they were delicious! (Cake, crueller, raised). This..."

Chelsea Wuth

"This is such a great place to get some interesting donuts. The variety is quite fantastic with an array of toppings and fillings that will give you..."

Nicholas Hoppenrath

"Where do I start?! We had Cranky's donuts at our wedding and they were one of the biggest hits that day. Joey was so cool and easy to communicate..."

Alexa Archer

"Our wedding donuts were a huge hit, offering a fresh and varied selection of flavors that pleased all our guests. Joey's exceptional service and..."

Amanda Lavin

"Best breakfast burritos in town! The breakfast pizza is really good too. Usually go with the bigger size pizza since I prefer that style thin crust...."

Josh O

"Cranky Al’s was our dessert choice for our wedding and WOW, they did not disappoint! We started with a quick meeting with Joey where he asked about..."

Brian & Kaylee Jordan

"These doughnuts are so good! They exceeded our expectations and gave a whole new meaning to classy doughnuts. The buttercream filling is so much..."

Kacie Molina

Classic Slice

88/100 (2375 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Gift Cards Available

Free off-street parking

"I'm sure Classic Slice could make a lovely Avocado Salad. But I will never know. I'm here for the pizza. It's decidedly New York style, either by..."

Tim M

"By the slice but made to order. Kinda reminded me of DC jumbo slices but they're not quite as big. I got the Detroit style, which was delicious and..."

Noe Valenzuela

"Very helpful staff and very tasty pizzas. The slices are huge. Clientele is diverse. Great introduction to..."

Mayra Rodriguez Valladares

"Loved this pizza! The lady at the counter was so friendly and helpful! And she had great recommendations for what to..."

J Larwig

"This pizza is one of the best in Milwaukee. I eat here weekly. The large slice has been inconsistent lately (in the last month) which is curious...."

Todd Moro

"Absolutely delicious! I took my kids here for lunch! We had so much food left over, it was great for later on! I spent a little over $38 but well..."

Desiree La Belle

"Pizza was SO SO good!! Smelled great, tasted great and was our first Milwaukee pizza. Yum yum for..."

Denise Johns

"We have a vegan, vegetarian, and gluten free person with us and there are options for all! I enjoyed the vegan scardinia a new..."

Gina Devecchis

"Giant slice NY style made to order, not sitting under a heat lamp. Good flavor, just a bit more than bland. However the crust was awesome, crisp and..."

Scott Wergin

"I'm from out of town and was craving pizza. Of all the suggested places, this place caught my eye because of the New York style crusts (thin). Im by..."

Mike C

Di Stefano's Pizza Palace

"Awesome pizza! We get the Tuesday special all the time. Everything is nice and fresh. The sauce is spectacular. They use lots of cheese. Only place..."

Karyn Lemke Holzman

"The best pizza on this planet. We've been ordering for over 20 years. Anywhere else we ever have pizza is always compared to di stefanos. No one in..."

Papaw Tom

"Our new favorite pizza! Ordered a 16" pizza with bosco sticks and we finished maybe half the pizza. Lovely family-owned joint. So much delicious..."

Maureen Brock

"Awesome pizza. I'm not a vegetarian but the Sicilian Garden pizza is amazing. Everything tasted so fresh. I had to stop myself from eating the whole..."

Sarah Kachellek

"Just had the Calzone, cheese, sausage, mushrooms & onions, & it was delicious. Have loved their Stuffed pizza in the past & was informed when I..."

Sue Kuehn

"I love this place! It's our go to for pizza! I love that it's family owned and..."

Anna 'Schmidt' Bughman

"Very tasty tasty Pizza !! I had the Deluxe and i certainly will be back again..."

John Agnello

"The BEST pizza in..."

Amy Wisniewski

"The greatest..."

Dick Oas

"Cozy little, no frills, south side Milwaukee pizza joint. Takeout only, the inside feels nostalgic and reminiscent of old school pizza places with..."

Jacob D

"It was good, I have been living in the area and decided to give them a try! It was very good! I enjoyed the spaghetti and the pizza was an 18 in and..."

Desiree La Belle

"First time trying the thin crust and all i gotta say is ive found my new favorite pizza in Milwaukee. Been here for 8yrs now and usually only order..."

Glenn Wojda

"Live in the immediate area and never tried this little gem, probably because of Maria's. I'm glad I ordered here ,the pizza tastes fresh and has a..."

Robert Evangelista

"I stumbled upon this place a few years ago when we had moved to the area and were looking for good local pizza. We ordered for delivery and the order..."

Sara Kircher

"Omg! The secret is in the crust. They nailed it! My mom and I can never agree on the crust when it comes to pizza. She loves deep dish and I love..."

Phayao Lem

"We are regulars at this place! Always great pizza and great service! This most recent time we ordered, we needed a pizza for a gathering that was..."

Dan P

"Solid local family pizza joint. Great amount of toppings and crispy crust. I will never understand why somebody would choose a chain over this,..."

W

"We specifically asked our neighbors on the Next Door app who they recommended for calzones. Real calzones, baked, not fried. This place came highly..."

Sean & Tracy Flynn

"Wowza. I love this pizza. I had the 14" deluxe thin crust. Gooey cheese, high quality ingredients, crust with just the right amount of crisp and..."

DB PC

"I'm an Italian from NY, so we know our pizza. There's nothing like NY pizza, but Milwaukee... this is as close as it gets! I've been a loyal..."

Jeff D'Agostino

"Cannot believe I haven’t been here before. Moved into the neighborhood 2 years ago and had my first calzone tonight. Huge portion, fresh..."

adam schmidt

"Best pizza in all of Milwaukee, and I don't say that lightly. I highly recommend what they used to call the Milwaukee Pizza, which is sausage,..."

Laura Vanderbilt

"This place is great. Pizza is delicious; fresh toppings, amazing thin & chewy crust, with a bright sauce. Eat local and..."

Katherine Hurley

"Don't know why I waited so long to try it. Ordered calzones and a sandwich for the family and it was all amazing. Will be ordering again for..."

Andrew Collins

"My wife and I believe in supporting local, family-owned businesses and as others have noted, this is a gem in the Jackson Park area. Having..."

John Thiele

"5 stars because I have not had pizza this good in a while. Had the Supreme and Hawaiian. Abundant sauce, quality ingredients and crispy crust. If the..."

Daniel Klosinski

Pizzeria Scotty

88/100 (1260 ratings)

Free off-street parking

Wheelchair Accessible

Lunch

Dinner

Cheap Eats

"Our friend Chris was over and we wanted pizza. He recommend this place so we ordered for carry out. It was extremely busy we had to wait for at least..."

Kristy M. Phelps

"Pizzeria Scotty is without a doubt the best pizza I have ever had. What makes it even better is the friendly professional service you get when you go..."

David Wieting

"Scottie’s has been a part of my family for as long as I can remember. We use it to celebrate life events and even to just bring us all to the table..."

Niki Skaer

"We always have great food and service, and we always know to order way ahead because there WILL be a long wait for delivery, because the pizza is so..."

Jill Krause Kirchner

"My daughter and I love their pizza and lasagna! They are always very polite and seem like they genuinely care about the service their customers..."

Cassie Anne

"By far the best thin and double dough pizzas in town! The staff are wonderful and make sure your orders is always what you ordered! I highly..."

Angel Salmeron Dueñas

"I am from Chicago and am a pizza junkie...have tried so many pizzas in this area and Milwaukee, there are is no better pizza in this area. Hands down..."

Aaron Hammock

"We've been ordering food from here for years and are never disappointed. The traditional topping pizzas are always a hit but the more I try their..."

Katy J. Schroeder

"Best pizza around! Great pizza and great customer..."

Kathryn Elizabeth Avilés

"We order all the time. Absolutely love the food and staff. We live across the street!!..."

Wenesdee Lyn

"I got the thin crust chicken bacon ranch pizza, which was delicious! I, however, was not impressed with the Chicago pan pizza at all. Not a lot of..."

Melissa Ostrowski

"Some of the best pizza in town. I was a little disappointed though that my pizza wasn't ready when the system said it would be which I understand..."

Jeff B

"Italian beef was tasty! The menu offers a later of ricotta on the lasagna for an up charge. Get the ricotta. You'd think it would come automatically..."

Kira Hagquist

"I've always heard how good the pizza was here but never had a chance to have it we decided they have it for our rehearsal dinner the night before our..."

William Low

"Finally tried this locally owned pizza place a friend recommend and am glad I did. Everything looked good and the most delicious smells filled the..."

Justin Provance

"Hello!! Not only is this my FAVORITE PIZZA PLACE!! Best Pizza in Townnnn by far!!! But they also treat customers with the up most respect:) When I..."

Jamie Wojczak

"Delicious food, and plenty of it for the price. The fried breadsticks are top tier, and the staff is friendly. The place is quite small inside, so..."

K Greenawald

"My favorite pizza joint in West Allis bar none. The pizza hear has a fantastic sauce and the people are great. Really enjoy..."

Kyle McHugh

"Tremendous pizza and attentive service. So glad I tried this pizzeria. Prices and wait times may be higher than average, but the quality of the pizza..."

Charles Mahoney

"Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Delivery can be slow sometimes so you have to plan ahead. When I've picked up, the guys are always super..."

Jennifer Mansavage

"Was my first time eating here a few days ago. Absolutely LOVED it. I ordered a veggie pizza it was delicious fresh & hot. The service was awesome. I..."

Tiffany Moore

"We have ordered pizzas for take out a couple of times now and Pizzeria Scotty has jumped to the top of our families favorite pizzeria. The food is..."

John Tice

"Best pie I've ever had, The Scott special is great, order a stuffed pizza with pep, green pepper , mushrooms and onions, its addictive I can't get..."

Steven valentin

"This pizza is awesome! Def will be back. Featured here is a stuffed meat lovers with mushrooms! The sauce is a mix between sweet and savory, really..."

Valencia Brown

"I've been eating here for a while now and it's the first time I got the stuffed pizza and this was amazing the cheese piled up and the pepperoni hade..."

Lisa Mitchell

"Some of the best pizza I've ever had. Deep dish is amazing, and their hours are even better. Being open till 11 pm is incredible on my schedule at..."

Owen

Balistreri's Italian-american Ristorante

87/100 (2792 ratings)

"Easily the best pizza in town. Staff is awesome. Worth the wait if you go during busy times. I like to order the pizza a little extra done/crispy ...."

Kyle GT

"Be prepared to wait over an hour when they are busy. We were there on a Friday night. Our waiter was good at setting our expectations of the wait. He..."

Denise Cole

"It was my first visit, and I couldn't say enough about the holiday decor. It was absolutely beautiful. Oh, and the pizza was delicious also..."

Kim R

"We order the large pizza and it was huge. It came out on a pan that must have been close to 14"x20" or 14"x24". The crust on the edge is like cracker..."

Natalie Cook

"Overall the food was good but it was a bit crowded inside. For the food, we ordered the large pizza and it’s huge. Such a good deal. It was the..."

Faith F

"Perfect place to get pizza for carry-out! Lots of cheese and the crust is nice and thin as well! Really enjoyed these and their large pizzas are big..."

Chelsie Tamms

"Went at about 2pm did was fantastic! Chicken dumpling was tasty and pizza was fresh! Ordered a pizza for take out. Was told it would be a 30-35..."

tee ols

"The atmosphere is "old Italian", reminiscent of the mobster movies. We were a table of 4, no wait at 4pm on a Saturday but the dining room quickly..."

Kimber Kaya

"I strongly recommend this restaurant if you want a traditional Italian old school restaurant. IT’s everything I knew growing up. The eggplant fries..."

Melissa Malone

"Can't beat this place! Been a fixture for many years. Love the small vibrant atmosphere. And decked out for the seasons!! Pizza is the bomb!! If you..."

John D'Amico

Divino's

"Great pizza, gluten free crust! Eggplant is to die for, best Tiramisu and the staff goes all out to treat you like your part of their..."

Jennifer Knauer Vogel

"Fabulous food, excellent pizza. We have NEVER had a bad meal. Excellent service. A family favorite. Even though we have moved to Grafton we make..."

Marilyn Linde

"This was my second time here and I was just amazed as the first. The food is incredible! The best Italian in town, in my opinion. And as full as I..."

Joan Marenda

"We love the pizza. The wine is fabulous the atmosphere is fun. We went last night and sat outside had a wonderful evening. Happy hour..."

Judi Anderson Loisi

"Food was awesome, sfingi & Nutella .. to die for. Cocktails 🥃..."

Rena M Glorioso

"Everything I ordered was fresh and homemade. I dream about the burrata salad that you have. I am so sorry I live over an hour away or I would be..."

Kendra Grace Maniaci Balistreri

"Stopped in for lunch to celebrate my birthday and catch up. Had garlic cheesy bread and fried ravioli appetizers, 3 different pasta dishes which were..."

Lauren Nachtigall

"We love DiVino’s! The pizza is exceptional and the service is..."

Barbara Fleming

"I love there pizza , best pizza in town !!!!!! Get you one..."

Eddie Love III

"Nothing better than a home cooked Italian Meal, from scratch! My first time here today. I highly..."

Jason Meissner

"Great food. Great service. � Taste like homemade food. ..."

Will Taleb

"Can't get better than Divino. Fantastic food, great people. Simple as..."

Patty Sheldon

"A great favorite of ours ! Super staff, terrific food and wine, nice, fun and friendly folks ....always makes it a great time with the best veal,..."

Kathy Schafer

"So I had high hopes walking into Tavolino. I follow Milwaukee Foodie on Facebook, and I have become very big into flavors and food over the last year..."

Katie Milosevich

"We came here for Valentines Day and the food was absolutely delicious! We got the bruschetta and the lasagna for 2. The service was amazing as well!..."

Danielle Bentel

"Simple and flavorful pompadour sauce & rigatoni. Several salads from which to choose, which they are happy to serve sans animal products. Nice..."

Sara Durkacs

"I was looking for a nice place for a romantic dinner when I came across this gem in a group from Facebook. The owner Peter suggested to come visit..."

Tempestt Ballenger

"It's a nice place to eat. I thought the pasta was average and something that could easily be recreated from home without much effort. Especially for..."

Ethan Winker

"Very nice Italian restaurant just off North Ave. Food was very good. Had appetizer, a lamb sauce pasta dish and tiramisu. Wife had same but pays..."

Gary Dalton

"Really delicious and well done execution. The spinach dumplings were my favorite part of the meal. Would come back just for appetizers and..."

Cayla Ostrowski

"First review of this place so I'll make it good. Overall great place, food, drinks, venue, and staff. Coffee was above average. Good drink selection..."

Ian Addison

"Food, atmosphere, drinks, service was all amazing. Will definitely be going back. The short ribs with the mushroom risotto was so..."

Matt Olson

"Outstanding! One of the main things I appreciated from here was that they have gluten-free pizza and gluten- free pasta (chickpea). Service: staff..."

Paola Beatriz

"I ate more than I wanted to because the food tasted fresh and absolutely delicious. I had mushroom pizza (the mushrooms were fried and covered the..."

Sarfraz Ahmed

"Fire. Lasagna for two is extremely good and their burrata was amazing. Definitely coming..."

Elias Probst

"Amazing experience. Great food. Quiet and quaint and just what we needed. Thanks..."

Carmine Papara

"Really enjoyed the experience. Good cocktails and delicious..."

Lindsey Roddy

"Love this place! Food is always great! I would love if they offered espresso, but that's not gonna keep me from coming..."

Tom Johnston

"Our visit was ok, except for misunderstanding with order - my husband ordered Pesto pasta and wasn’t told it’s vegan option. So he ate cabbage..."

Julia Shtefan

"Hands-down the best Italian food in Milwaukee. Modern and fresh flavors, while still embracing the classics. Elegantly decorated, while still being..."

Kate Coysh

Ian's Pizza Cream City

86/100 (4707 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"I have been here twice for one thing and one thing only: the Mac and cheese pizza. This time, I was pleasantly surprised to also get to have another..."

Paige Buschman

"Pizza is pretty good. I tried three different slices and found the Mac and Cheese to be my favorite of the three. The bread sticks are ok, though..."

Sarah Klein

"Ian’s has such a fun and different menu, but the highlight for me is the HUGE vegan menu. Not only is it great to see, but at a pizza place, it is..."

Talor Gregory

"Delicious pizza. Having the options to buy it by the slice is a nice deal. We were able to try a few different flavors. The crust was crispy on the..."

ADUMB

"Not gonna lie, I was a bit skeptical when my boyfriend told me this was one of his top pizza places, but he was correct! We came in and it was pretty..."

Vy D

"Love IAN'S! Great pie by the slice. Delicious and creative recipes. Nice and quick. I hadn't been down to Water in a while and was pleasantly..."

Tony chips Chiappetta

"I usually love a retro good vibes place, and that's what this restaurant has! Love the video games on the top floor. My friends and I had a great..."

Steven Ocampo

"First time trying this place. Employees are great! They make the place. Pizza was not bad. Prices are nice. Dining area seems cluttered- broom..."

A.

"First time at this pizza shop after doing a Google search of best pizza places in Milwaukee this place with number two. Hands-down the best pizza..."

David Leavitt

"WOW! This place is amazing! The staff is super fun, friendly, very helpful, and know a lot about what they have to offer. The pizza by the slice is a..."

Joshua Moore

"Ian's is a no-frills, counter-serve pizzeria serving traditional and non-traditional styles of pizza, ranging from cheese and pepperoni to chicken..."

Abhi Singh

"On a weekend trip and decided to stay in and order pizza. THE BEST, we got pepperoni & a salad. Highly recommend! And delivery to the hotel was fast..."

Jessica Leigh

"Ian's is awesome, favorite pizza place before I became vegan. My kids received burnt slices , but staff replaced it right away. Unfortunately, my..."

Elisa Myerson

"Another star location A+ pizza as always! And A++ service (when they are not bus :) it fluctuates. My fav joint when in Waukee can’t come to waukee..."

Faisal H.

"Delicious thin crust pizzas. One of the best pizzas in Milwaukee. Long crowds in the weekends highlights it. Varieties of sliced pizzas which the..."

Evan Ramos

"Great pizza as always. It's what we've come to expect from Ian's. Don't plan to stay though. The dining area is small. Get your stuff and eat it on..."

Levi Kohlmann

Johnny V's Classic Cafe

"We loved it here. We arrived around 10:30pm. Very few people there. Jordan was our waitress and she was so awesome. Great head on her shoulders..."

Tanya Vitucci

"Ordered delivery for the first time tonight. 30-45 minutes. Showed up in 22, and the food must have been straight out of the kitchen : pizza was so..."

Marty Asher

"a great place to relax n eat /great food/great waitress service/great hospitality/great decor'for any holiday/great waitors service!!! we have our..."

Tory Jr Williams

"It's like a family atmosphere! The staff is gracious and attentive to the patrons. Highly recommend this Milwaukee landmark!..."

Chip Decorah

"The hash browns were perfect and the eggs Benedict were the best ever. And of course they have very good coffee. Waitress was a..."

Ruth Werderitz

"Been eating here since it opened! Owners always there to greet customers, very friendly staff, good food, and the BEST chicken dumpling..."

Liz Peters

"Chilled place with, good food. Even though I've only ordered one thing everyone I've gone. Haha steak egg breakfast..."

Eric Ehn

"Coffee was a fantastic bottomless cup, I found out they grind the beans right there! Also had chicken fried steak that was delicious! The service was..."

johnnyitup

"It's my new favorite place to eat in the Milwaukee area. For breakfast lunch or dinner. EVERY meal I've had was great. This is truly old school diner..."

Matthew Robinson

"We were greeted and seated right away. Coffees were brought and kept full. Order was taken and food came out fast and hot and was delicious. We had..."

Christine Christine

"Cute old school diner/café. We stopped by for breakfast during a weekday and we were greeted as soon as we walked in. We sat at the counter and was..."

Anna Rowe

"Love this place but not the steak sandwich. Had to send it back twice. We go there all the time and food is always great. Don't know what..."

Sherry Grainger

"Our waitress was very pleasant and attentive. The food was good. I loved my gyro pita..."

Rick G

"A real southern hospitality experience! Our friendly server Rose really brightened my day with her wonderful personality. Coffee cup was always ket..."

Lyle DeGraff

"I had A really good experience here, I ordered their Big Breakfast with French Toast. Food was prepared as requested and everything was Hot, even the..."

andrew treinen

"This place used to be The Old Johnny V's Classic Cafe. It is a much better place now that they changed the name to 84th Classic Cafe and the..."

Joseph

"Atmosphere takes a distant third to food and service when eating in a Diner. 84th Classic Cafe is indeed "classic". Just good, home-made food,..."

Tony Novinska

"I can't say enough about this place..the food is fantastic and the suvice was great. Portions are amazing.. So many great things to try I ordered 2..."

JP Bluma

"Our waitress was Linda B. We got great service, and she was very friendly. An excellent waitress. We would definitely recommend..."

Christopher Smith

"I love eating here. The food is good and we get great service!..."

Ris G

"This was my first time here meeting with a large group of friends. Our server was awesome! I had eggs, bacon, hashbrowns, and toast, and everything..."

john p

"The food was excellent & so was the service! I absolutely enjoy getting a meal, that's quick, fast & served..."

Lanita Elliott

"Good place for a small get together or something lowkey. Average prices for pretty good food. Only complaint is the girl with black hair tatted up..."

Nevaeh Biddle

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana

86/100 (1052 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"First time here. If you are looking for fresh, interesting, and delicious pizzas, this is the place. We all ordered a different pizza, and shared..."

Scott W

"This is the only Neapolitan style pizzeria certified to use quality Italian ingredients in its wood oven fired pizzas in the Milwaukee area! It was..."

C. Ernest

"This spot was recommended by someone who is from Italy. I was told this is legit Italian food and authentic Pizza Napoletana. It did not disappoint. ..."

Sarah Sterling

"A truly unique pizza experience. If you dine in, I highly recommend sitting at the pizza..."

Thomas Genack

"So fantastic. Service was awesome from the hostess, server and kitchen. The food? Perfect. Can’t wait to go back. We had Margherita pizza, gnocchi..."

Jennifer Garofalo

"The real Italian wood-fired pizza. Great Alessandro, it was a pleasure to meet you, if you pass by Las vegas remember to come to Farinata, Italian..."

Mauro Saiglia

"We ordered the burrata app and the Ilario (pictured). Both dishes were good but not mind-blowing. Crust was very good and was hoping that would be..."

Lisa Ridenour

"My friend and I visited the place for supper. Their individual-sized pizza were on a pricier side, but the quality of ingredients was excellent. They..."

Dmitry Zinger

"What an awesome spot! The pizzas are incredible and our waiter was so great! He was so personable and gave great recommendations of items that the..."

Noah Scibbe

"At ate there last night for the second time with my husband and parents before the Ringo Starr concert. Megan was our server and she was an absolute..."

Janine Abplanalp

Balistreri's Bluemound Inn

86/100 (2350 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"This Bluemound Road staple is great, from the bar where the bartenders can make good Martinis to the kitchen where they make great food. I recommend..."

Kevin Culver

"We were at the 68th street location. The best thin crust pizza. We ordered a large for the 3 of us so we could take some home. Fried eggplant and..."

Sue Kraus

"Went last night with family and had prompt service, great wine, and amazing lasagna. Whenever we stop through the food has always been excellent. Try..."

Danielle Romain Dagenhardt

"This is one of our favorite places to eat! Service is excellent! We love Natalie, Rhonda, GiGi and Antonio and great bartenders Dave, Phil and of..."

Kathleen Dagenhardt

"What a great place, atmosphere, service and excellent food. 6 of us shared the house salad, eggplant and a large pizza. Thoroughly enjoyed it all. ..."

Liz Gaengel

"Our meal was beyond spectacular and our waiter Antonio was excellent. Thank you for a great meal and experience. Can't wait to come..."

June Prestin

"Becca served Mom and I. She was absolutely the CSO-Chief Service Officer! Mom needed a pick-me-up so we decided to pop in for sweets. Mom ordred the..."

Mary Perry

"I think I found my new place to have a relaxing dinner with great service and incredible food !!! 5 stars..."

Brad Jancarik

"What a top notch restaurant. Excellent staff, atmosphere, and an extensive menu. Everything our group tried was..."

Debbie Jacobs

"Found the place late evening (10:00pm) via reviews after a long day of exploring Milwaukee and we couldn't have been happier with the place, old..."

Kevin LaBarr

"Went late night and had pizza and Martinis... Awesome server Anthony as well as the best Pizza and Martinis I’ve had in a long time... very clean..."

Carmen Wanzo

"Food was terrific and great service. Will definately be back. Highly recommend making a reservation as they are very..."

Mindi Wamser Zenisek

"I had the tenderloin steak sandwich it was so tender and delicious! My husband had the seafood pasta, also loved it. Great service in every way!..."

Cheri Graffenius

"Absolutely delicious! I went for a date night on a Sunday night. Highly recommend reservations or you likely won’t get in. We had lasagna and..."

Faith

"Celebrated my birthday here. Food was amazing. Got the baked tomato bisque soup (made like baked French onion soup) and lasagna. Couldn’t even eat..."

Renee

"We tried the garlic cheese bread and a pizza. Ordered the pizza a little well done and it came out perfect. Nice thin crispy crust and great flavor...."

Erich

"Great service we were seated so fast and barely waited at all for our appetizer, the home made garlic bread! So delicious! And the atmosphere itself..."

Wings-N-Whisky Meat and potatoes

"Stopped here looking for a new pizza experience..I was not disappointed!!! We had half order of eggplant for an appetizer and it more than enough..."

Joe-Ann Landry

"My boyfriend took me out for a nice birthday lunch here and it was amazing! I couldn't believe how great my food was. Prices are really not that bad..."

Marta Julia

"We just love this place. A goof old fashioned supper club. I had the Delmonico steak and it was amazing. Wonderful wait staff, awesome bartenders...."

Mike McLane

"Friendly Service with a Smile. Didn't get the"Not my Job", when we asked the busser for Parm cheese Shaker!😎..."

Joseph Gagliano

"Balisteris is a very good Italian Restaurant! The building itself is very nice and homely, very well kept and clean from the inside out though it CAN..."

MistahZ

"The most beautiful atmosphere with incredible food and exceptional service! Our server Jason recommended the vodka sauce on the mushroom ravioli and..."

Thomas Vaughan

"Top notch Italian food. Fine dinning without being all stuffy. You can go casual. I don't wear jeans or shorts here. Service and food is outstanding...."

Paul Jeffers

"The food and service were exceptional. A little too hoity toity for me as far as atmosphere since we were taking a shuttle to the Brewers game. I..."

David Ernst

"We are staying in town from Minneapolis for my daughter's gymnastics competition at the State FIr Grounds and decided to try Balisteri's out. Walked..."

Joe Dancho

"Wonderful food, great service. Balistreri's special pizza and ribeye steak sandwich were a perfect..."

SFaye Kachikis

"It's like a home away from home. Jim's people are always top notch, foods great and the drinks refreshing. I've been going here for more than 30..."

rob m

"Stopped in late after everyone else's kitchens were closed and ordered an incredible Cavatappi Bolognese! Extensive menu, the bar was lively, but..."

Reset

There are 95 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Milwaukee

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Davonta Badazz

Kenya Jackson

Tonya Manning

Jackie White

Sundra D

Viola Ervin

Keyshia Rule

Shelon Wade 25TOLIFE WIFERSATIONS HESPEAKS

SILVER_EDITZ 2 SILVER

Tameika Newson

Ieaisha Tate

Wayne Reese

Kelis Young

Karron Moffett

MonteDaGreatTV

Todd Shake

Ramadan Mubarak

Lyn MsHollywood

Angelic Peterson

Drew Johnson

Joe D

Tristan Rawlings

Desiree La Belle

Jacob D

Jennifer Cohen

Kyle Swartz

Brian Arnold

Holly Weber

Noor Al

Christina

Charlie Bauer

Robert Garrett

Dustin Barrett

Scarlett Bell

SCORE SE Wisconsin

Lynne Rhyan

Margarita Limón

Lorinda Liongson

Michael A Lazar

Norman Klein

Jeff Ledvorowski

Marsha Gapinski

Kass S

Esteban

Jisha Hechel

Justine Filapek

Kris Eaton

raquel hakkenberg

Bill West

Lauren Domski

L All

C Kru

Shanta E.

Ben Klepzig

Tristan Rawlings

Burt “CPStubbs” Perkins

Aleksandar

Daniel Pieper

Rick Buckley

Andrew Bethke

Ray Bell

Annette Lucchesi

Michael L

Mjg13 87

Travis Sternhagen

Todd Witt

B Rivera

The DeloDelo