Must stop pizza joint! They run different types of pizzas throughout the seasons so it never gets old and the pizzas are always top notch. We definitely couldn't finish it all but it's just as good later as it was with the first bite!
Some of the best pizzas we have ever had! The service is great, and the pizza is far superior to any others in the near vicinity. This is not tavern style and more closely imitates a napoletana Italian crust. A much needed food style for the neighborhood!
Guys! This is a MUST TRY pizza place. The crust is perfect, chewy on the inside with a crispy outside. The sauce is light and seasoned to perfection. We went with the sausage, mushroom, and onion, but I wish I could've tried them all. This is my new FAVORITE pizza!
Wow, mind blown!!! Service was excellent!!! We had the arugula salad, amazing. The
focaccia garlic bread had the perfect crust on it with a garlic butter that looked like peanut butter, it was F-ing amazing also!! We ordered 2 pizza's, a sausage and red onion, and a Ring of fire. Awesome pizza, quality ingredients. They definitely got there crust game dialed in perfect. Chewy and soft👍👍 We also got 2 homemade dipping sauces for your bread or crust. One was a ranch and other was a creamy balsamic. The ranch was the best ranch I ever tasted. Amazing place. To the owners thank you for having such passion and love for the food you make and serve. I will be back very soon
After several years of driving past it, I finally tried Wy'east Pizza and I have to say, I'm really sad I didn't try it sooner. This is easily one of the tastiest pizza joints in the Milwaukee area. My wife and I did take out for the Hot Marmot, the Pesto Plateau, and the Beet Salad. So delicious! The Hot Marmot was my favorite bite, but the Pesto was not far behind, and I typically don't go for pizza without red sauce. Perfect crust and undercarriage on this Neopolitan-style pizza. Super friendly staff and prompt pickup process. I will definitely be back soon.
Damn good date nice. No lie- some great pie. Highly recommend. Owner Ann, checked on us twice. Great human.
Still dreaming of this pizza, seriously the best in the Milwaukee area. Make sure to call ahead to reserve a spot or pick up order. They make a finite amount of pizzas a night, which shows just how dedicated they are to the craft. The staff were so nice and welcoming, really had a magical time here and can’t wait to come again.
Been wanting to try Wyeast for a while now and finally got a pizza to go. Tried one of their specialty pizzas with chutney, potato, sausage, and cheese blend. The flavors were so good together and the crust was that perfect wood fired pizza dough. Excited to come back and try another pizza as dine in!
Stopped here for dinner and ordered a Trailhead (cheese) and a Hot Marmot (pepperoni and hot peppers). The crust gets this great leoparding and tastes amazing. Small space with outdoor seating and take out available. Definitely not your typical chain pizza!
Cute, small little pizza shop. Excellent menu with classics and rotating specialties. The environment is small and cozy allowing for a nice atmosphere. Recommend the ring of fire.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Milwaukee
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes