I'm sure Classic Slice could make a lovely Avocado Salad. But I will never know. I'm here for the pizza. It's decidedly New York style, either by the giant slice or by the pie. Yeah, the menu has other stuff that I am unlikely to ever review, because pizza. And the pizza goes from the pepperoni standard to the unique with cheese curds, jalapenos, and bacon. Service is friendly.
By the slice but made to order. Kinda reminded me of DC jumbo slices but they're not quite as big. I got the Detroit style, which was delicious and fairly priced.
Good vibes inside. Nice folks
Mayra Rodriguez Valladares
+5
Very helpful staff and very tasty pizzas. The slices are huge. Clientele is diverse. Great introduction to Milwaukee.
Loved this pizza! The lady at the counter was so friendly and helpful! And she had great recommendations for what to order!
This pizza is one of the best in Milwaukee. I eat here weekly.
The large slice has been inconsistent lately (in the last month) which is curious. Maybe new pizza makers? The cost is now $6-$7 per slice which is a bold price so you have to deliver.
Hoping they continue their great tradition because this was always the best slice in town. Perhaps my experience will be better this week.
Absolutely delicious! I took my kids here for lunch! We had so much food left over, it was great for later on! I spent a little over $38 but well worth it! The place is clean and amazing seating for social distancing! We ordered a huge pizza with garlic knots and cheese bread, along with 5 drinks! There was 3 adults and 3 kids and we still had food left over! My kids loves their pizza! Its hot and fresh and the staff are amazing! Looking forward to coming here more often!
Pizza was SO SO good!! Smelled great, tasted great and was our first Milwaukee pizza. Yum yum for sure!!
We have a vegan, vegetarian, and gluten free person with us and there are options for all! I enjoyed the vegan scardinia a new favorite.
Giant slice NY style made to order, not sitting under a heat lamp. Good flavor, just a bit more than bland. However the crust was awesome, crisp and charred just right. Great vibe which is kid friendly as well, and service was really good too. A top spot in MKE.
I'm from out of town and was craving pizza. Of all the suggested places, this place caught my eye because of the New York style crusts (thin).
Im by no means a pizza connoisseur BUT I know good pizza when I eat one. Delicious crust, doesn't leave that raw dough taste, the toppings stick, and I swear to god it looks like someone is making fresh dough slices as they're ordered back there. It just tastes fresh.
If you're looking for a place that prides themselves in the art of good dough and quality ingredients, this little gem of a place is a definite must eat!
10/10 would recommend!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Milwaukee
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes