Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Madison

"Our first visit as we were just passing thru ... the food was excellent and I can not say enough about our service !! Your servers are second to none..."

Nathan Therrien

Andrew M

William Brophy

Joseph Sullivan

Carmen Lozano

Mark Dahmer

Robert Aufseeser (Robbie)

Cesar Fonseca

Joey's Italian Grill

75/100 (2046 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Great food great service been going to the Madison location for years but don't expect the same in..."

Jen

"Good Italian. Joey's is part of the Longo family that has been well known in Lake County for many years. Been to this location several times and have..."

Eric

"It's not bad, it's not great, it's Joey's. The food is fine. It's basic diner food. Their are quite a few things on the menu that are actually pretty..."

Mason

"Relaxed comfortable place with excellent chow choices. Thank you Tracy for the fast, friendly, and attentive service. Excellent Madison Chicken and..."

Warren Hixson

"We came here last night and it was pretty decent. I feel like the Alfredo sauce could have been more flavorful. I feel like the sauce had very little..."

Pvt. lunchbox

"Gf and I shared a lasagna and sausage pepper pasta. How wonderful. So much flavor. Our server, Madison, was very attentive and checked on us now and..."

Joe Blavatsky

"May have been the best overall dining experience I've ever had. Melissa was the waitress, awesome! Light-hearted and fun, good attitude, and..."

Caleb Hoffman

"Waitress was inattentive. I ordered sausage and pasty with a side salad. After asking for it, my salad showed up 5 minutes after my dinner was..."

Stan Williams

"We were looking for a spot to have dinner, other than a pub or bar, and found this place online. Joey's Italian was a nice surprise, we had never..."

Mary Johnson

"I’m Italian and I love to cook. But I have to tell you I had the best meat sauce ever(I even thought it was better then mine). I only wish that I..."

Joanne Peraino Pusateri

"Absolutely adore this restaurant. I have yet to eat anything I don't like. The employees are always so nice to us. Great place to play some corn..."

Britina Freeze

"Thoroughly enjoyed this place. It was crowded so we added our name to the waiting list and went back to the bar to have a drink and relax before..."

Cyndi Dotson

"We have wanted to try Joey's for quite some time. They have a nice outdoor patio during this challenging time. Tables are well spaced. Lauren took..."

Shane Cook

Pizza Pit Extreme

Free off-street parking

"This place has the best Chicago style pizza if you are looking for lunch spot I'd highly recommend. $7 for 2 slices and a soda, try the bucky you..."

DJ T

"Definitely my favorite lunch spot when in the area. The pizza is awesome and sold by the..."

Ronny Gilmore

"The stuffed pizza is awesome. The only problem is they are not always open when they say they are..."

Michelle Dvorak

"Pretty decent pizza. They sell slices which is nice for a quick bite. They have chicago style slices as well as regular. Prices are good as well. The..."

Austin M

"Great pizza. Service is kinda slow 🐌 But the pizza is good enough to keep..."

Mike Somsanith

"Pizza Pit is my favorite hands..."

Keith Knauer

"Try the deep dish BBQ chicken, you won't be..."

Kyle Davis

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Wheelchair Accessible

"Enjoyed unlimited salad and soup for lunch right after the lunch crowd hour(s) and our server was fantastic! We were encouraged to just relax and..."

Kristine Nelson

"We sat at the bar and received awesome service with a smile! Food was served hot and fresh. One of the best locations to enjoy Olive Garden..."

D Erb

"The food was good as always. Service was good as well. Stand out for me is always the salad and bread..."

Kassy Heard

"Required gluten free food. Three smiling staff wanting to seat us. Ordered pasta and 🍤 shrimp. Thankful to receive more shrimp than expected. All..."

Bob Doyle

Il Mondo Vechio

"Fantastic experience! Food was delicious and service was top not notch. Love the "bring your own wine" concept! Saves $ so we were able to eat more..."

Tara

"most restaurants dont retain quality over years and years. this place does. remarkably consistent. excellent food. excellent service. classic..."

Charlie Cessna

"Complentary brushetta and crispy zucchini to start that was very delicious. All the food is delicious here. There is a liquor store next door and..."

Tina Ho

"Delicious food, atmosphere was great and the wait staff were friendly and attentive. It’s a BYO which is nice and we were given complimentary..."

Steve M

"Amazing place to go for a meal. The staff is warm and inviting, and willing to engage in some conversation to make you feel at home. The food..."

Kevin Murphy

"Recently hosted an event. The staff was professional, polite & responsive. Atmosphere & decor is beautiful. Food was AMAZING! Our guests raved about..."

frank iannarone

"BYOB dinner cost for 4 people range $250 (include tips) is not bad for $$$ value especially they serve you big portion, OMG! A must have recommend..."

Sunny Orchid

"I've been going to Il Mondo Vecchio for special occasions for more than 30 years. The food has always been incredibly good. Huge menu, everything is..."

Eric Pinzur

"Went to dinner here recently and Claudio, the manager was great ! We had great service, the food was amazing and we will definitely be coming back..."

Donald DiDomenico

"Great food, ambiance, and service! What more can you ask..."

M E

"Delicious and elegant dining experience! The dessert and apps we're our..."

Daria Richline

Subway

71/100 (1903 ratings)

"Not bad for a quick meal. There's a nice big eating area here. And they have your typical sandwiches, cookies, chips, soda, etc. They open early..."

Jenny K

"Super good! Freshly baked sub bun with fresh vegetables - tomato, cucumber. Lettuce, red onion, green pepper topped with chipotle southwest. What..."

Tom Chubaty

"Always good food, quality and consistent choices. Service is good and you know you can plan on getting your favorite meal. Healthy..."

Richard Hanson

The Maze Of Madison

Tutto Pasta State Street

70/100 (2143 ratings)

Pizza Pit - Madison West

Free off-street parking

"Pizza Extreme has the best Chicago-style pizza in Madison. Great crust and sauce. Great chicken drummies..."

Danny G

"I ordered Friday, early afternoon... it got there faster than they said and so hot I couldn't eat it right away. Definitely the freshest delivery..."

Tabitha Falch

"After not having Pizza Pit for almost 20 years due, to a bad experience, we tried it again when we heard it was under new management. I am so glad we..."

Susan Brady

"I have always received great pizza, great timing on delivery, quality is exactly how I remember it when I was 9! Friendly staff..."

Luda Kazachenko

"Friendly staff and great pizza, will be ordering..."

Nuggetynug Linc

Mazzio's

Wheelchair Accessible

Lunch

Dinner

Mid-range

"This was actually my 2nd time, getting food from this location. The 1st time was very underwhelming. The wings were overcooked and dried out. The..."

DaJuan Williams

"Pretty good for the selection and price. I was disappointed that they didn't make enough cinnamon pizza desserts, making primarily chocolate chip..."

Audrey L Morehead

"Great service! The staff is very friendly and they treat you like family. This place was clean and kept very..."

Earl O'Banner

"We jumped off the interstate and wanted to sit down and eat after driving several hours and after checking several places no one would offer dining..."

Bubba Logan

"the pizza is good, not great. the salad bar is very good. service is friendly. they are consistently a good place for their lunch..."

Reset

There are 82 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Madison

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Angela Dawn Mason

Kimberly Berry

Jennifer Hardy

Jacob Ray

Tori Collier

Tanaya Bose

Andy Reidler

Patricia Wright

Anarchy 99

Tania Jonjack

Dan Bock

Hannah Porto

Shelby Petersen

Tobin Shucha

Ann Kaplan Kruska

Corryn Ashleigh Johnson

Brandon Rusch

Haley McKenzie

Kelsey Steinmetz

Julie Williams

Marilynn Galkowski Gallenberger

Jill Heathcote

Dale Loff

Joel Baeza

Nicole Wittkopp

Gina Love

Nathaniel Hope

Joshua Kleczka

Joe Wierschem

Bryan Boccard

Bethany Jensen

Anantharaghavan Sridhar

Harish Ramalingam

Royal Joker

sam mcilwain

Savvy L

Lisa Hatala

Meg Mullin

Jackie Outwater

Mariah Heller

M Rog

Christopher Halasz

Kaitlyn Molino

molly devlin

Isaac Diaz

Loren O'Donnell

Carla Cortes Baez

cabadger11

francine wade

Guy Bollfrass

Desarae King

Jeff Redington

Randy Luher

K S

Allan Hastings

mohindar reddy

Vanessa Sue

Juan Camilo Giraldo

Brian Spain

Kristen Maines

William J Sisti

steven soprano

Tony Paternostro

Erin Cummings

Nathan Therrien

Andrew M

William Brophy

Joseph Sullivan