Was trying to find a place that wasn’t outrageously priced for some Italian food. Found this little place. Definitely didn’t look appealing from the outside but pretty decent inside. Street parking or there’s a parking lot I noticed across the street where people were parking. Has a bar area then seating for dinner/eat in. Ordered Alfredo with chicken. Wasn’t crazy about the chicken on it bc it was like boiled and white like the sauce. The sauce was pretty decent. Not one to run back and have again until I have other places to compare it to. But wasn’t bad either. I definitely could do without the chicken on top. But the portion size was ok for the price.
This place was a happy surprise.. On the outside it looks like a tired honky Toni. On the inside it looks like a honky tonk lol. BUT the menu included some of my favorite Italian dishes. We were there for a birthday party and we had about 20 people. Cathy was our tireless waitress and she served us by herself. The food was rich and the portions generous…
This little “hole in the wall” is beyond great! Nothing to look at outside, the inside very interesting, feels warm and a family atmosphere. The bar is so old and beautiful. The food I love ❤️ love ❤️! I got the puttanesca with chicken it is amazing!! The salads are very delicious as well! The prices are very reasonable and the servers are very friendly and they take good care of you. Go you will LOVE it! 🥰
Great "hole in the wall" Italian restaurant, that's been a staple of the community for some time. Food was fresh, service was great.
Had some things missing due to supply chain issues, but most places are running into that right now. Waiter always worked to make replacement suggestions and try to make the most of it.
For appetizers, the wontons are the go to! Pastas were good, but still looking for my favorite choice to recommend.
Love Come Back Inn. Ambiance, and food are incredible. We frequented the Come Back Inn three times and each time was incredible. We will continue to invite new and old friends and continue to visit the restaurant. Hoping the Inn stays open for many more years to come. The pasta dishes are always good and hearty. The servings are ample size for even two persons to share. We have not tried the pizza yet, though this is planned for future visits.
Some of the best pasta I've ever had! And the service was excellent! The bread sticks on the other hand were just ok. On a side note our table was so small it was hard to eat with our appetizer and entree on the table.
We loved the family atmosphere. The food was excellent! I had the Italian Roast Beef Loaded. A meal for 3!! it is a lot of food!
This is a Hidden Gem in Louisville. Check it out and you won't be disappointed!!
Cathy was our superb server - great atmosphere & historic decor. I had the Meatball Bake with pasta and my buddy had the Chicken Breast Bake without pasta. Ample portions and wonderful draft craft beer.
Plenty of street parking and it has a full bar.
OMG! This place is amazing, honestly some of the best food I’ve had in L’ville. It may not look like much when you walk in but rest assured your going to have a good meal and top notch service.
Comeback in is a friendly home style Italian place. The food is very good for the price. Wood paneling reminds me of Grandma's house and so does the full bar. Everything is good even the chicken tenders for the picky eaters. Highly recommend, underrated
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Louisville
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes