Good, comfortable place to eat. I run a small science fiction relaxacon that meets at Eden Resort every summer. Since we are all in the hotel we often end up at Garfield's for lunch. I am in the area so I eat here often during the year. I am told by 2 friends that the chocolate milkshakes are excellent. I can recommend the burgers, the Chicken Pie, the Pot Roast of Beef, and the taco salad. The Monster Shakes and the Mud Pie are heaven!
I had pot roast with mashed potatoes, it was delicious, very tender, and well seasoned, the portions were excellent for the price.
For desert I had a Mud Pie which was fantastic.
Best Hamburgers In Lancaster. Great place to eat and Stay.
One of my favorite restaurants! Food is always great & the service is terrific. The wait tends to be a bit longer but if you have the time it’s worth the wait. It’s very spacious and there’s enough room to fit 6 in a larger booth. There is also a bar area that is not usually crowded during the day. If you have a platinum card you get a discount every time... I believe it’s 20%... Good deal!
Nice, quaint eatery with an entrance within the Eden Resort. It was nice not having to go far for a quick bite. The menu had a nice assortment of options from appetizers to entrees. The staff was very nice and accommodating. Best part is they charge the meal to your room. Very convenient, but also could get dangerous if you're eating here often during your stay! We will likely stop in for a bite during our next stay at Eden Resort
Rob “Scalewoodman” Woodward
+5
Great lunch spot with bar service and a superb lunch buffet. Fresh and always excellent. A great place to reward your staff for exemplary performance and something for everyone. Never ever had a bad anything at the Eden: restaurants, events, weddings, meetings, brunches- first class all the way and excellent value.
This rating would have been lower, as the garden vegetable pasta dish I ordered was not that good, but it was saved by the sweet young lady named Martha who was our waitress. I ordered the dish without mushrooms, as I'm allergic to them, but Martha realized that the chef prepared it with mushrooms in error as she was bringing it out to the table. She apologized profusely and immediately took it back without me having to say anything. I was prepared a fresh dish, and Martha gave me a complimentary slice of chocolate fudge cake as an apology. Thank you, Martha! Excellent service!
Eden Resort and staff by Best Western was great.. But I need to give a special shout out to the staff at Garfield's.. what a great week.. Jennifer, Tabatha, Ashley and the rest of the staff.. Thanks so much for your kindness and service. I definitely will be back soon.
Super nice restaurant that is not too high on its horse. Biz casual recommended. Stay @ the hotel, too... super nice to have the Eden and this restaurant in same place. Garfield's used to be a joke, overpriced and too stuffy, but it has turned around to a great little Lancaster joint.
For the most part this is a solid restaurant with above average buffet food (although what is on the buffet isn't a very broad selection and it can be a risk that there's nothing there you may like) but the food is of a very good quality and the wait staff is attentive and friendly. Very good experience overall.
Good comfort foods. Average salad bar. I liked the chili at the salad bar. Prime rib was fine and the sides were good too. Reliable food every time we've eaten here.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Lancaster
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes