The pies were good, but I expected more of a dine in than a grab and go. My child enjoys the wooden spoons. The prices were reasonable for the quality.
Not sure why i have never written this review. This is hands down some of the best pie in the world. I40 by far my favorite but everything i have tried is awesome. I'm not a apple pie guy but it looks amazing and is said to be delightful. My least favorite would be the strawberry, taste was good but textures didn't work with me. Never been a crust guy but this is one of those exception with Buttermilk Sky. Form the look of the building down to the wooden cutlery. The feel and smells will get you thinking about your favorite pie and memories to go with. Great to pick up a few and share with friends for after dinner dessert or just a pie date. I do prefer to buy the small pies as they seem to just have better balance and all around flavor over the full pies. Plus you can get a variety and everyone can decide what their favorite is for next time.
The pies here are phenomenal! I have tried multiple pies from this place and they were all excellent. The only complain is that they are a little pricy, but still worth it.
Hottest dessert in Knoxville!. This little pie shop has truly taken over Knoxville! For those on Urbanspoon for the Bearden and Turkey Creek locations who have stated you can get comparable or better desserts at Kroger/Publix, I strongly disagree! Pies are baked right in front of you and fresh daily. Perfect crust and the pecan pie is to die for! The pecan pie filling seems to caramelize on the top of the crust giving a homemade caramel taste - amazing! I will say I find the chocolate pie a little too sweet and am not the biggest fan of meringue. Also recommend the lemon and I-40 pies. It is a little pricey, but pie is definitely a treat, not a daily meal!
Robert S. McGrath Jr
+4.5
Great Place!. A friend and I stopped in about two weeks before the grand opening. We got to sample the Buttermilk pie (which we were sceptical about, having never heard of such). To say we were impressed is a bit of an understatement. We went for the mixed pack (4 for $16) of small pies. I got a couple pecan pies, a buttermilk, and a pumpkin. The pecan pie is to die for - my other half and I couldn't share one (kept tugging the plate back and forth). The pumpkin pie is the best I've had in town.
I've been in 2x since, and enjoyed both experiences, though I see them working through growing pains each visit (as you'd expect). I've since tried the chocolate meringue and the caramel pie - both were similarly excellent.
I'll definitely be back!
- Side note - the ice cream (at present) is made by Cruze Farms!
Excellent. So rare to be able to get such good quality pastries.... their pies are delicious and still warm... they cook in front of you, and you see them preparing the dough.
Just try it and you will come back on a regular basis:)
Their ice cream is also yummy, creamy, fresh and tasty.
The pumpkin pie and the pecan pie are as good as if your southern grandma had cooked them for you with all her love.
They sell pies, both 4” individual and 9” full-sized versions. They also sell biscuits, although I didn’t sample any. I may swing by on the way to the office one morning to pick up a batch of biscuits for breakfast for the office at some point, based on the quality of the pies alone.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Knoxville
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes