New Bethel Ordinary

New Bethel Ordinary, Indianapolis 8838 Southeastern Ave - Indianapolis

Now open
American
• Pizza
• Sit down

81/100
Give a rating

What's your favorite New Bethel Ordinary's dish?

Ratings and reviews

81
/100
Based on 2652 ratings and reviews
Updated

The menu of New Bethel Ordinary suggested by Sluurpy users

Ratings of New Bethel Ordinary

TA

Trip
Last update on 26/03/2023
4,0
80 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 18/07/2023
4,5
2101 Reviews
Facebook
Facebook
Last update on 15/08/2020
4,5
306 Reviews
Zomato
Zomato
Last update on 07/10/2020
3,8
101 Reviews

G

Grubhub
Last update on 15/08/2020
3,5
4 Reviews

Menu New Bethel Ordinary

  • Appetizers
    • Breadsticks
    • Potato Skins
    • Chicken Strips
    • Quesadilla
    • Fried Ravioli
  • Wings
    • Traditional Bone in Wings
    • Boneless Wings
  • Soups & Salads
    • Side Salad
    • Chicken Salad
    • Chef Salad
    • Wedge Salad
    • Chicken Caesar Salad
  • . . .
  • Browse the menu

Available menus

Reviews

Zomato
Benson Skelton
+3.5
Some time back Pat and I made a small tour of Wanamaker eating at Extraordinary Pizza and Wheatley’s. We had heard of The Ordinary but never got around to going there. Last week our server at Rebar  made a pitch for us to give it a try. He is a night-time cook there and told us they offered more than pizza.
Mar 16, 2017
Zomato
Julio
+4
It was great, tried accidentally, it wasn't planned like that, but was great
I Nearly ate two slices!
Meat is good and flavor too, however the base was king of hard to bit, so you ends up bringing the cheese and the meat only and leaving the base
It was good thought
Dec 30, 2015
Zomato
Mhav2k
+4.5
Decent pizza just outside South East Indy loop in Wanamaker!. Started out picking up my Dad to take out for a late breakfast during the week. He knew I hadn't tried this place as yet and talked me into doing a pizza. No regrets. This place has been on my wishlist for quite sometime and glad we went here. We arrived early thinking they were open for breakfast but that was only on Saturday/Sunday, it was Monday. We drove around for awhile and arrived back right at 10:30 opening time and the staff was extremely friendly and attentive. The breadsticks were absolutely fantastic. Cheese dip was very good with a bite as I like. Didn't include any pics since we scarfed them down and forgot to take pics of those... The pizza lunch specials were the 7" pizzas and remembered to include pics of those since they were just out of the oven and very hot to eat at first! The crust does taste freshly made and very good! Not in my top 10 of pizzas but in my top 5 and will certainly visit this place again when passing through or my Dad talks me out of a late breakfast again!! ;)

Enjoy!
Aug 15, 2012
Zomato
Cathy
+4.5
Decent pizza and big, but not as good as the Xtraordinary and pricier.
Mar 10, 2012
Zomato
Patrick Golston
+4.5
So...we took a coworker here for a going away lunch. I heard the Pizza was great, bit I opted for the Chicken Philly instead .with onion rings and bread pudding for desert. Excellent! ALL of it. NBO is an out of the way spot, which is cool. Go early for lunch, around 11-11:30!
Feb 29, 2012
Zomato
Stuart Banya
+4.5
Average look, great pizza. This is not an upscale establishment...this is a place for good "pie".
They also have a good beer selection . Bells two-hearted for instance.
Would drive a long way for this pizza.
Feb 23, 2012
Zomato
Anna
+4
Their pizza may not be for everyone. It's heavy, full of calories, and covered in cheese. But above all, it's delicious, AND affordable which is more than most places offer.
Jul 04, 2011
Zomato
Tina
+4.5
Pizza was awesome! They now have my business.
May 01, 2011
Zomato
The Mick
+4.5
Good grub. The pizza here is top notch,breaded tenderloin is a real winner also.And they have a great breakfast,but for some reason,they don't offer pancakes.This is a must try even if you have to drive a little to get there.Don't expect to see a fancy shiny place when you go though.The inside is, to put it nicely very dated and cramped.The parking is not good,and by all means don't park in the garage's lot next door,even if it is closed,or you risk getting towed.
Apr 24, 2011
Zomato
Jessica Huber
+4.5
Decent pizza, lots of microbrews, horrible salad bar.
Apr 23, 2011

Description

Timetable

Now Open
Monday:
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Tuesday:
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday:
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday:
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Friday:
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday:
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday:
11:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Order online with

Zomato
Zomato

G

Grubhub

Book a table with

Zomato
Zomato

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google
Facebook
Facebook
Zomato
Zomato

Info

Compare the best restaurants near New Bethel Ordinary

The Chef reccomend

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 81 based on 2652 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 317-862-5020

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1