This place has been a favorite of Indianapolis residents for over 50 years! It's a must have if you've never been!
Wow the meat pizza is great, we will add this to our list of places to grab pizza from when we are in town.
We ate there for the first time last evening and were very pleased with all of our food items. We tried the veggie and BBQ pizzas, breadsticks, hot wings, and chef salad. Good service and very helpful staff were found. We ate in, but most of their business is carry out.
Great Pizza!. I work down the street from Mickey & Bill's...we have it delivered regularly. It is the best pizza I've ever had! Loads of toppings, great flavor!
The BEST thin crust in Indianapolis. I worked at an airport hotel for a while and we ate Mickey & Bill's ALL the time! We recommended it to guests, so if you're staying in Indy near the airport and have a craving for some Hoosier-style pizza, call up Mickey * Bill's.
My favorite is their all-meat pizza. There is a ridiculous amount of meat and cheese on it, so much in fact that normally after 2 small squares, I'm full. The sausage and mushroom combo is good. The veggie is good. The taco pizza is by far the best I've ever had!
I grew up in mars hill and have eaten at M&B for as long as I can remember. They've always been generous with their toppings IMO. You do have to understand this is true hoosier style pizza...thin crust, finely ground meat, etc. If you're looking for a chicago-style pie you won't get it. Their chicken is AWESOME. Not as many sides to chose from as id like. I will concede that they aren't the best about making good on something if they mess up, but the food is good enough that even tho we now live out of the delivery area we will make the drive to get it.
A SW side staple. I have been ordering Mickey & Bills since I was a kid. I still have their number memorized -- 241-6019. Go for the sausage and mushroom. Just spicy enough and so yummy!!!
Love their taco pizza & the Mars Hill monster! Been ordering from here for years.. you get what you pay for!
M and b is not a place you dine at. It's sketchy, don't die. Absolutely get your pizza from there. Because I promise you for miles. There's not another pizza place. That's going to be as good when it comes to toppings and sauce. Now I do wish being a pizza Enthusiast is I wish that they would do better on their pizza crust.
The taco pizza in the Mars Hill monster, I feel like they're best pizzas.
Food is served hot, pretty quickly and with a smile. Got an old school vibe, like something from the 80s. Pepperoni pizza was good, standard issue dough and sauce and pepperoni. Wasn't blow away with it but at the same time couldn't complain one bit. I'm guessing that this style and flavor suits the masses when looking for a good solid pie. I would definitely go back here to try them again.
Pizza is delicious and the price is fair for what you get in return. The toppings are fresh and they pile it on. Customer service is excellent. Very nice and helpful over the phone and delivery drivers have always been polite. Highly recommended.
Cute place, wonderful food. Service was prompt and precise. Great Pizza. Best in town
Chloe Holding (TatoesMamaBear)
+5
Amazing staff. Great food. We love this pizza. Even if last time we got someone else's order lol! Still great pizza!!
Food is exactly what we ordered hot and good. Not the best pizza in the world but very good old style food joint. They are really nice and I would definitely recommend. This is not paid advertisement just a happy customer.
My husband and I tried Mickey & Bill's for the first time. We ordered the Mars Hill Monster, and it was delicious!!!! Very hefty pizza with every topping. We highly recommend it.
Glenn Brown (drwho6871)
+5
Mickey & Bill's Pizza has been around for nearly 60 years at the same location in MarsHill and has the best tasting pizza you ever put in your mouth! The only negative that is to be said about them is they do not stay open for very long like the use to before the Covid stuff all started. They are only open for like 5 hours a day which is just plain ridiculous and a complete waste of time on both their part and their long time customers as well as any new and future customers. They use to stay open at least a normal 8 business hours a day and longer on the weekends. Not anymore!! Very sad indeed and very disappointing also... ☹
This was our first time having Mickey & Bills pizza, it was very good. Crust might be frozen but the stuff that on top was fresh and good. It took 20-25 that what they said, of course any place you go for pizza it take that long anyhow. Will come back again.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes