The best pizza EVER! We go to the convention center every year for an expo. Every night for four nights in a row we go straight back to the motel and order the same Giorgio's Pizza. The delivery guy laughs with us because we want the same thing every night. Come to think of it, in the past several years that we have been coming to the dealer expo, we have never tried any other restaurant's food. When you find the best, you just want that.
Best New York style pizza in the midwest
Excellent pizza with fast friendly service. Had the stuffed meat pizza, pepperoni slice and some of the pepperoni bread sticks. The flavor of the pizzas were very good and I enjoyed the stuffed one a lot. The bread sticks were big and fluffy and had solid flavor. The cheese dipping sauce was serviceable but could use an upgrade. Prices seemed reasonable and restaurant was clean but could use a facelift. Overall solid experience and will be back.
I've been told by several sources to try this, as it is like NYC style pizza and comparable! The breadsticks/cheese felt a bit basic/plain to me, I can't say the double-stacked slices were great BUT the simple pepperoni slice was pretty good I'll say. I think their best work likely is in the simple slices.
If your looking for that New York , thin crust, style pizza, then this is it. Great pizza in a clean environment makes this place a good choice if you are downtown Indianapolis. Pizza sold by the slice makes for a great lunch
We had a great experience. We wanted a good New York slice and we definitely got it. Staff was friendly. Only complaint was difficulty finding parking but you’ll deal with that anywhere this close to the circle. I really enjoyed the stuffed breadsticks.
A wonderfully nostalgic experience for me. As excellent as it was 20 years ago! No frills, just great pizza and friendly service. You’re missing out if you haven’t had Giorgio’s!
Another good place to get a slice in Indy!
Got a slice of cheese, a slice of meat, and 4 sticks. Pizza crust was GREAT!! Sticks were just good. Price was okay.
Knowledge applied is wisdom
+5
I literally smelled the pizza walking outside down the street, smelled so good! Order by the slice or whole pie!
Staff was very friendly, nice area for seating. Restrooms for customers only.
Absolutely delicious, and a true New York style pizza. Super friendly staff. Great pizza by the slice right in the center of Indy.
It's one of my favorite pizzas by the slice. The crust is always crispy and food fresh. Love the cannolis here also. 😍 🍕 ❤️
The Elevator and Airplane Finder
+5
I have been on a quest to try as many local pizza restaurants in Indy and my most recent visit was Giorgio’s.
Walking in, there was quite a long line, but it moved relatively fast. Their slice selections and combos are very well laid out. The employees were working hard and were super nice.
I got the combo #4 (which is one slice of a choice of topping, 2 breadsticks, choice of sauce, and a medium drink). It wasn’t all that expensive. Honestly pretty cheap!
And what are my thoughts? The pizza is amazing! The toppings were seasoned super well, the cheese was melty, and the crust was super crispy! The breadsticks were also soft and fluffy, and overall were fantastic!
Overall, if you’re in it for a NYC style slice while in Indy, Giorgio’s is a good recommendation from me! I’ll definitely stop here again if I get the chance.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes