Service wasn't the best, as waitress never came back to check on us and we had to ask another waitperson for water, and I believe one shouldn't have to.
Big slice of pizza is good, with each topping costing 70 cents, as is House Salad with lemon vinaigrette. My friend liked his Atomic Burger.
Seems a busy place, has two bars at two different levels - one higher than the other. There's a pool table in back and a bull skull on wall.
🍕 Great place for NY style pizza in Denver, no complaints here!
Idk why the reviews for this place are such a mixed bag, but I *almost* let that stop me from trying it out.
On a whim, I ordered delivery for lunch because I didn't have time to go out and grab food. The pizza arrived hot, fresh, and earlier than the stated timeframe. (Kudos to my delivery driver, she was great!)
The pizza was HUGE and tasted great. It had that crispy/chewing crust but was thin enough to fold in half - just perfect. I ate two slices and was more than satisfied, there were 8 slices total. Plenty for leftovers!
S/N: I love that they have the ordering and delivery process integrated, I just went to Fat Sully's website and checked out. No need to install a million apps or go to another wesbite.
Now my only regret is not ordering the waffle fries, but I'll just have to try those next time.
Definitely recommend giving this place a try, either stop in for a slice or grab a whole pie!
Love Fat Sully's! A single slice is a meal. They are huge slices, true New York style. Fold it in half and mongia.
Thems some big pizzas - and I like big pizzas. Really though...some good thin pizza to highlight your favorite toppings. Folding is required!
This place is great for a lot of different “dates” friend date, 1st date, date night. They have NY style pizza slices that you can add toppings to. This is perfect when a group of friends can’t decide on what to get. They have this Amazing chipotle ranch dip sauce that they make in house . They also have build your own 26” pie ( if you don’t know how big that is because you’ve been lied to about how big 6” is, just know it’s way bigger than that)!! They also have these waffle fries that are FIRE. They toss them in this magic seasoning that’ll have you ordering the full portion every time. Aside from this they also have some other bar like food & a salad for everyone that has the best combination of Ingredients that’s worth trying. They have many options for draft beer, cocktails, & even mocktails. Last but not least, they have board games. So grab some friends, order a pie & play a game while you wait!
We always make it a plan to go here when we come into town. My New York husband is is very picky about his pizza and he absolutely LOVES this place! Highly recommend getting a slice for 2 if you can handle the big sizes!!
A really fantastic pie. First time ordering and I got 1/2 cheese and 1/2 supreme style. You can fold the slices in half like NY style and the tomato sauce is delicious!
I recently tried the 20-inch pepperoni pie at Fat Silly's Pizza, and it was nothing short of amazing! 🍕 For just around $20, you get an enormous pizza that's perfect for sharing with friends or family.
The crust was crispy on the outside and wonderfully soft on the inside, and the pepperoni had that delicious, slightly spicy kick that I love. The generous amount of cheese and rich tomato sauce made each bite a delight.
Not only was the pizza fantastic, but the service was also top-notch. The staff was friendly and accommodating, and my order was ready promptly.
If you're in Denver and craving delicious pizza, look no further than Fat Silly's. It's a must-visit spot for pizza lovers, and I can't wait to go back for more! 🤤🍕
#FatSillysPizza #DenverEats
If you are from New York like me, you have found your new favorite local pizza slice. For a real taste sensation, go inside and order a whole pie! It is enormous! The closest thing to a New York Pizza you will find in Denver.
Pizza was great but I made a huge mistake of ordering the 26” pie in house with only two of us to eat it. My girl and I are very medium sized people and my god this thing is huge. That said we loved the food and had plenty of leftovers. The take out pie seems to be a more classic size. Been back a bunch because it’s just good stuff.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Denver
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes