Professional Eater Mike
+4.5
Excellent prices and very good pizza. The first thing you need to know about Carlos Pizza is that it's in the mall and if you go in the winter, it will be absolutely freezing because it's right next to the door. The second is that the pizza in the display case is for display only, the pieces you order are kept under the counter to be heated up in the oven. Normally, pizza that gets reheated in the oven is better for texture because the bottom finally gets crispy. So make sure to tell the guys behind the counter to leave your pizza in for longer because when mine came out, it was not crispy yet.
The prices are extremely reasonable with two giant pieces and a drink for something like $5. This is also what makes it very appealing to the local Columbus school kids who have open lunch. Come 1130-45, the place gets saturated with them.
The value and ability are there for Carlos Pizza to be a great choice for your next pizza craving, but in this guys opinion, Zwanzig's still reigns supreme for the best tasting pizza in town.
Amazingness. This is the greatest place to get breadsticks and there cheese aka golden necter from the gods is so good that your taste buds will explode.
Pizza:). Carlos pizza is the best pizza in columbus... maybe the best in Indiana:) ive been going there cents i was a kid and every time i go there he gives us a free cheese... carlos was the bigest role model for a kid with no dad like me
NYC in Col IN. This is the closest thing we have in Columbus to NY pizza. They are also the friendliest pizza place in town!
"You got it sweetie!"
Tell Carlos you want it "New York Style" and he'll keep it in the oven a bit longer to get those nice brown spots on the cheese.
We lived on this stuff when undergoing a kitchen reno. Cheap too. ~$11 for a large cheese pie.
Best calzones around. Their NYC style pizza is tasty, but there's no topping the calzones. I've heard Zwanzigz' called the best in town, but that's always by people who've never had Carlos'.
This place has got to be my favorite place in indiana. Beyond the friendly service the food is delicious. The pizza is the best New York style pizza hands down and if you're a native new yorker this is it guys, you will be mentally transported & you will not be disappointed in anyway. The guy who makes the pizzas is the best & its just like being in a NY pizzeria with his witty banter and sarcasm. The prices are on point and I can't wait to try some of the pasta.
This is a hidden gem amongst pizza restaurants. The staff are very friendly and I have a very pleasant experience with them. I go there so often to the point where they started memorizing my order, and it makes me happy to know they care about their customers. Would be 10/10.
Bought 4 pizzas for a company lunch. Best New York Style pizza in Columbus, Indiana. Perfect balance between toppings and dough. Huge pizza. Excellent value! Ordered ahead and pizza was coming out of the oven when I arrived. Excellent service!
Super friendly service and great food! This is a great place to go that's not only budget friendly but fantastic quality. Easily a great lunch or dinner stop.
Best pizza in Columbus big slices and really nice owner and the other dude perfect date spot to take your girl combo meal 1 is the way to go fills you up and cheap!
I’ve been eating here since I was in high school, I love this place and the people! It doesn’t matter how long it’s been, they still know my order. The pepperoni breadsticks are my fav but I have not had one bad thing!
Best pizza in town. Pepperoni Breadsticks are absolute bangers. It's the best NYC styled pizza I've ever had.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Columbus
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes