Was in town for a concert and happened upon this place and decided walk in on a whim while I was out exploring and killing time before the show. Good atmosphere, good beer selection, good food, good service. Great happy hour prices too. Had two craft beer pint drafts and a 12 inch margherita pizza and only racked up a bill of $11 and change. I also appreciate that the bartender brought me a glass of water without me needing to request it and made sure my water glass stayed full. Hydration is key so I appreciate that. Haha Anyway, I'd definitely visit again.
We absolutely love this place! The atmosphere, great beers, the best cheeseburgers ever and the brussel sprouts are amazing!! We found this place while visiting Columbus in April of last year & made sure to visit again on this trip. Highly recommended!
If you’re looking for a mix of hometown plus comfort food this is it. I loved the lobster Mac. Also the Reuben eggrolls were 3.8/5 pretty solid taste. My guy is BIG on texture and he said it was a hit. I wish that the dipping sauce had a little something else, maybe heat, maybe more salt…But overall pretty tasty. I love love love the decor. The pictures, the murals, everything points back to Columbus history and I love it. Staff 10/10. People came to watch the game and they did. I think this would be a perfect first date kind of place. The burger was hyped up online but I thought it was ok. Needed more flavor 2.8/5. Overall nice restaurant, nice ppl. We will be back.
We came here to celebrate after wedding dress shopping nearby! We went a little after 12 on a Saturday and there was plenty of seating. By the time we left, it had gotten pretty crowded. The tomato soup was soooo good. Very creamy and flavorful. We ordered the group mimosas and it comes with an entire bottle of champagne and as many flavor mixers as you would like. Great deal for the price! The atmosphere was very laid back but felt upscale at the same time. Service was good as well.
Came here on a Sunday afternoon with 2 friends. All of our meals were excellent! We got pasta, the chicken sandwich, French onion soup and a burger. Their homemade chips were delicious - seasoned and slightly spicy! Can’t wait to come back and try some other items on their menu.
What a great fun place! It took a while to get in but, the wait on a Saturday night was so worth it! One of us had a delicious pepperoni pizza, another had Arch City burger, Amish Chicken sandwich and the Market Burger! All was excellent! The special blend of beef is so good! The fries were very good! Our server Megan M. Was on it! Great background dance style music 🎵! This was one of the most fun places I have been in a while!
Saturday night was my first visit to Arch City. Busy, but relaxed - I got the feeling that most of the patrons had been there a thousand times. A mature, cultured, and unpretentious atmosphere. The food was outstanding and all my friends loved their cocktails.
But I was most impressed with our server, Maggie. She was authentically warm, punctual, and enthusiastically professional. Exactly on time when we needed her help, and not hovering the table when we didn't. Wonderful stuff. By the end of the night it felt like I had been there a thousand times myself - thanks again Mags.
We'll be back to see you again very soon!
The blueberry mock tail was amazing. We had them add vodka. Perfect cocktail. The Mac and lobster was flavorful and full of meat. It was just the right amount of cheesy goodness. Wish it was a larger portion. Salad was perfect . The chocolate cake desert wasn't the best . I would just pass next time. Great overall experience.
My wife and I had a great meal at the bar. My wife really loved her burger (and she is a bit of a burger aficionado), and I thought their French Onion soup was one of the best I have had out in a while. The cocktails were also very good and they had a pretty decent beer selection. Definitely one we'll be back to.
I really like this place. Great gastro pub type food that is pleasantly prideful of their culinary creativity. Yes, a lot of alliteration to make your mind as happy as your belly will be (and your taste buds). Awesome happy hour for deals on food and drinks - had the Smoked Tavern Old Fashioned, it was good but not super stellar. Got the pork sliders with truffle fries - absolutely delicious. Service was great, food came quick and overall had a great time. Came back two days later just to drink beer. Will be back!
Grown / mature bar and restaurant with a great vibe. I’m hoping it always stays like this.
The service was great and food was amazing!
The tavern is obviously in a historic building. The hamburger was delicious, and the truffle fries were good. The moscow mule has a very strong ginger beer taste (which I like), but it may be too strong for some. The wings were good but needed more flavor variations. The mixed drink menu needs to be larger. Overall, it's pretty decent.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Columbus
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes