MERVE NAJA
Cute cheesecakes, fresh pies, friendly staff, reasonable prices. Their polka dot cheesecake is gluten free. They have mini fruit pies and full size pies and cheesecakes on hand all the time. I have yet to try the coffee here but it smell’s pretty great every time I walk in here. They also have pizza friday where whole pie pizzas are like less than $10
missaffliction
I have had the polka dot cheesecake and the mango margarita pie twice each and they are devastatingly good. I would kill for the recipes. The polka dot cheesecake has almond flavor to it, delicious. And the mango margarita pie is so smooth and has tajin sprinkled on top which is just… *chefs kiss*
Edit: have been back several times! Mango margarita is seasonal, but they do have the polka dot cheesecake always!
Li Ho
Very good pie. Unique flavors. Let the pie sit at room temperature before enjoying
Li Bruno
Quiet happy place for lunch! Tastty barbacoa sandwich, generous side salad and the blueberry hand pie was delicious!
Lydia
Peanut butter pie was not mind blowing like I hoped… still good and pretty reasonable price. But just tasted like eating regular peanut butter which I can eat out of a jar at home lol
Maybe I’ll try a different flavor next time :)
Mykiyah Jackson
BEST pie place ever !! i had the duck confit and the pear goat cheese panini and it was very delicious. Veggies were extremely fresh and everything was seasoned perfectly. Also got the key lime pie and toffee coffee pie and they were the best desserts ever. Could really taste the intended flavors and not overly sweet. Staff was very friendly and the locals who join in are very open. Join in to study, quick lunch date, or stop in when you want a carefully crafted cozy meal :)
ana torres
been coming here since i was little and its still so good years later!!! the pie is the standout obviously but their food and coffee is phenomenal too! not to mention the wonderful homey vibe to the place.❤️❤️
Pop Zack
always a wonderful fresh selection. Fresh roasting coffee all the time. And the staff are absolutely wonderful.
Gabrielle Musacchio
Always near and always come for coffee but finally tried some of their Thanksgiving eats... Chicken pot pie and pecan pie were divine!
Pecan Pie was one of the best I've had!
Moore Kelly
Such a treat! My first time there. I went for lunch and had the duck confit sandwich with chips and a latte. Sandwich was delicious combination of flavors and the pie was even better!!! Can’t wait to go back.
Grace Margaret
Love everything I have tried at all locations,great food, service, and mission. I just visited the new Evanston location at Church and Dodge this morning, 2 blocks from my house, and it didn't disappoint! Excited to have it so close by!
Teresa Neumann
We had First Slice cater our wedding in Andersonville. The pies were incredible.
Our guests raved about the chocolate peanut butter, cherry, apple, key lime, French silk and the pecan. I highly recommend them for any catering event, especially a wedding.
Antonio Ruiz
We had the pecan pie and the apple pie.both were great.looking foward to trying the food
Scott Galassini
The best pies I ever tasted! We tried the coffee toffee, the key lime & the chocolate raspberry!!! All were outstanding!!!
Jackie Blue Lazzari
What a great find! This was my go to place for pies but now it is my go to place to feed my family as well. The weekly food subscription has seriously improved my quality of life. We receive 3 entrees and 6 sides each week prepared with great detail and attention to great taste. The selections are appealing to both parents and children. We look forward to the new menu every week and it saves me so much planning, shopping, cooking, and cleaning. We love it!
Kayleigh Granato
Absolutely amazing! Me and the people I was with tried several different kinds of pie, and all of them were excellent! The Arnold Palmer was amazing too!
Eric Schulz
Absolutely amazing pies! I've tried both the Coffee Toffee and Apple. The Apple was the perfect balance of sweet and tart and PACKED with apples! Can't wait to try more.. and the rest of their menu.
Jim O'Reilly
Great start to the day. Great strawberry rhubarb pie.
Linda Acosta
Delicious pie and coffee priced perfectly! Super nice staff.
Gerald Cernak
Super yummy, it's a must in Andersonville! ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Marie McDermott
Stopped by last night, hoping to grab dessert with Friends. Their air conditioner was broken - had to be 90 degrees in there. I was fine with getting my pie to go, but who would make your employees stay open in such conditions? Grabbed a slice of Michigan Sour Cherry (which was fantastic- 5 stars) and a slice of Traditional Apple (nothing to write home about - 2 stars).
Sandra Casteneda
My favorite place to go have brunch with my daughters. �
Eddie Castro
Definitely won't be my last slice, incr-edible pies and delicious grub,everytime I go to purchase one mini" I can't believe I ate the whole thing" pie ,I walk out with three pies .....scrum diddly umptiois on all accounts. ..
Chelsea Milligan
Phenomenal place to eat, work, and enjoy! Thankful for places like these that truly DO MORE.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes