Sam Chewleff
I’ve been hearing good things about Scalini Fedeli for a few years now, so when my wife and I finally got a babysitter for a night we decided to try it for the first time. The first impression we got was just how incredibly charming the restaurant is. Kinda like upscale farmhouse chic. We were early for our reservation so the hostess politely informed us our table wasn’t quite ready and offered us a glass of Prosecco. When we were seated in the dining room we were immediately impressed by the curved vaulted ceilings and large columns that sort of broke the room up into smaller sections. Overall very cozy and comfortable feel. The service was very prompt and very accommodating. We got the feeling that everyone truly wanted us to enjoy our experience. The food was excellent but perhaps had a couple imperfections: for example my pappardelle with ossobucco and marrow jus was utterly dominated by an overwhelming flavor of rosemary. And my duck breast was good, but I’m not quite sure I would order it again. The star of our show was my wife’s linguini carbonara. Simple, classic (American style: with cream instead of egg yolk) but silky, savory and exactly what you want when you order carbonara. We added a course that I loved as well: butternut squash agnolotti in brown butter and sage. Decadent. And the “primi piccolo” (kind of like an amuse bouche) was excellent as well. Overall Scalini Fedeli comes in at 4.75 stars due to some nit-picking on my part (at a restaurant of this caliber the server should crumb the table in between courses) but we had an excellent experience and a fantastic date night.
Janet L
Absolutely wonderful experience with both the food and service. The restaurant itself is warm, inviting and charming, with knowledgeable servers and well made drinks. Had an amazing dining experience and would love to return soon.
Steve Looney
Excellent!! Beautiful room, attentive service and super eats... For a special night...
stealth yacht
Great Sat night dinner destination. Dress up desired, great date night place. We do family events there. Pricey but BYOB makes it better! Try the lobster linguini dish, fabulous! TRUFFLE RAVIOLI AS an appetizer! Staff is quiet and professional. Make reservations a week ahead. Flaw is its crammed table to table but the ambiance is nice.
Brian Yates
Enjoyable fine dining experience, the egg ravioli was great and the chocolate truffle cake was incredible. Atmosphere was really cool and unique being in an old spacious house revamped into a restaurant. Prices are what you'd expect for a fine dining experience in Chatham. Parking is valet
Tom S
One of the best meals NJ has to offer. I have been to the Tribeca location a handful of times and this location is just as good. It is also about $60 cheaper for the prefix so if you are trying to fine dine on a budget you can't beat the $100 price. Smoked tuna, shrimp, pasta, salad, sorbet, porkchop, cheesecake for $100. All the food was perfect, as you can see from my photos. The restaurant itself is also very beautiful. I would highly recommend it.
Leslie Carrasquillo
My experience proved why this restaurant receives 5 stars. From the service to the delicious food, the entire evening was perfect. Set in an old house with tapestries on the walls and an old world charm it offers a wonderful price fixe menu with something for everyone.
Alexander Kontoleon
Amazing Italian fine dining. The atmosphere is great, the food is amazing, the service was on point, it was an all around great experience. I had the pappardelle with ragu as a primi, and the veal chop milanese as a secundi. Both were outstanding. The house the restaurant is located in is filled with charm and decorated in a warm and inviting way. Cant wait to go back.
Justine DK
I took my mom here for her birthday, and everything was amazing. My mom is extremely hard to please, but our waiter Daniel was exceptional. They went above and beyond. The drinks, food, and the little extra touches all really add to that extra special experience. Will definitely be going back!
Amy Fox
Always a wonderful dining experience. The warm atmosphere is pleasant. The food is amazing .
Anthony Popola
Dined with my wife daughter and her boyfriend, this place was amazing! Great food, nice atmosphere and impeccable service! Having been to the Soho location, this one is even better, we will definitely be returning!
Stephanie McCloskey
Overall the place was great! Will definitely be back for the ambiance. The menu is nice because it’s prefix but I think it could use a bit of modernisation in terms of style. Would definitely recommend.
Lewis Lane
Excellent service..food was delicious...thanks for making the birthday celebration special
George E
Wonderful dining experience from the moment you walk in until you leave. The entire staff is amazing, and the food is phenomenal.
Isabela manages the restaurant and ensures that all runs smoothly, a true gem.
Our waiter, Alex, is friendly, knowledgeable and attentive.
Along with Isabela and Alex, the entire team are pleasant and there for you.
Kudos to the chef and the kitchen crew - "WOW" just sums it up.
The menu alone will whet your appetite - we had the BEST pork chops (medium).
Blake Carrington
We had dinner here and loved it. (family of 4 - 2 10 year old girls). The food was excellent and even though they have a menu that can accommodate kids, our kids ordered from the regular menu. We all had different dishes and everyone loved the food. Also, the service was excellent. We will return for sure.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes