Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Key lime pie in Chatham

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Pisces Restaurant
88/100 (406 ratings)
Restaurants
American
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Seafood
Gluten Free Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Dinner
Calamares
Salmon
Shrimp
Chowder
Lobster
Pasta
Cod
Salad
Swordfish
Scallops
Halibut
Clams
Octopus
Oyster
Key lime pie
Calamari
Bananas Foster
Risotto
Pesto
Fish
Mussels
Profiteroles
Tuna
Sit down
American
Seafood
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Validated Parking
Valet Parking
Reservations
Breakfast
Dinner
Fine Dining
"The service was awesome, Carl was most efficient and personable. The food was spectular. I had the risotto of the day with pan seared scallops, so..."
Colleen Baldelli
"Pisces served a meal that from our drink to appetizer to main course to dessert was flawless. Amazing atmosphere, phenomenal food with perfect..."
Eileen Kammerer
"Delicious food, yummy cocktails, great wine list, excellent service! We will be..."
Sueann Waryas Van Buren
"Awesome staff! Delicious food and desert!..."
Ryan Oliver
"Unroll that menu and take your taste buds on a journey that you will never forget. It will leave you longing for..."
Brent Phillips
"Great place, great food!! I had one of the best surf&turf..."
Jomara Cardoso
"Great food! Great service! Nice atmosphere. Definitely an again..."
Mitchell F. Kaufman
"Perfect Place. Delicious. Very small but very charming. Defenetely worth..."
Michael Maendler
"Absolutely wonderful, portions were perfect and food was beyond mouthwatering. Octopus appetizers should be offered a main course it was that..."
Nellie Cabral O'Donnell
"Simple the best dining experience on the..."
Paul Gass-Feeley
"Absolutely the best of everything! Food, service &..."
Nicole Diamantas Bassi
"Excellent- everything is made to order. Love the hummus, my fav is spring salad with seared scallops & risotto special every pm. Plan ahead & make..."
Ceil Harrigan
"By far the BEST restaurant in town! The freshest food and great service! Can't wait to go..."
Christina Sequin Bassett
"All Good! Will return with family next..."
James Gleason
"Thoroughly enjoyed our dinner at Pisces! Very small, somewhat choppy sections for the tables but the food was very good! The rib eye steak was..."
Kim Mai
"If you're looking for a night out in Chatham, with some dynamite, fresh seafood fare, add this to your list. On the Cape its hard to find a bad..."
Alexander Kontoleon
"Exceeded expectations. We flew into Boston from Florida today and by the time we got to Chatham we were travel weary. Thankfully and gratefully we..."
AA Hice
"Amazing dinner with great service. Warm and welcoming place. Good variety of delicious cocktails. Each dish was beyond excellent. Each dish was..."
Chris Walkley
"Between the corn chowder, the coconut salmon, the swordfish risotto and the Tres Leches cake, I couldn't have asked for a better meal on the Cape!..."
James Gnann
"I messed up the date for our reservation and they made an exception and got us in. A party of six, and they accommodated our group with a..."
Sueann Van Buren
"Sue and team are exceptional. We always look forward to going to Pisces. Service is causal, warm and friendly. On arrival there is small valet..."
LSE
"A small place but the food and service was amazing, I had lobster ravioli and it was great. Be sure to add this place to your visit to Chatham,..."
c Thompson
"Consistently one of the best meals on Cape Cod. Absolutely loved our selections (drinks, chowder, salad, entrees, and dessert). The asparagus,..."
Jordan Schnell
"Phenomenal dining experience! The food was perfect, and the wait staff was excellent! Thank..."
Lee Johnson
"Great little find. Excellent food and service. The lobster ravioli was amazing. Definitely planning to go..."
Sara Gelpke
"Service and food are very good! We had several appetizers and entrees as there we were a party of four. The only course I was a little disappointed..."
Donna Barreiro
"Food is always good, especially the lobster ravioli. Service very good. One word of caution: there’s no parking and the valet is always a bit busy..."
Seth Chodosh
"Inexpensive considering this is true cuisine prepared by two chef partners who have amazing skills. We visited due to a recommendation from our..."
Get mikie 2eatit
"Glad to have a wonderful meal and friendly caring service during rough times due to COVID-19. Outdoor dining, social distancing practices, masked and..."
EBH
Marion's Pie Shop-
86/100 (1165 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Bakeries
American
Vegetarian Friendly
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Breakfast
Lunch
Hamburgers
Lasagne
Key lime pie
Shrimp
Quiche
Beef
Meringue
Apple pie
Lobster
Pasta
Cakes
Salad
Fish
Mac and cheese
Scallops
Clams
Lobster Roll
Cod
Burger
Café
American
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Parking Available
Accepts Credit Cards
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"Yum yum yum! Has Marion's grown over the years! It's been quite a number of years since I've been to the Cape, and I was (not) very surprised that..."
Helen Jean Stipo
"This is honestly the best pie I have ever had. I killed an entire Rhubarb pie myself amd then came back for more the next day. 5 stars, hands down..."
Sapientia Thomas
"OMG, if you love pies, you must stop at this gem! Key Lime is our favorite but there are lots more to enjoy! All fantastic! On our way out of town..."
Sueann Waryas Van Buren
"Went in looking for a chocolate silk pie and the women says try the Boston cream pie as it was her favorite. Didn’t catch her name but wanted to..."
Mitchell Louis
"I stopped by and picked up a chicken pie with gravy and a cherry pie while I was staying in W.Yarmouth. they were so delicious I would drive the 96.8..."
Kathleen McManus Allen
"Love Marion's Pie Shop! Just got back from Chatham and had both their savory and sweet pies. The crust melts in your mouth..."
Pamela Pakey
"This place is amazing. Baked goods are fresh and delicious. Chicken pot pies are our favorite. Even comes with gravy on the side. I stock up for the..."
Tammy Hare
"Such delicious pies! I can’t wait to go back and try some of the other goodies on the..."
Tami Conn
"Stumbled on this place while driving around on vacay. Cookies were delicious, as were the pies. Staff was so friendly and..."
Jimmy Bee
"What’s not to love about yummy chicken pot pies..."
Holly Abate
"Honestly, this was the best pie we’ve ever had! We purchased a razzle berry pie and the next day came back for a cherry pie. Today I am going back..."
Zoe Swartz Koston
"So happy we came across this little gem out on the Cape!!! The pies are amazing and well worth the..."
Michael J Farrell
"What’s not to love?? Delicious muffins, cookies and pies. When you go be sure to try the Chatham Muffins-..."
Jim Pressman
"The Beef Pie we brought home from our trip was pure EVIL....so delicious, we cannot stop talking about it...."
Diane Tufts
"Razzleberry pie is our absolute favorite! Have been going for..."
Alec Schwartz
"Go all the time... great hermits and turnovers- All our..."
Genevieve St.Louis Jan
"I absolutely LOVE Marion’s Pie Shop—easily some of the best pies and bakery goods down on Cape Cod! I always come here at least once or twice a..."
Alex Issokson
"First time in Cape Cod and we were super excited to try this place. We ordered the shepherds pie, hamburger pie, macaroni and cheese, apple pie, and..."
Michael Tunick
"We used Marion’s Pie Shop for our wedding desserts and we cannot recommend and thank Cindy and her team enough! They went far above and beyond to..."
Elise LeBlanc
"My girlfriend loved the slice of Bumbleberry pie we got but while I think it was well made with good ingredients, the filling was under sweetened and..."
Viraj Patel
"Not do crazy about the chicken pot pie we got... very few veggies... granted got tons of chicken and the extra gravy bucket comes in real handy. The..."
Larry Hazen
"I'm a New Zealander and we are pretty fussy about our pies which are considered a national dish. My brother and I stopped by and grabbed the..."
Louise Baddiley
"For our Cape Cod wedding in June, we decided to skip the traditional cake and go with something different. Marion’s Pie Shop was the clear choice,..."
Amy Gentile
"I have not had their dessert pies, but the savory Seafood pie and chicken pie are excellent! Pick one up , add a quick salad and you got yourself a..."
Adolfo Diaz
"Best carrot cake you will ever have. We always buy the Bumbleberry pie which is awesome. This week we tried the carrot cake and it's the tastiest,..."
Cheryl Saunders
"We stopped just before closing. Staff was very happy to explain items to us and offer us what was left. We purchased a small chocolate cream pie!..."
Michelle Iler
"not exaggerating— best pie I’ve ever had. Baked fresh and melts in your mouth. And they have savory treats too??? Do yourself a favor and stop by..."
Emma Popowski
"We dropped by Marion’s Pie Shop for the first time a few days ago and were delighted to discover their assortment of sweet and savory pies and..."
Anna Romanov
"Wowza!! Literally the BEST pie I ever ate! Get the BaileyBerry Pie, large. Actually, get two! Wish I'd tried the Clam Pie, bought for my house host,..."
Mary McPartland
"Picked up a couple of pies, strawberry and rubarb, and a hamburger. Both were delicious and as a Kiwi (New Zealander), the pie tastes just like one..."
Kev Alexandra
"Absolutely delicious! Crust is amazing. Fruit pie is not too sweet. Chicken pot pie and quiche are spot..."
C Smith
"Wonderful set up. Cozy and welcoming. I got a chix pot pie too. Great..."
p walkie
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use