The best Frozen Yogurt in Chatham | Sluurpy updated in May

Buffy's Ice Cream Shop

76/100 (437 ratings)

Dessert

American

Ice Cream

Frozen Yogurt

Café

American

Wheelchair Accessible

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Cheap Eats

"Best Peanutbutter ice cream..."

Liz Des Cognets Champagne

"Pink Explosion! My daughter dove into a strawberry ice cream and pink sprinkle cup of deliciousness! We’ve never stumbled upon pink sprinkles..."

B C

"Thinking about the girl who posed for a photo for her social media and them promptly handed it back to her man exclaiming, “Here, I don’t want..."

Teresa S

"The cookies that surround the home made ice cream bar are baked by hand by my friend, Nolan Linsky...."

Fran Marci-Glenn

"Great ice cream and great people that run this shop. As visitors to the area, we have been to get quarts of Heath bar vanilla ice cream 3 times. Just..."

Alf Raju

"I ordered maple walnuts which is great! It’s not over sweetened and the walnuts smell great. They made these two in a perfect..."

Claire Chiang

"Tried the most popular cookie dough sandwich and the special snickerdoodle sandwich. Both were out of this world! The cookies were the perfect..."

Morgan Milhomens

"Great ice cream place. We went in for some ice cream after eating dinner nearby. Quick service and tasty ice cream. Two spoons way..."

John McCarthy

"Amazing homemade ice cream. Loved the coconut oreo and the waffle cone. It tasted so fresh. Social distancing inside and great outdoor seating area...."

Sahara Marte

"This place is absolutely amazing. How good? Let’s just say Chatham Bars Inn is second best. Now to figure out how to bring some..."

Corey Rethage

"Really, really, really good ice cream and the staff is very friendly and helpful when you are trying to make your choice. There are also picnic..."

David Ryan

"Very good ice cream in the heart of Chatham. We went on early evening one Saturday and the lines were not too bad. They have some outdoor seating as..."

Shahzad Zia

"Amazing ice cream, I had the Banana Boat, it was huge but..."

Laura Nedelcu

"I had their blackberry ice cream in a waffle cone and it was the best ice cream I had in all of Cape Cod! There was a marshmallow and delicious..."

Sue Cluck

"A great little ice cream and milkshakes. An easy 5 star..."

Andy Davies

"oh wow, that milkshake was amazing. Would recommend if you’re..."

ShownLettuce430

"Delicious ice cream!! We got milkshakes and ice cream bars and they were some of the best we’ve ever had. We talked with the owner and he was..."

Allie Turner

"With the tons of choices of ice cream on the Cape you may miss a place like this. This spot sits in downtown Chatham and is near the end of the town...."

Matthew Liptak

"I love the variety of flavors here! Nice place to stop by especially as the weather warms..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Frozen Yogurt in Chatham

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters