I have ate here a few times and was always satisfied with the food and staff, however, I would like to know if this business is still open......I'm under the impression they shut down. please set my mind at ease. email me @ billy_schmarje@yahoo.com. Thanks.
Pizza, BBQ and Fried Chicken are all subject to personal taste but you just can't go wrong with Pagliai's Pizza! The toppings are all fresh and the best quality meats around. Crust is yummy! It's a great place for families too!
Awesome pizza, great service, and a very good family atmosphere. We stopped in this evening with our 3 boys ages 6, 5, and 2. The pizza and dough was all hand made and tasted wonderful. My wife and myself had the Everything pizza. It was so loaded with toppings we could barely eat half a medium. We ordered the boys a small pepperoni. They loved it and they are picky eaters. Very friendly to toddlers too. High chair came covered in Saran Wrap with colors or animals cookies. It was very clean and not like other restaurants that throw them in the corner and never clean them! We were very impressed and will be frequenting Pagliai's more often
Jonathan E U Thomasson Sr.
+4.5
Great for a date night. My and my wife had dinner here on a recent date night. We tried ordered a small pizza, some garlic bread, and an order of pasta. Everything was prepared very well and the service was quick and friendly. The Pasta was cooked to a perfect al dente and the sauce had a good deep tomato flavor. The Pizza was also good and we had plenty of it left over for lunch the following day. We plan on taking the kids here soon as the place was also very family friendly.
Great pizza...but why not deliver??. Great, local pizza joint. Very good pizza. Nice crust. Good sauce. Actually got me and my wife's convoluted 1/2 this, 1/2 that, double sauce instructions correct without skimping.
But why not deliver?? We come from out of town and stay in a hotel. Would love to not have to drive the miles to pick up. Besides your parking lot is rather cramped. Please reconsider delivery!
Fantastic service and great pizza, you will not be disappointed
Hidden Gem!. We were spending the night in Cape Girardeau on the way to MS, and we decided to see what they had to offer as far as pizza was concerned. I saw rave reviews for this place called Pagliai's (Pronounced "Polly eyes"). We gave them a shot and were pleasantly blown away! We are pizza officianados and believe me when I tell you this pizza is good, IT'S GOOD! If you are ever in Cape Girardeau, try it! It's a must!
Good food!. They have very good pizza. The folks are nice. The pizza has a crisp crust. Good fresh toppings. Since they remodeled, their portions don't seem as generous- just my opinion. Overall, you will probably be happy with your pizza if you like a crisp thin crust. Their restaurant is very clean and the help is friendly.
By far the best pizza place in the area. Freshest ingredients and great atmosphere for any get together
Delicious pizza, pasta and appetizers in a laid back atmosphere. All the staff, waiter/waitresses are all great, they definitely keep your glad full no matter what you're drinking. Nice selection of adult beverages as well!
I'd highly recommend stopping in for a bite if you're in the area.
Sarah Caroline Mueller
+5
I was positively surprised to find that they could accommodate my dietary needs as a vegan, I ordered the baked veggie pasta and they even had vegan cheese. It was incredibly delectable. Salad bar also had some options. I was very pleased, would definitely visit again if I were in the area.
I liked the atmosphere of the place, and great service. However, let’s be honest - this is not Italian pizza. Probably, that is American adaptation of Italian style, but being in all parts of Italy and knowing what Italian pizza looks and tastes like - this is not the one. Nevertheless, the pizza they serve is tasty, nothing against. Just not Italian…
Just ordered take out and had to make some changes to one of the pasta dishes. The changes were right and the dish came out tasty. The rest of the order was equally delicious!! I had the baked spaghetti, and it totally hit all of the comfort food buttons. Highly recommend!
How have I never eaten here but grew up in Cape my entire life ?? 😂 Better late than never! 😉 Thank you, Matthew for the superb service !!! The food is BOMB.COM! I had a sandwich with ham & provolone & their yummy homemade red sauce and it was 🔥 my mom ate a sandwich as well- I also will be back so soon to try the pizza but 10/10 recommend stopping in!! 👌🏼
Great pizza parlor that's been a staple of Cape for decades. With continued excellence in delivering a quality pie, friendly staff, and nostalgic atmosphere, it has staked it's claim as among one of the best pies in MO, and will weather any storm.
I'd been wanting to try this for years and it did not disappoint. Friendly workers except for the one weird guy (who another employee told to knock it off), nice atmosphere, great music and great good. Pics and salad bar were top notch.
1st time customer. Loved it. Great atmosphere and wonderful food. Salad bar had fresh ingredients and the pizza was wonderful. Definitely will visit again
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Cape Girardeau
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes