Cafe 58
169 58th St, 11220-2515 - Brooklyn
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2021
#3262 of 3928 restaurants in Brooklyn
Updated on
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
60/100
Data Completeness
56/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (3)
Photo 1 / 3
100%
Google Reviews
115
Google reviews
The pizza here is actually really good. Best in the neighborhood for sure. Too bad they don't do evening or late night deliveries.
Google
I adore this place. It’s a cozy and calm haven on a gritty block of Sunset Park near the Brooklyn Army Terminal. The cooks prepare all the food fresh from scratch everyday, and the portions are very generous. If you like meat pizza, this is the place! But the best thing of all about Cafe 58 is Nick—the hard-working owner of the shop. He’s a real sweetheart.
Read more
Google
I honestly didn't have high expectations, it's the only thing close to the ferry, and surrounded by warehouses.
The pizza is amazing, the sauce in particular. I live in an Italian neighborhood in NYC, I eat a lot of good pizza, and this place stands up. I'm going back here every time I'm at that ferry stop.
Read more
Google
Order lunch from here many times. Their small pizza pies are $8 and very good. The lunch special on Thursday is pulled pork w mashed potatoes. Goes fast so order before 12 pm . They make an okay burger. Cheap fast delivered eats
Google
There food is amazing and it's a family owned business, that been in this area since I was a child. It taste amazing and the stuff are helpful and kind. I eat there often and they open early. Check them out .
Google
Great diner/pizzeria in an otherwise for dessert near the Army Terminal. They accept both cash and credit cards and the counter person was friendly. The space seats about 15 comfortably.
Google
Great place for breakfast. Pizza great too. Delivery mat take a while but that's because everyone is ordering. Owner and staff cool.
Google
I been eatting here since I was 17 years old . There food is well cooked and has flavor. There food is freshly made and its a family business. Go try there food if your ever in Brooklyn. I post on my Instagram the food I bought my ig is moonchild181.
Google
Explore more in Brooklyn
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: