Sluurpy
Reset

There are 14 restaurants

Best Sandwiches in Bainbridge Island

There are 14 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Jake's Pickup Grab 'n Go
93/100 (152 ratings)
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Deli
Barbecue
Healthy
Vegetarian Friendly
Healthy
American
Vegan Options
Barbecue
American
Deli
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Burger
Po' Boys
Pork
Beef
Salad
Tuna
Hot Dog
Sandwiches
Café
Healthy
Deli
American
Barbecue
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Accepts American Express
Free Wifi
Accepts Discover
Accepts Credit Cards
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Fantastic. From a quick meal to full on catering, Jake's delivers on all fronts. I even hear he has a generator to keep things going if the..."
Julie Peck Boss
"Had the egg salad sandwich, the salmon sandwich, the carrot cake, a breakfast sammy... ALL PERFECT!!!..."
Janice M. Danielson
"I love there Kale Salad! The best!! Everything else I have had is delicious as well! Organic, fresh and..."
Robin Callahan
"Best food around and friendly staff, by far my favorite place to go for lunch, and worth every..."
Jesse Tevault
"Just what I needed! Great fresh food and a reminder of my southern roots. Thank you Jakes Pick Up! Friendly and quick..."
Sara Bean
"Best kept secret on BI. Best salmon cakes, egg breakfast..."
Phil Herzog
"Every single thing I have eaten there has been..."
Bret Doc Black
"Had the most delicious Turkey sandwich yesterday, service exceptional. Have to go back and try the Big Block..."
Fred Araneda
"Great food, great people! Glad to have these folks in the community. Amazing salmon cake burger; actually tastes like salmon! Something not to take..."
Nikki Lounsbury
"Delicious fresh food. Best burger I've had in a long time. Sweet wonderful beet salad, inventive blueberry and broccoli salad. Really exceptional!!!..."
Diana Jacobs
"Favorite place to eat on Bainbridge Island! Marvelous! Jake and team totally..."
Bobbie Burkholder
"Love their BBQ and gluten free baked goods...ALL OF THEM..."
Tirza Marie
"This was a fantastic burger and fries!!! I was sad they were out of the Sconuts... Been dying to try them!!! Great customer service and friendly..."
Windy Rider Tuttle
"Great food and attitudes from the staff,..."
Josh Tuttle
"Just bought this delicious banana cake from Jake's. Wholly shmokes it's..."
John Beesley
"Great service! Jake and his staff is always professional and goes out of his way to make his customers happy. I'm kind of picky. The cold cut..."
Michelle Kyles
"If you think this is some "gas station food", you are missing out! this is gourmet food... invented, inspired, and delivered flawlessly from an..."
J Todd Larson
"I was finally able to try this place and it did not disappoint. The breakfast sandwich was one of the best I've ever had. From the bun, to the basil..."
Andrea
"Definitely worth it to stop at this gem of a place in a Chevron station! I know I know what you're thinking, restaurant inside a gas station?? No..."
Imran Mukati
"Amazing sandwich.. Although probably best not to customize it.. Roast turkey sandwich, added bacon and jalapenos.. Pricy, but..."
Chris Pick
Restaurant Marche
89/100 (618 ratings)
Restaurants
Gluten Free Options
French
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
French
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Brunch
Drinks
Dinner
Lunch
Tuna
Grilled cheese
Salmon
Crème Brulée
Shrimp
Halibut
Beef
Salad Nicoise
Creme Brulee
Croque Monsieur
Salad
Crab
French onion soup
Duck
Lamb
Fish
Oyster
Mussels
Sandwiches
Steak Frites
Burger
Sit down
French
Reservations
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Drinks
Brunch
Mid-range
"I can't say enough about the flavors of the food. The dungeonus (sp) crab oh gratin was fantastic as well as the trout with scalloped potatoes. Oh my..."
Michelle Mickey Cole
"We really enjoyed our dinner: oysters, french onion soup, duck breast and mussels. The side of bread that we were offered was warn with a great..."
Kaushik Veeraraghavan
"Best steak I've had at a restaurant on Bainbridge. Add to that the homemade catsup, aioli, and fries and I am food heaven. Consistently delicious..."
Matt Makowicz
"What a great find! Superior device, delicious food, I highly recommend this place. The chef gets 5 Stars! Thank you..."
Patrick Turnage-Lannan
"Omg the Moule Frites though... and Burger..and Market Veggie Plate...and chicken liver pate..and I could keep going, but you should just read the..."
Anita Chhun
"Always a delight to dine at the Chef's Counter at Marche. Ending my work week with a plate of oysters on the half, the Marche Martini (cardamom..."
Lisa B Martin
"Whether it's date night, dinner with friends, special occasion, or a quick bite in the bar, Marche is a wonderful experience. The goodness coming out..."
Julie Kapphan Davis
"Super classy place! I loved the food, the atmosphere, and I had a very polite..."
Blake Jackie
"Wow the food here is exceptional!! Always had such a great time, and my my what handsome kitchen..."
Ben Cox
"Best restaurant on Bainbridge Island! I've had almost everything on the menu and nothing has ever been anything other than great! Top..."
Gregory Duke Jr.
"The atmosphere is intoxicating with sights and sounds mixed with wafting aroma of fine cuisine. The owners greet you like a long lost friend..."
Sid Ball
"We’ve been dining here for many years and still love it after a three year absence. Chef Greg and Betsey do an amazing job turning out excellent..."
P A
"If you’re looking for traditional French food, this isn’t the place. Like another review said, there is actually more American dishes than French..."
Audrey Ike
"Long time favorite. The seasonally changing menu draws on fresh regional ingredients offered with two takes. There are always the French Bistro..."
Mason White
"It's been nearly 3 years since we've been back to Marché due to the pandemic and it was SOOO nice to be back. What's lovely about Marché is that..."
Matt McDonnell
"I love this place! Local amazing food. Great cocktails. And very warm and friendly staff. A perfect date night..."
Tia Schwarz
Streamliner Diner
89/100 (1534 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Cafe
Diner
Diner
American
Cafe
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Vegan Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Burrito
Eggs Benedict
French Toast
Breakfast Burrito
Toasts
Pasta
Meatloaf
Salad
Omelette
Crab
Waffles
Scallops
Waffles & Crepes
Salmon
BLT
Lasagne
Biscuits and gravy
Halibut
Lamb
Sandwiches
Pesto
Pork
Sit down
Café
American
Diner
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Outdoor Seating
Seating
Takeout
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"Love this diner. We are regulars for breakfast which is always fantastic. Last week I experimented with several selections on the new dinner menu. ..."
Tim Dixon
"I'm a born and raised islander, and Streamliner has been the go to for breakfast/brunch since I can remember. Through my life's travels, never has..."
Justin Berg
"This was my first time here and I absolutely loved it. The amazing food, the coziness, the friendly staff all blended to make it unique, memorable,..."
Amber Shaw
"This is a small, busy place, but the food is the best on Bainbridge Island. The service is slow due to the crowd. People are very..."
Dale Singleton Doeller
"Best breakfast on Bainbridge Island! Great nostalgic diner experience! Sat at the counter and watched the friendly engaging cooks work their magic..."
Tracy Bonham Myers
"The service was awesome, the food was phenomenal- best eggs Benedict and buscuits hands down!..."
Falishia Howard
"One of my favorite breakfast spots in the Seattle area! My favorite is the green eggs & ham (with pesto making them green). This place is easy to..."
Alex Porter
"My first time here, it was so good! I had the Morning Sauté with fresh fruit on the side. Delicious! When in Bainbridge, I will definitely be..."
Patti Cox Redmond
"Great service and excellent food! We had the spinach salad and it was delicious! Good coffee and a sweet waitress..."
Sara Rogers
"We had breakfast on a Tuesday. It was delicious! The homemade biscuits were divine, homemade raspberry jam, omelets, scrambles everything was..."
Kelly Togesen
"Great service. Great food. I will be..."
Christina Hayes
"My first time back there since 1995 and it was excellent..."
Mikel Travisano
"Excellent breakfast, possibly the best we had in Seattle. I had the omelette with sausage and other good stuff and the.hash browns with a strawberry..."
Tony C
"Excellent food with a good selection of breakfast options. Big helpings, my wife got a side order of biscuits and gravy and it was just right. Only..."
Dean Webb
"Service was exceptional. My dish was delicious. My boyfriend didn't really care for his huevos ranchero. My dish called the green machine was very..."
Cindy Sawyer
"New Review (August 2021) I came by on a busy Friday morning straight from the ferry, on the way out to the Peninsula. It's a very convenient place to..."
Steve Hiday
"I had the PNW Benedict and it was superb. My only issue was how large the serving and I couldn't finish it. Service was excellent and my only..."
Brandi Wagner
"Worth the wait. When you get off the ferry don't think that a better place to get you brunch beyond Streamliner diner, put your name on waiting list..."
Ruji Nithayapun
"Overall it was Great! The food, The Service and the Prices were all Great. The only thing i didn't like was that there wasn't much Elbow Room...."
Cameron Barnes
Doc's Marina Grill
84/100 (2833 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegan Options
Bar
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Grill
Gluten Free Options
Seafood
American
American
Grill
Seafood
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Brunch
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Halibut
Pork
Crab
Sandwiches
Prawns
Clams
Burger
Oyster
Hamburgers
Calamari
Cioppino
Risotto
Mussels
Tuna
Shrimp
Calamares
Salmon
Fish & chips
Lobster
Pasta
Chowder
Omelette
Salad
Fish & Chips
Kale Salad
Clam Chowder
Tapas
Pesto
Mac and cheese
Fish Taco
Tacos
Fish
Sit down
Bar
American
Grill
Seafood
Accepts Credit Cards
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Reservations
Waterfront
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Mid-range
"The best! The fish and chips were great. Fish had panko batter....crisp and lite, not that Olly mess from beer batter. peel and eat shrimp were..."
Leslie F Borrelli
"The Crab Risotto was amazing, especially with the Pinot Grigio, definitely squeeze the lemon on the perfectly tender calamari. Perfect view, and a..."
Jeny Jwow Johnson
"Great food, great atmosphere, friendly service. We live in Texas and had eaten there 5 years ago, where hubby fell in love with their lobster mac and..."
Suanne Gilleland
"Loved it. On a whim, I took the ferry from Seattle tho Bainbridge Isle. It was a particularly rainy day. On the way back to the ferry terminal, my..."
AJ Rodriguez
"Loved the atmosphere, view, food, and service. We had the crab risotto and the salmon aglio e olio. Both were absolutely delicious and very..."
Marsha Sosnow Epstein
"Wonderful food and service, would definitely recommend this..."
Donna Courville Menard
"We had a wonderful experience at dinner. Our server was outstanding and the food was delicious. We will definitely be coming..."
Julia Denis
"We had a party of 15 and a special menu Great food. Great service. Great view This is a wonderful venue all..."
Michelle Hopkins- Bretz
"Great view, service, food and drink! Our table had the fish and chips, clams, calamari, French dip and clam chowder. Everyone enjoyed their..."
Sally Mendel
"Beautiful view of the harbor and great food. The staff is friendly and helpful making for a great casual dinning..."
James Gott
"We took the ferry from Seattle to Bainbridge Island Friday afternoon,just to kill some time. Stumbled upon this nice restaurant in a beautiful..."
Robert Holshouser
"OH. DEAR. LAWDY. This place is good.... amazing Prime Rib and Chedder sandwich. The service was top notch and very attentive!!! Worth the ferry ride..."
Paul Sinclair
"Warm, covered outdoor separated seating area with large mounted fish decor and a view of the Marina. Excellent fish and chips (3 oz per fish) along..."
Danny
"Awesome staff! Super friendly and accommodating. Our food was great. It's been a long time since I've been here but I have to say much better than I..."
Diane Morrison
"Started with calamari, rings & tentacles served with this dish and very delicious. Fantastic mushroom risotto & add wild blackened salmon atop. Also,..."
William Espinosa
"A nice place with outdoor dining, with heaters and friendly staff. A little higher priced but I guess they call that "Island Prices" and these days I..."
Rebecca Williams-Bartella
"Absolutely amazing! We came for lunch and ordered a salmon entree with pasta and the clam linguine. We were not disappointed. We sat inside at the..."
Stacey Kinney
"This is second time we have been there. Service was excellent, they were super friendly and almost too fast. They did everything right. The food..."
Vipin Singh
"Great Bar & Grill right on the marina with outdoor seating, covered porch seating, and inside seating options. We had the cod fish & chips and the..."
Jackson Teal
"Waterfront dining and great food. My wife really loves this place and I can’t disagree. Tasty options and portions are generous. I’m a burger..."
Jon Bensen
Hitchcock
81/100 (672 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Beef
Pasta
Salad
Clams
Duck
Oyster
Salmon
Halibut
Confit
Octopus
Sandwiches
"We had an incredible dining experience yesterday while visiting Bainbridge Island. I had the moist, delectable pork chop "to die for" accompanied by..."
Diane Gravitt
"A very phenomenal experience. You start with a ferry Ride beyond compare and roll into the Island. Walk a few blocks of downtown into this very..."
Stephan Oxman
"Went with friends and family to try the Chef's Tasting. For $40 each, we were treated to seven courses, fifteen different items. None of the items..."
Joe Tomko
"We ate here on Saturday night and it was fantastic. We were just walk ins off the street but were greeted warmly and seated without an issue. ..."
Bob Tennant
"We just had dinner there with wine pairings. The food was wonderful. The pairings were really interesting, including Sherry's and varietals we hadn't..."
Rebecca Davis
"An amazing, amazing dinner last night at Hitchcocks. We did the tasting menu basically turning ourselves over to the chef and he didn't disappoint...."
Bill Hanson
"I highly recommend the chef's tasting. Delicious food courses, perfect variety, complementary wine pairings and and a fantastic view of the kitchen...."
Cristy Beech
"Amazing menu with locally procured ingredients worth the drive from..."
Jay Calabig
"Great New Year's Eve dinner!! Thank you! Great start to 2016. We have never been..."
Susan Hawkins Nakata
"The people are friendly and professional. The food is imaginative, locally-sourced, and delicious. The cocktails are fierce. What's not to..."
Lara O'Neal
"Outstanding Chef Selection dinner last night. What a fantastic way to celebrate our friends..."
Paul Pradel
"..."
Lasse Karlsson
"My Cousin Brendan has inspired me to try new foods and new experiences in the kitchen. Since 2005 I knew and still know what I want to be. Just like..."
Steve Garth
"Thanks Chef Brendan, and Quinton for a wonderful dinner tonight! Trying many different plates is the way to..."
Julie Stewart
"Seriously you must do the chefs..."
David Rogers
"Really enjoyed the food. We went for a quick lunch, the soup and pastrami sandwich was good, the turkey was just Ok, nothing special. Perfect quick..."
Polyanna Marcos
"Charming place with excellent cocktails! Impeccable service! Here for a bachelorette party & was brought complementary champagne and popcorn for the..."
Lindsey Halwes
"Best thing I can say about Hitchcock is they keep it simple. For the most part it is just a.sandwhich shop with a cocktail bar. The sandwiches are..."
Oremo Ochillo
"Incredibly expensive. $15 for 1 slice of gluten free toast with some avocado. It's half the size of non gluten toast. The food there is very..."
Auggie
Pegasus Coffee House
81/100 (1102 ratings)
Quick Bites
Coffee & Tea
Coffee & Tea
Cafe
Contemporary
Gluten Free Options
Cafe
American
Diner
American
International
Gluten Free Options
Brunch
Drinks
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Sandwiches
Café
Diner
International
Café
American
Contemporary
Takeout
Street Parking
Serves Alcohol
Live Music
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Digital Payments
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Waterfront
Dog Friendly
Seating
Outdoor Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Lunch
Drinks
Brunch
Breakfast
Mid-range
"The most unique cafe in the island. Great coffee, food, ambiance and innovative drinks. If you come to Bainbridge Island this must be one of your top..."
Elif Esra Baskaya
"Change is good. Had breakfast on a Sunday late morning. The breakfast biscuit was stellar. Simple ingredients with big taste. The small side of..."
Corrie Lyn Yadon
"Great locals joint that has their own roasted coffee on offer. Cozy with good wifi and great baristas. Was working today and had my coffee refilled..."
Stuart Moulder
"World class ambience and great staff creates a favorite place to..."
David W Cohen
"Great place to get breakfast and really good coffee. Warm, cozy and..."
Suellen Honeychuck
"Very friendly staff, our food was great, welcomes dogs on the..."
Lynda Castillo
"Excellent food of gourmet quality and coffee..."
Erin Gove
"Extremely cute coffee shop right on the water in Bainbridge. The coffee was delicious and I purchased a few bags to take home as gifts. The food was..."
Dustin Gunnells
"We’ve been to Bainbridge many times but never visited Pegasus until our most recent visit. Our failure! It’s the best coffee spot in Winslow and..."
P A
"I'd heard and read a lot about the place. The very first sight of the coffee shop from outside is really captivating. It has a nostalgic and..."
Pragya Agarwal
"The perfect start to the morning. We stayed at the Eagle Harbor Inn for a romantic weekend getaway, and it was fantastic to be able to cross the car..."
Tim Sneath
"Pegasus Coffee on Bainbridge Island is in an ivy-covered building, leaves turning yellow and brown when I visited. It looks like a house from a movie..."
Yü Wu
"The coffee I had here was truly decadent. Overall experience was very satisfying. I was welcomed by a friendly, youthful staff who gave both great..."
Nathan “Nate” Underwaterguy
"I absolutely love this cozy little shop, amazing locally roasted coffee served by some of the funniest and most awesome baristas I know. Please do..."
Ly Vu
Madison Diner
79/100 (1623 ratings)
Restaurants
Diner
Diner
Vegetarian Friendly
American
American
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Toasts
Grilled cheese
Hamburgers
Omelette
Waffles
Fish & chips
Fish
Beef
Pancakes
Salad
Salmon
Fish & Chips
Sandwiches
Eggs Benedict
Burger
Sit down
Diner
American
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Brunch
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Good NW style breakfast. Good value, generous portions so you can save some for later. I had two large cornmeal pancakes, eggs, and what tasted like..."
Clubmud
"A classic diner with great food. We have eaten here for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Breakfast is busy but we'll worth the wait. I always eat the..."
Ron Erickson
"Awesome burger. I had an awesome mushroom swiss burger there today, best burger I have had in a while, after arriving too late for Cafe Nola, which..."
Chandira
"This is the ultimate diner! Was worried after some reviews but tried it on our first visit to the island. It was very busy and we had to wait about..."
Oak71
"GF Patty Melt!!!. What an awesome diner! Featured on Diners, Drive Ins & Dives in 2007, this diner has all the personality it seemed too. To top it..."
Sara Vollmer
"A breakfast I now crave daily.. After seeing The Madison Diner on the Food Channel, I always kept this place in mind for my next visit to Bainbridge..."
Leslie
"Breakfast Burrito. Awesome! tasting, just the right amount of spicy... highly..."
BigMak
"Such a cute piece of history! The food is always so good! They treat you like family. The atmosphere is always pleasant. Amanda (waitress) is..."
Tara Short
"Great atmosphere and great service. The food was was good. We had breakfast which is standard breakfast fair. I have the corned beef hash and my wife..."
Roger Smith
"Real food - Real good! Friendly, helpful, disabled accessible!!! And we were blown away with how neat and clean the place was for being a retro..."
Beverly Jewett
"Great diner with a retro feel. Everything from traditional eggs n hash browns to creative Benedicts and daily specials. I most recently had the..."
Michael Guio
"This place is so awesome! Classic diner with super generous hospitality with the beach boys playing in the background! The atmosphere is fantastic..."
Mike y
"Great breakfast, and really wonderful staff. Our waitress explained all the current features and limitations, so we had no disappointments. We..."
Greg Key
"The Madison Diner had a very fun and warm atmosphere. The menu had some staples and inventive items. Food was great and will come again next time we..."
Jorge Santoyo
"Hands down best breakfast I have ever had! I had the hash browns with cheddar, scallions, bacon, a biscuit with 2 eggs. Me and my wife shared it and..."
Joe Hooker
Treehouse Cafe
73/100 (621 ratings)
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Pizza
American
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Pizza
American
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Sandwiches
Pasta
Salad
Pesto
Sit down
Pizza
American
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Television
Breakfast
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Mid-range
"Second visit here. Fantastic pizzas and quick service. Friendly atmosphere and a good vibe. Overall a great experience and will definitely be back...."
Stuninho
"My sandwich was fantastic. There was ample beef – but not too much – and the au jus was slightly sweet, and not..."
The PDX Foodie
"Super yummy we go there often! I would recomend it for casual..."
Grace L.
"The best pizza..."
Dean Dierickx
"Great pizza. 2 pool tables and nice atmosphere - especially during the..."
Irish Setter
"We shared an order of mac and cheese that was absolutely crammed with white meat chicken, bacon, and red bell peppers. Plus we shared a delicious..."
Janet Kragen
"Excellent food, wonderful non-intrusive service, and a great outdoor patio. Really enjoyed taking a rest there while riding a loop around Bainbridge..."
Nikita R.
"We went all out and got 1/2 of the Manzanita Margarita, 3T Three Cheese, Rockaway, and I can’t remember the name of 4th. It was good pizza but..."
Lynn Tran
"Excellent pizza and a well-lit airy dining..."
Kean Stump
"Charming place with great pies. Good for families and..."
גל נוביץ'
"Great dinning experience! Awesome service with polite and courteous servers. The food was excellent and my wife and I look forward to our next..."
Brandon Torrence
"Loved it. Our server was so amazing and sweet. The salads ALL OF THEM ARE AMAZING. You get what you pay for. Great place. And family..."
Yvette V
"Literally the best gluten free crust I've ever had. Whenever I hit the island whether to visit friends and family or to just have a day adventure. I..."
THE RYEGUY