I happen to think this is the Best most Reasonably priced Restaurant in Westhampton. Very good food, not overpriced like so many other restaurants in the Hamptons. Everything I’ve had here has been good. Especially the steak and baked potato! Monkey brains are pretty tasty too! Good for takeout as well. I was throwing a dinner party last year for 20, my chef got sick last minute so I ordered everything from Buoy One. No one even knew I didn’t have a chef!
Had a great time eating off season. The decor was so bright and welcoming. The menu selection had lots of choices and we all had the seafood, which was excellent. The tuna was so fresh it tasted like it was just caught. Will definitely go back again.
The blackened shrimp is my favorite seafood dish of all time! Nothing is better nothing! But I’m sad they closed their Manhattan location, I can’t drive almost 2 hours to Long Island for it now 😔
Great food and service. We arrived and were immediately seated in the large open back room.
Upon my second visit, the food was excellent and once again the service was outstanding. Friends loved the oysters and muscles.
Excellent fresh well prepared seafood. Clam fritters and fried oysters were off the hook delish. Very affordable with large varied menu. Definitely will be returning!
Will the waiter and Bartender was so kind, efficient , experience and excellent during our Birthday dinner with my roommate .
The atmosphere was warm and cozy. Coconut shrimp and oysters to start were very appetizing. We were not rush! Drinks were systematically brought to us to enjoy. The main course was Sirloin steak with mixed vegetables prepared perfectly . My favorite was the Roasted Duck! It was so moist and delicious. I can’t wait to go back and enjoy another meal!
You have to try Buoy One in Westhampton NY
Went to this location for the first time today with my father. It's so beautiful inside, very clean and the fresh flowers definitely give it a welcoming touch. The waitress was friendly, polite and overall a great server. The beer selection is good! Food as usual delicious!!!!! I am definitely going back, if you haven't been there yet you really need to get there like right now. Buoy One is my favorite to go for Lobster, i can't get enough.
Fantastic menu, super fresh seafood and a great, upbeat atmosphere makes Buoy One a perfect place to dine out. The manager Andrew is particularly awesome and the staff all around are top notch!
Really loved the oysters tonight. We had the fried oysters, roasted oysters and the stuffed oysters.
I always enjoy the large buffalo shrimp.
We had the place to ourselves on this cold winters night. Definitely love sitting outside in the summer, but prefer off season.
Gina treated us like family, and could not have treated us better.
She is always so warm and welcoming.
Set a course for a great time and follow the bouy to Bouy One.
Food was great, our server knew the menu and was extremely helpful, friendly, and professional.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Westhampton
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes