The place is under staffed. The White bean soup is excellent as well as the sautéed mushrooms. The Pasta with garlic and oil was a bit bland.
Patriot The Penguin (Bottlesgonewild)
+5
Cake was delicious!!!
We all enjoyed it.
Cake was moist and flavorful.
Fresh fruit on top.!!
We all pigged out!!!
July 1st 2023
Cake Again "55"
Beautifully baked desserts, down to the detail. Can be a little oversweet at times. The cafe's grilled cheese is to die for!
Growing up in Westhampton Beach, I’ve been visiting the Beach Bakery for many years.. It’s always been the heart of this town, staying open through the winter and providing consistently delicious baked goods, coffee and food as well as a warm and inviting atmosphere.. The previous owner, Simon, was always present and ran a very tight operation.. I just stopped into the bakery for the first time since they changed owners and I will be honest and say that I could definitely tell that there’s been a change.. The window display didn’t have the same charm, the shop wasn’t as clean and organized, and the selection of baked goods was not what it once was.. Having said that, the food was still very good (not sure if the bakers are the same).. This was the only time I’ve been in, and I will keep an open mind and continue to support this business.. I’ve heard good things about the new management and I know this is still the place to go for baked goods and treats..
Fast, reliable, and tasty! Got a couple birthday cakes here as well as pastries, and all were delicious
Delicious food, reasonable prices, loved the decorations, atmosphere, friendly staff. My husband and I were not lucky with dessert it was a little dry but other than that we would come back just to sit there relax and have another meal.
They put our cake order under the wrong time. So 2:00 pick up instead of 12:00 for a birthday party. They did offer to deliver it once it was completed. I will update this with the results but as of now I am unhappy with the experience. Other than that it was a busy atmosphere, everything looked good, great location, but as my first experience with the aforementioned location my first experience hasn't been entirely positive.
A hidden gem in the Hamptons with excellent food and service. Had the greek omelet for breakfast (it's large enough for two to be honest) and came back for the fish tacos. Enjoyed both very much. The only Kosher restaurant in eastern Long Island too. It was a perfect stopping off point to and from a visit to Montauk. Looking forward to future visits!
You have to give this place a shot, but please have realistic expectations. We get bagels, tarts, and croissants here regularly, occasionally a cake and everything has been good. I can't speak to the cafe, but our neighbors say good things. Staff and management are approachable/friendly and they are strict on cleanliness, which I appreciate. The bakery is usually immaculate with lots of options. Call ahead for orders as they sell out quickly. If putting in an order, follow up to make sure everything is correct because it can get loud. The tarts are my personal favorite.
Great bakery and an excellent cafe with very friendly and helpful staff. So delicious. The corn chowder had a delightful kick which was beyond awesome. The cheese fries were great. The house salad was yummy and the kids loved the personal pies. We also had fish and chips which were well cooked. There was a tremendous assortment of baked goods such as cookies, cupcakes, cheesecake, biscotti, turnovers, cakes, linzer tarts, and so much more. Big portions, delicious options.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Westhampton Beach
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes