Ok, so I’ve had lobster rolls all over MV and Cape Cod. Sandy’s lobster roll is by far the best! No fillers, perfectly toasted bun with an abundance of lobster! I may or may not have had 5 in my 15 days this year. And probably just as many last summer. Today I tried The Obama burger! I will say, Michelle would probably not approve but I did! Every single bite was perfect! Thank you to all the employees. Samantha is amazing! The food is all homemade, not frozen and heated. They are super friendly even when others are not. Be kind, people. See you next year, ladies.
Friendly and great product. What more could you want. They’re now my go to for fresh seafood, especially for off season. I went there the last two years before thanksgiving and got some amazing catches because let’s be honest, on the vineyard, turkeys can stay in the yard instead of going in the oven. It’s a fisherperson’s world here ✨
Excellent seafood market and food counter. One side for picking up fresh fried seafood dishes. The other side is the market. Nice staff. Probably one of the best spots to eat or shop on the island.
Great selection of fish, and their crab cakes are delicious! We got the grilled tuna sandwich and it was had a generous amount of fish. This was the best fish sandwich I've had in a long time, especially for only 11.50!
Now, I’m biased because New England seafood is ok at best when you compare it to the different fish down south, lobster aside. However, this is a place I would take my mother to eat. I’ve eaten all those seafood stores in the different towns in MV but they are overpriced, over cooked, and underwhelming. This little seafood haven is worth the trip. Ridiculously good prices, a huge selection of fresh fish AND prepared dishes, and the overall package can compete with the best restaurants down south. 15/10 I recommend.
Locally loved 😍 ❤️ fish market offers fried delights to go, great suggestions and cooking advice but closes at 3pm most days so be an early bird because the catch is in demand
Thank you for a great summer season. Your seafood is the best we have ever had. We will see you next season!
John's fish market was highlighted on Andrew Zimmerman's delicious destinations.
This was our first stop off the ferry to Martha vineyard.
We met the owner Glenn and got a little bit of history about the place.
My husband came here for the whole belly clams and cohogs.
I had the salmon wrap with lemon dill sauce and crab cakes. Delicious
Jumbo lobster is good and with great price. People who work here are nice. Noted that the hot food section (Sandy's Fish and Chips) is not open on Sundays.
The onion straws were beyond amazing - I’d go back just for those! The flounder sandwich was a great value and the coleslaw was perfectly balanced and moist!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Vineyard Haven
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes