New York Pizza

Update: I've lived overseas for the last year. In coming back to Tucson for a visit, I knew I needed to get some New York Pizza. The pizza is always perfect and the staff are kind, helpful, and good humored. The atmosphere is laid back and welcoming every time. When I recommend a pizza place to people from out of town, this is always it. Previous review: Always wonderful pizza. Staff is amazing and helpful!

I've been a regular at New York Pizza for over 30 years. East Side Local & Sahuaro High Grad. I've never ordered a pie though. Always there for slices. Lunch special. Honestly, it was a shock seeing the 'new' place. Times they will always be changing. They made all the right changes. The place looks really good. Very clean with much needed updating. New flooring, clean bathroom, new large TV's, air conditioning!!, fresh paint. The ceilings no longer look nasty. I do kind of miss the picnic tables though. Overall, great job as far as I'm concerned. Oh and the pizza...... there's that. The pizza is as good, if not better, than I've ever had. I guess they've made a few changes in recipe. That's to be expected. But they're moving more towards fresh ingredients so that's a good thing. We came in for late lunch, about 3pm. The guy at the counter was really cool and offered us slices that were done and ready now, or fresh slices that were ready in 20 mins. We weren't in a rush, so we opted to wait for fresh pizza. He was even nice enough to bring our slices to our table, instead of us coming up to the counter. And they were ready fast! Our slices were delicious, and I thought the crust seemed a little more full, which l liked. They're putting all the extras, parmeson, garlic, peppers, on the tables now, which is a good idea. So you no longer have to dress your slice at the counter or take jars to your table. Yuck. There's no more draft beer. Which is still ok for me because they have a larger selection of bottles. All in all, I'm really happy with the new look. Keep up the good work! Be back soon.

I’ve been coming here since high school. 1999 And I haven’t been back in Tucson for 12 years. I decided to try this place again because I remember the price for a slice and drink was cheap and it’s still the same amazing taste and good price. What’s better is the customer service. Riley was very kind and noticed me waiting and acknowledged me waiting. I asked for a refill and dropped my glass on the floor. I was embarrassed and she laughed it off with me. She was very kind and I appreciate the smile. Thank you

I started going here in high school in the 80's. I had moved away for many years & came back. To me it was as good as I remembered. Still probably my favorite place to get pizza. I've only had that & calzones, but both are delightful. I will continue to patronize this establishment so long as they are open. It's super casual & the service was friendly.

I know I am a creature of habit. I've been coming here off and on since going to Sahuaro High School, like many other long-time patrons. I will say I prefer the old interior before the new owners. I miss the old bench seats, long time paper menu and other old school touches. I did have trouble placing an order on Saturday during peek times was not able to get through on phone to place an order. Tried calling about 6 or 7 times, but no luck, but I'm understanding. But I waited to give a fair shot. I got a large pepperoni and to me the dough smelled and tasted similar to the original recipe but not quite quite the same but was still good. I got great service by guy I spoke with on phone and when I arrived. The pizza is fairly priced for the rise in pizza price around Tucson.