Review Wiseguys New York Pies

John M

Ordered for the first time thru DoorDash and was mostly happy. Ordered a large pepperoni pizza, antipasto salad and cannolis. Pizza was very very thin but had a nice cook and good flavor. Salad was fresh and the tomato was ripe. Cannolis were fresh also, crisp crunchy outside, creamy and sweet inside.

Kevin McDougal

This is some seriously good pizza and the staff is great too. We had the Meatball Parmesan. Super happy we stopped by!

Jeff Dennewitz

I absolutely recommend Wiseguy’s Pizza! I was starving and needed something to eat QUICK! I saw Wiseguy’s Pizza nearby, so I decided to check them out. I walked inside, and was instantly greeted by the restaurant owner with a smile “Welcome to Wiseguy’s Pizza!” I explained to him that I had never been there before, and so he kindly went through everything that they offered on their menu to me. I decided on a 14” meat lovers pizza, he took my order, and said that he’d have it ready for me shortly. I sat down and was looking around the dining area and noticed the all the cool New York wiseguy decor he had displayed throughout the restaurant, and I also noticed how clean the place looked too. In less than 10 minutes, he had prepared my pizza fresh and delivered it out to my table himself. I got really excited when I saw how good it looked. I took my first bite and... WOW!! Absolutely delicious! It was perfectly cooked fresh hot out of the oven, meats piled high, lots of melty mozzarella cheese, sauce was delicious, perfect crispy golden brown crust. I was very impressed to say the least. I ate the entire pizza! I also had a good conversation with the owner too. Really a nice, genuine guy. I had a great experience here, and I absolutely recommend Wiseguy’s Pizza.

Christian “Kiki” Ortiz

These guys are always on point and the pizza is very good. Real authentic new york style pizza. These guys have very good customer service to offer and they are very friendly for about 5 dollars you get 2 slices of pizza ,either pep or cheese as well as a drink of your choice.

Lino Rodriguez

I ordered a great tasting & huge eggplant Parm hero, was ready in 10 min, I tried a slice of cheese pizza & it took me back to when I worked in NYC, drippy oil, crispy & soft crust, I enjoyed the heck out of it! UPDATED: It is now my new favorite local pizza joint! $11 buffet was basically whatever I wanted! Meatballs & sauce in hero were incredibly tasty, pizza had near perfect crispy lower crust with a hair of soft above, great cheese to sauce ratio, & The kicker was the fantastic tasting real sliced Italian sausage on the pizza! Bonus was a friendly ex NY’er using great NY language & attitude :) I wish them great success & highly recommend it :) !

Conor R

Absolutely the best NY style pizza around. The place is a little rough around the edges but it's what you'd expect if you were in Brooklyn so it's perfecrt. I order at least once a week from here and I love it very single time. I'm so happy this place opened here as the other NY style pizzerias do not even come close fornthe quality and taste that Wiseguy's has.

Ivan Richman

I am so excited that Wiseguys is now open. If you are looking for great pizza this is the place to go. Reminds me of back home. I enjoyed the cannoli as well. All I can say is WOW. You need to come here.

Liza Benitez

This is seriously one of the best NY style pizza in the Tampa area. Maybe even the best. We had no problem with service, and we ordered it in person on a Friday night!

Paul Vinales

If you are looking for the best pizza, look no more. By far the best pizza in town. Great Pasta menues as well. You will have a difficult time deciding what to order. Stop by, you will not be disappointed.

Leslie L Burrows

Just dropped in on a whim & was rewarded w/ tasty pie and friendly service. Would give a five if they had had a veggie slice awaiting. Still the crispy cheesy slice I did get convinced me to drop in for more the next time I'm by.

Misty Monteleone

Everyone is so nice. And the pizza is the best I have had in florida. We drive 20 minutes just to eat this pizza. I love love love it.

Lino Rodriguez

I found my new favorite local pizza joint yesterday! $11 buffet was basically whatever I wanted! Meatballs & sauce in hero were incredibly tasty, pizza had near perfect crispy lower crust with a hair of soft above, great cheese to sauce ratio, & The kicker was the fantastic tasting real sliced Italian sausage on the pizza! Bonus was a friendly ex NY’er using great NY language & attitude :) I wish them great success & highly recommend it :) !

Sarah Elizabeth

I ordered a pie for delivery. I had one bite and immediately spat it out. My boyfriend had one bite. Chewed once and spat it out. Our dog, who eats everything under the sun, wouldn’t even go near the pizza. The sauce was oddly burnt, and it looked like there was an afterthought sprinkling of cheese after the pizza had been half burnt in the oven. The horrendous flavor that assaulted us tasted like it had been made yesterday. I wouldn’t feed this to my worst enemy. I’d rather starve than eat this. I hope it was a fluke, but it was so bad I think we’re going to have nightmares about that pizza.

Kim Krouse

What can i say about wiseguys new york pies...? Well...Ill say this....Its beyond great food!!! billy has some great pizza and pastas you will NOT find anywhere andb i dont care where you go...maggioanos ..Olive garden or any other 3-5 star italian restaurant on the planet!!!...when it comes to his recipes and his sauces (both marinara and pizza sauce) they are made with 100% pure love....this guy takes alot of time preparing and perfecting them and i consider him a "master of his craft"...if you have not tried his pizza or pastas, hero subs..or the wings...you are truely missing out...and i dont just say this because i love the man lol ...i say this because i see behind the scenes just how much time and attention he puts into each and every batch or pizza pie....bit dont take MY word for it...YOU be the judge for yourself...trust me...you will be hooked immediately!! And you will more then likely Thank me later;)...k.k

Chris DeLaughter

Thin NY style pizza is really good. Their wings are meaty and seasoned, their Italian sandwich was awesome, they have great cannolis, the employees are very nice. Highly recommend.

Frankie Vanek

Owner and staff very cool people , got a supreme the pizza was on point 100% kids even loved it and ate the vegetables lol way better than the big chain stores you won't be disappointed , going back for the ceaser next time ��

Chuck Perry

Thank you Bill for the best Pie/ Philly in the Southeast!!! Great quality and great prices!!! They treated me like Family from day one!!!

Tommy Storm

If you have been waiting for a great pizzeria this is the place. The pizza reminded me of back home. Great desserts as well. Especially the cannoli. This is a must have.

Keisha Leeshawn Bankston

Best pizza ever!!! Finally have a go to fresh pizza place!!! Never leave Unsatisfied� #happypregnantwoman

Tim Rowland

This place is awesome! Try their calzone, you won't be disappointed!

Dawn Jesse

Great pizza. The owner is very nice. I'll definitely go back.

Alicia Tucker

Delicious Pizza, wonderful atmosphere and great customer service!!

West Sylar Moreland

Best pizza in the area, gotta love the sauce and the toppings are plentiful. Excellent

Kim Brown Parker

Enjoyed a two topping 18 inch pie! Will definitely visit again.

Review Wiseguys New York Pies - Tampa