Sluurpy
Reset

There are 3 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best New York Style Pizza in Tampa

There are 3 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Cappy's Pizzeria - South Tampa
88/100 (802 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Italian
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Salad
New York Style Pizza
Deep dish pizza
Sit down
Italian
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Highchairs Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Cash Only
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Mid-range
"Excellent tasting pizza!! Fresh ingredients on the veggie pizza. Amazingly great crust. Cozy place remember to bring cash as no cards accepted...."
Niurka
"When I travel, I always seek out local pizza joints; Cappy's did not disappoint. The sauce is how I like it, more savory than sweet. I also judge..."
Doyoufoodude
"Great NY Pizza. NY style pizza really is top notch. Cozy venue in an old bungalow. Feels authentic and eclectic. Wife "Sally" and I like the little..."
Backtrak
"Yummy. I love Cappy's the deep dish and greek salad are both very good! Very casual..."
Agirl225
"I just love this pizza and Greek salad with potato salad. I'm a regular. They do, however, mess up every single pick-up order I place so I just stay..."
Honey Badger Don't Care
"Yummy food! Great atmosphere!. Chicago style knocks your socks off! New York pizza taste so fresh and you can tell that everything is made ON..."
Katie
"The REAL DEAL!. This is, bar none, the best pizza anywhere. But, it's not Ci-Cis, so if you want fast food pizza, skip Cappy's. Plus, you get a lot..."
Nancyj003
"Fun atmosphere. Great prices and great..."
Amy
"Best Pizza in Tampa.. I've always had great food from this place. It's always absolutely perfect. The music is consistently good, and the menus are..."
Karen S
"Hands down best pizza in Tampa!! Great Greek salad! Love it! Wish they'd..."
ED
"Best Pizza in Tampa!. Cappy's Pizzeria is the best pizza in..."
Pinky's Diner
"Great place!. I love this place. It's in a old bungalow and the pizza is tasty! The greek salad is the best in..."
Todd
"I have had pizza in Italy, Germany, Japan, France, Turkey, Poland, and several states and Cappy's is the best pizza I have ever..."
Yumtofood
"Awesome Chicago Style Pizza!. If you like deep dish pizza, you owe it to yourself to order a large "Chicago Style Cappy". They also have a great..."
TampaBayFoodie
"Great spot!!!. The Chicago style deep dish is spectacular, the crust/bread has something like cornmeal in it, it's been cooked perfectly every time,..."
AskDrTodd
"The best plan–taught me by the friend who introduced me to Cappy’s–is to order and share a salad and a deep dish pizza. While you wait for the..."
Inkwatu
"Ordering from an album cover menu was cute. Quaint, nostalgic and cozy describe the atmosphere. We were fortunate to dine there shortly after they..."
Arlisa
"This location is the original of the 5 Cappy’s in the area. It has a cool retro charm, easy going, family friendly atmosphere with indoor and..."
Bina P
"Delicious Italian style pizza with good homemade sauce. The crust is just right, you have to give just a little pull to bite through it. Many choices..."
Kathy W
"The deep dish pizza here was phenomenal!! Great service. The restaurant is very small and parking is limited, but it's definitely worth ordering for..."
Madelynne Bell
"Great pizza/ great owner- beautiful establishment. If you're in the Tampa area I highly recommend this place. Definitely worth the..."
David C
"We went for the Chicago style pizza. As a very long time customer I was surprised to see that they cut down on all of the ingredients including the..."
LisaMarie B
"Traveling from Mississippi and my husband is Originally from Chicago. We don't have any true Chicago deep dish restaurants in Mississippi so whenever..."
L J
"Great food, great service. Pizza almost like NY, plenty of cheese and pepperoni! Definitely going back again..."
cynthia o'neill
"The Chicago deep dish is equally as good if not better than Giordano's or Lou's. Their Greek salad and regular crust pies are also pretty..."
Courtney Leigh
"Old time Chicago pizza shop. Serves only salad and pizza, cash only. Offers gluten free..."
Thomas Gill
"Really enjoyed the pizza here - very quaint and unique spot that feels cozy and truly feels like a neighborhood spot. Service was pretty quick for..."
Steve P
"We had an amazing dinner at Cappy’s. After starting with the small Greek salad, we moved on to a medium Chicago pizza with sausage, green olives,..."
Jeff Rooks
"Cappys is among the best pizza I've ever had. The deep dish is legit! Don't sleep on this place. What it might lack in curb appeal, it makes up..."
Dan Hall
"Great pizza 🍕 Good service. Relaxed pleasant atmosphere. Always enjoyable at Cappys..."
Don B
"A friend recently moved around the corner and picked up a pie. Both of us being from Jersey I don't do much pizza till I visit up north but I got..."
Robert Dlugos
"Great pizza, they need to move to a bigger location with more parking, I would go more..."
Mark C
"Cappy's is a South Tampa staple serving both thin and thick crust pizzas, calzones, and delish greek salad. The pizzas are a very generous size and..."
Chip Weiner
"Small spot with excellent pizza and salads. We ordered 1/2 a Greek salad and the Sicilian Pizza both were..."
Jeffrey Ronstadt
Eddie & Sam's Ny Pizza
84/100 (25208 ratings)
Quick Bites
Fast Food
Pizza
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Lasagne
Gelato
New York Style Pizza
Eggplant
Salad
Wings
Sit down
Pizza
Italian
Television
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Highchairs Available
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Great spot for grabbing pizza, watching a game and hanging with friends. NY style pizza that tastes great! You order from kiosks. Tons of pizza..."
Yvette Domke
"This is hands down the best pizza around. If you are looking for authentic NY pizza this is the place to go. The pizza is delicious. The..."
Howard Bogan
"Took a trip to Tampa to visit family and came here as per the reviews on Tik Tok. Coming in at 4.1 ⭐️ Odd ball star review. I couldn't bring them..."
E P
"Great pizza! Busy place but they get the orders fast! And the smell is so good that drives you crazy! Definitely a pizza place to come back to and..."
LiLi
"The pizza here tasted so delicious. The slice are huge and super cheesy. You can get full with just 2 pieces of pizza. My favorite is the Hawaiian..."
My Lam
"As always Eddie & Sam’s pizza some of the best NY pizza I have ever had outside NY. Service is always good there. They import water from NY to make..."
Esfaque Ahmed
"I've been hearing about Eddie and Sam's NY Pizza for a while now. Especially when I ask people where can I find a good pizza in the Tampa area. Okay,..."
Thomas Knotts
"I don’t Doordash often but when I do, I spend twice as much for being lazy 😅 Although it was delivery, my pie still arrived fresh. I ordered..."
Rothschild Dort
"Sampled 7 slices...surprisingly, Margarita pizza was the best followed by the lasagna...the rest were just ok..parm, white, Buffalo, Sicilian, meat..."
Jay Nolasco
"I have the fortune of living right by this place, and I've had the pleasure of dining there many times. Without fail, they consistently deliver..."
Rocco Colafrancesco
New York New York Pizza - Ybor City
82/100 (3284 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Fast Food
Italian
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Fast food
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Pesto
Pasta
Salad
Wings
Meatballs
New York Style Pizza
Sit down
Fast food
Pizza
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Delivery
Takeout
Television
Late Night
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"The best pizza in Ybor!! I'm plant-based and our server was more than accommodating. This is definitely our go-to for pizza and other Italian..."
Pam Jones
"Not only was this the only pizza place that could accommodate an 11:30am delivery for a lunch meeting, they also had great customer service, called..."
Lauren Hasbrouck Kriz
"I've been told about this place but my youngest son I was notified about this place by another family member. I finally went the ending of September..."
Doris Zambrana
"I’m from ny born n raised. When it comes to pizza � I know first hand. Tampa does not know anything about pizza until I met this place ny ny..."
Joshua Muldrow
"The best NYC style pizza in the Tampa Bay Area! I dream about this pizza because it’s that awesome..."
Christine Crociata
"Absolutely the best Italian food and pizza in Tampa... Fettuccine Alfred like real Italians make... Awesome...new favorite work goto..."
Thomas P. Canizio
"I wasn't ready for how good the pizza, wings, and salad were!! Definitely worth coming in for good food at a great..."
Brandy Evans
"Best Pizza place we have found in Florida. We drive over from Orlando to eat..."
Michael Leach
"I updated this review from a 1 star to a 5 star after an issue was resolved with my first delivery experience with them. We had received a pizza..."
Juan Eduardo Marengo
"The pizza is really good New York style thinish crispy crust. They've got a great little outside seating area with the view from my pictures. The..."
Montana Fox
"While visiting Tampa I went to #UrbanTrivia downtown and this pizza spot was across the street from the theater. $3.50 for a slice of pizza is rare..."
Khalilah S
"The BEST New York style pizza in Ebor! Cool people, great service and awesome..."
Christopher Carlos Tesvich Salazar
"A very great & delicious pizza for even greater prices! Came here for the 1st time with my family a little late at night and we had a great time. The..."
Justin Vega
"Was in Tampa for work and walked over for lunch. Ordered what was recommended, fried chicken alfredo pizza, was excellent hot and later in the hotel...."
James Dicken
"Omg..The pizza is sooo delicious! Not stingy with the toppings at all! When I come back to Tampa, this is my pizza..."
T Shaifer (Pulse)
"Absolutely the best pizza in Tampa!😮😍 I’m originally from the Bronx and I haven’t taste NY pizza like this in years! So good! The salad..."
Lisa B
"I have ate a lot of pizza in my life and WOW the slice of meat eaters pizza was perfect! Lots of flavor with a slightly crunchy crust and perfect..."
james brecken
"One of my favorite slices around. The cheese sticks are really good and the cheese steak sandwiches are some of my favorites. However, the inside..."
Tim Norris
"the pizza was not quite as 'new york style' as we would have preferred, but it was pretty close. we ordered garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, and a..."
penelope porcupine
"Very close to pizza like home!! If you get the pizza and want more authentic style get a large or xl pizza...or by the slice. If the oil drips down..."
Lala Lew
"Mozzarella sticks were fantastic! Cheesy goodness that just oozed everywhere and went perfectly with the marinara. Ordered the four cheese pizza and..."
Fiona Thomas
"Love. Love. Love. And Pizza. This pizza is exactly what I been seeking in Tampa. A true NY Style Pizza that could be right at home here in Tampa or..."
Joseph (Rockstar)
"Really enjoy their food. Buffalo chicken sub is delicious. Walkup window is great for a quick bite to eat. Slices and drink combos. Give them a..."
Meghan Yorks
"Really great pizza place we found in Tampa. the food lives up to the review hype. Crispy almost buttery tasting crust and plenty of sauce and its..."
Temple Thomas
"Classic NY slice 🍕 Simple grab and go or dine inside. More than pizza, menus got subs, pastas and wings!! Location is prime on west end of Ybor..."
Fonzo Afre (Mr. Real Reviews)
"Happened to stumble on this place! Service was great and fast. Food was..."
chris connolly
"Ybor in Tampa has many pizza 🍕 places. When we talk about New York Style pizza, there are only a few places that make the cut. New York New York..."
Enrique Sánchez
"This is the best pizza I’ve ever ate. I just wish they weren’t 30 miles away from where I live or I would order much more often. The pizza is..."
Samantha Schneider
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use