The best Deep dish pizza in Tampa | Sluurpy updated in April

Cappy's Pizzeria - South Tampa

88/100 (802 ratings)

Restaurants

Italian

Vegetarian Friendly

Dinner

Salad

New York Style Pizza

Deep dish pizza

Sit down

Italian

Free off-street parking

Highchairs Available

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Cash Only

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Wine and Beer

Gift Cards Available

Parking Available

Dinner

Mid-range

"Excellent tasting pizza!! Fresh ingredients on the veggie pizza. Amazingly great crust. Cozy place remember to bring cash as no cards accepted...."

Niurka

"When I travel, I always seek out local pizza joints; Cappy's did not disappoint. The sauce is how I like it, more savory than sweet. I also judge..."

Doyoufoodude

"Great NY Pizza. NY style pizza really is top notch. Cozy venue in an old bungalow. Feels authentic and eclectic. Wife "Sally" and I like the little..."

Backtrak

"Yummy. I love Cappy's the deep dish and greek salad are both very good! Very casual..."

Agirl225

"I just love this pizza and Greek salad with potato salad. I'm a regular. They do, however, mess up every single pick-up order I place so I just stay..."

Honey Badger Don't Care

"Yummy food! Great atmosphere!. Chicago style knocks your socks off! New York pizza taste so fresh and you can tell that everything is made ON..."

Katie

"The REAL DEAL!. This is, bar none, the best pizza anywhere. But, it's not Ci-Cis, so if you want fast food pizza, skip Cappy's. Plus, you get a lot..."

Nancyj003

"Fun atmosphere. Great prices and great..."

Amy

"Best Pizza in Tampa.. I've always had great food from this place. It's always absolutely perfect. The music is consistently good, and the menus are..."

Karen S

"Hands down best pizza in Tampa!! Great Greek salad! Love it! Wish they'd..."

ED

"Best Pizza in Tampa!. Cappy's Pizzeria is the best pizza in..."

Pinky's Diner

"Great place!. I love this place. It's in a old bungalow and the pizza is tasty! The greek salad is the best in..."

Todd

"I have had pizza in Italy, Germany, Japan, France, Turkey, Poland, and several states and Cappy's is the best pizza I have ever..."

Yumtofood

"Awesome Chicago Style Pizza!. If you like deep dish pizza, you owe it to yourself to order a large "Chicago Style Cappy". They also have a great..."

TampaBayFoodie

"Great spot!!!. The Chicago style deep dish is spectacular, the crust/bread has something like cornmeal in it, it's been cooked perfectly every time,..."

AskDrTodd

"The best plan–taught me by the friend who introduced me to Cappy’s–is to order and share a salad and a deep dish pizza. While you wait for the..."

Inkwatu

"Ordering from an album cover menu was cute. Quaint, nostalgic and cozy describe the atmosphere. We were fortunate to dine there shortly after they..."

Arlisa

"This location is the original of the 5 Cappy’s in the area. It has a cool retro charm, easy going, family friendly atmosphere with indoor and..."

Bina P

"Delicious Italian style pizza with good homemade sauce. The crust is just right, you have to give just a little pull to bite through it. Many choices..."

Kathy W

"The deep dish pizza here was phenomenal!! Great service. The restaurant is very small and parking is limited, but it's definitely worth ordering for..."

Madelynne Bell

"Great pizza/ great owner- beautiful establishment. If you're in the Tampa area I highly recommend this place. Definitely worth the..."

David C

"We went for the Chicago style pizza. As a very long time customer I was surprised to see that they cut down on all of the ingredients including the..."

LisaMarie B

"Traveling from Mississippi and my husband is Originally from Chicago. We don't have any true Chicago deep dish restaurants in Mississippi so whenever..."

L J

"Great food, great service. Pizza almost like NY, plenty of cheese and pepperoni! Definitely going back again..."

cynthia o'neill

"The Chicago deep dish is equally as good if not better than Giordano's or Lou's. Their Greek salad and regular crust pies are also pretty..."

Courtney Leigh

"Old time Chicago pizza shop. Serves only salad and pizza, cash only. Offers gluten free..."

Thomas Gill

"Really enjoyed the pizza here - very quaint and unique spot that feels cozy and truly feels like a neighborhood spot. Service was pretty quick for..."

Steve P

"We had an amazing dinner at Cappy’s. After starting with the small Greek salad, we moved on to a medium Chicago pizza with sausage, green olives,..."

Jeff Rooks

"Cappys is among the best pizza I've ever had. The deep dish is legit! Don't sleep on this place. What it might lack in curb appeal, it makes up..."

Dan Hall

"Great pizza 🍕 Good service. Relaxed pleasant atmosphere. Always enjoyable at Cappys..."

Don B

"A friend recently moved around the corner and picked up a pie. Both of us being from Jersey I don't do much pizza till I visit up north but I got..."

Robert Dlugos

"Great pizza, they need to move to a bigger location with more parking, I would go more..."

Mark C

"Cappy's is a South Tampa staple serving both thin and thick crust pizzas, calzones, and delish greek salad. The pizzas are a very generous size and..."

Chip Weiner

"Small spot with excellent pizza and salads. We ordered 1/2 a Greek salad and the Sicilian Pizza both were..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Deep dish pizza in Tampa

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters