NY Times Square Pizza is truly a "Slice of Heaven" in Tampa. It's my absolute #1 choice for pizza. The first time I tried their pizza i realized the difference between them and the fast-food pizza shops (you know the ones). 5 Stars! (If i could give it 6 then I would!). The Atmosphere is great, and The owner is welcoming!
I'm a big fan of pizza, and I've tried a lot of different places in my day. But I can honestly say that their NY style pizza and wings are top notch. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful.
But what really sets NY Times Square pizza apart from other pizza places is the customer service. The Essie and staff are always friendly and welcoming, and they're always happy to go the extra mile.
If you're looking for a delicious pizza and great customer service, I highly recommend. You won't be disappointed!
Great NY pizza. Sauce was good. Garlic knots excellent. One of the best in town.
Anthony Galvez Photography
+5
Incredible place! From the moment you walk in to the moment you leave, pizza is made perfectly! Service was amazing, very welcoming, and pleasant. We got pizza by the slice and they made them fresh, they were delicious! The pricing was right on for the quality. Hands down the best!
I finally found it. I've lived in Tampa for a little over 3 years now and I've finally found amazing pizza. Not only amazing pizza, but probably top 5 of my entire life. And that's saying something because I've had a lot of pizza. The lady running it was super nice too, and very sweet to our little girl. We'll definitely be back to try more! We got the eggplant pizza, which is mind blowingly good and now my baby's new favorite food 🥰, but I really want to try the white spinach pizza as I saw someone else's and it looked to die for. Wonderful all around, can't recommend enough 10/10⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Edit: Just tried the Eggplant parmigiana sub and OMG. It was the best Eggplant parmigiana I've ever had😍
Essie is such a gem and always takes care of me and my place of work for all our food needs! We love this place and the food is excellent! The pizza is always fresh and very much like NY pizza. You will not be disappointment with the food and exceptional service that Essie and her team provide.
Been eating here on and off for a few years. Restaurant always appears to be clean, great staff, and responsible owner. Plenty of seating (both booths and tables) and quality food. They also offer both Pepsi and Coke products. Today we had two slices of pizza (nice crunch to the crust). Plenty of parking. Competitive pricing, but always depends on what you’re seeking.
They’re hiring at the moment as well. Stop on in or call.
I am from Brooklyn, so a thing or two I can say about this place is that the pizza is really New York style pizza that I miss. Other selections on the menu are delicious as well. I recommend the meatballs and calzones. The owner is a very kind lady and the staff are great. This is definitely the pizza you are looking for if you moved to Tampa from NY.
I am thrilled to give New York Times Square Pizza a well-deserved five-star review! This pizzeria undoubtedly serves some of the best pizzas I've ever tasted, with their authentic New York-style crust that's perfectly crispy yet chewy. The flavorful toppings and gooey cheese make every slice a delight. But that's not all – their wings are a true treat, boasting a deliciously tangy and succulent taste that keeps me coming back for more. Even their salads are fantastic, offering a fresh and healthy option that still leaves my taste buds satisfied. Lastly, their service is top-notch, with friendly staff always ready to assist and a warm ambiance that makes dining there a pleasure. New York Times Square Pizza has won my heart and taste buds, making it a must-visit destination for pizza enthusiasts and food lovers alike!
I have had many great dining experiences at NY Times Square and finally decided to write a review. The pizza is always excellent and their wing recipe is definitely a must-try. What stood out was the impeccable service provided by Masha. Her attentiveness and friendly demeanor elevated my last visit to a whole new level. Will definitely be returning for more delicious food and outstanding customer service!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Tampa
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes