5 stars across the board. I'm a driver for Walmart and I'm staying the night at the Hampton Inn across the street and I gave it a try after getting my Dunkin of course, lol. Pizza shop is right next to Dunkin. So got me my Dunkin and some great Pizza for dinner and I'm glad I did, very good! I will be back. Keep up the great work! Very happy customer here.
They were excellent. Stayed open past 8pm. Pizza, and garlic knots were delicious. They also make pasta dishes and subs. Going back as soon as I'm in the area.
Great Philly cheese steak! Been living in Houston for the past 12 years and finally back in PA. So glad to have stopped in for this sandwich. It was great and a perfect philly steak!
I’ve loved this pizza place for many years. Food is consistently delicious, the owner is awesome and he makes subs faster than any other place without compromising perfection!!!!
was driving through town from NYC and happened to stop here for a quick slice. happy i did. really some of the best pizza i've ever had. I can't wait to go back when I go to Camelback next winter.
Stopped in with a coworker who had been here before and raves about it. Did not disappoint. Food was delicious and staff was friendly. Buffalo chicken pizza was the best I’ve had anywhere.
Seriously best spaghetti and meatballs I've had in a long time, huge portion too, lentle soup awesome, and slices were huge too! I usually don't give 5 stars but with reasonable price I'll be ordering from here probably 4 times a week while in town! And no I'm not the owner or affiliated...
As a born & bred New Yorker, I was pleasantly surprised by the cheese pie, chicken drums & zeppoles. Soo hard to get a good slice in the woods. Slice has a nice chew & u can finish the crust. Zeppoles were warm, light yet dense, not greasy. Delish. Paulmbo's II is the closest thing to Amore's (in Flushing) Also saves me a 2hr drive to Queens. Thanx guys.
My family and I absolutely love this place! Great staff, very clean restaurant, reasonable pricing, and tasty food. They never disappoint. The photo below is pineapple pizza with extra cheese (which is the best!)
I have gone to the Original Palumbo's a few times before in Stroudsburg and wanted to check out this one in the Bartonsville area as well. Went early on around when they opened for the day. The man working inside was friendly and the slice was just over $2 or so which is standard for the area.
The slice was good. Minimal flop and a nice little char on the bottom. Sauce to cheese ratio was solid and the sauce had good flavor. Couldn't speak to the rest of the menu as I just grabbed a slice to go, but the cheese slice was solid.
As always, check out TikTok for our video reviews of the restaurants we rate here!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Stroudsburg
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes