Absolutely love Presto Pizza !!! Food is amazing and great prices! I have ordered my Christmas Eve appetizers to my children’s party from Carmine and his crew! They are always on time hot and delicious! Love the kids cat for the weekly special, that feeds my family for 2 or 3 days !!!
Great place Food is spectacular. Price is right. The owner is very friendly and the place is so clean and spotless. The Chinese restaurants on Castelton Ave should be avoided as the prices are high and the the food is terrible. Go to Presto instead you be glad you did
Excellent customer service and great tasting food! The medium pizza was a little bit smaller than I was expecting, but I think my perspective may have been warped by the fact that I habitually order large pies. That being said, their “ crazy eight“ special is a pretty fantastic deal, and is available all the time - a medium pie, eight garlic knots, eight mozzarella sticks, and eight wings, all for $18.99 plus tax! Plus the delivery was very quick! I will certainly be ordering from here again.
Best pizza gem!
Try the pineapple jalapeño pizza and the potato wedges, great customer service! Too bad they're close on sundays..
Great food, fast delivery, amazing staff, very clean and when dining in you feel at home.
Writing this as I digest my delicious meal! I am on Staten Island visiting and of course had to get some NY pizza. I’m from Jersey and the pizza is good but I’m a native New Yorker and will always be! Anyway, we got two of the deep dish personals, a Caesar salad, and the Philly cheese steak egg rolls. The pizza was delicious! Sauce was flavorful and the dough was crispy and doughy at the same time. Definitely not disappointed at all. Philly cheese steak egg rolls were also delicious. Crispy on the outside, cheesy and savory on the inside. Caesar salad was your basic Caesar. Definitely recommend this place! The personals are actually really filling. The best of all was talking with the owner who was incredibly friendly and kind.
I usually order lunch from here when I'm at work, and it's always fresh! I had a small party on Saturday and had them cater, and everything was delicious!!!!! As long as they keep delivering to Eltingville ill keep ordering! Thank you, Carmine!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Staten Island
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes