Midnight Cookie Co
1058 N 39th St, 98103-7921 - Seattle
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#1893 of 2823 restaurants in Seattle
Updated on
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
61/100
Data Completeness
56/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (10+)
+2
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 10
100%
Google Reviews
426
Google reviews
I’d been wanting to go here for a long time—it’s kinda tucked away in a weird spot but finally made the stop. I’m a little bit of a Cookie monster and have made my rounds on the Seattle bakery scene. These cookies weren’t bad—but for a place that only makes cookies, they weren’t impressive. They tasted like day old cookies. Don’t get me wrong, they’re still cookies so they will get eaten, but wouldn’t be my top choice. Of the six we got, the double chocolate was my favorite.
Read more
Google
Did you know they have a cookie happy hour? I mean, what’s not to like about that. This place serves delicious cookies. The flavors are standard and cookies are consistently delicious. I give this place 5 Stars because it’s an excellent walking pit stop in Fremont, has a happy hour and great customer service.
Read more
Google
We ordered delivery cookies from this location and they were hard as a rock. I’ve never put a more stale cookie in my mouth. It tastes like they were left on the counter for a week. What are you doing?
Google
The ice cream is not something you should buy from here. Their salted caramel doesn't even have caramel in their ingredients... This ice cream is pure disgusting. I have bought store brands ice cream and they are a lot better than this one. I have a food-coma from eating this ice cream. Stay away!
Google
Great cookies! I love the variety. My favorites are the macadamia nut, the smores and the fruity pebbles.
Google
After ages of being tempted by these cookies in Postmates listings & various ads - I finally cracked and ordered a box. Extremely disappointing. Hard, borderline stale cookies that would fail to satisfy any craving - especially after paying $12 (before delivery fees) for seven cookies.
If you're looking for a soft midnight sweet, look elsewhere.
Read more
Google
Incredible! Seriously, where else can you get a homemade cookie at midnight... other than firing up your oven and baking them yourself? But who wants to do such a thing? Midnight Cookies is awesome, and with uber eats delivering it will seriously help you gain weight. Also, the birthday cake cookie is the best.
Read more
Google
I have been getting cookies and ice cream from this company for over a month now, and I can safely say I love them! The cookies are soft, tasty, and the Chef's special Fruity Pebbles is incredible. Midnight Cookie Co. has delicious ice cream; their dark chocolate reminds me of the one I always used to get as a kid. Highly recommend this place!
Read more
Google
Explore more in Seattle
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: