Great Pizza - a score for the whole family
We were visiting Pier 39 and Coit Tower and this is located between the 2 points. The process were great and so was the pizza. Everyone was pleased with this meal. I highly recommend Goodfellas!
Great pizza. Full of flavour and fresh food.
I am hoping I can go back before we leave.
I’d say best meal I’ve had in San Fransisco so far!!
Great restaurant, amazing pizza and lots of options. The staff were very helpful and ensured we had everything we needed. Went here right from the airport and returned several times while we were in town. If you're looking for a quick bite to eat while at Fishermans Wharf I 💯 recommend
Food was great and very affordable. the large slice of pizza lived up to its name. Only thing I did not like was the flies, wish the owners took care of those.
The staff was very friendly, not overly priced, and the food was amazing. We had the 11" Supreme pizza, Philly cheese steak sandwich, chicken fingers, fries, and mozzarella sticks.
Great experience! Definitely a different level of quality in comparison to chains. Very personal and down to earth people that make the experience more 1 on 1. Setting can make a wrong impression but soon adds to the authenticity of the place. Great Greek salad taste and portion wise. Great pizza as well!
Very good pizza!!!!! Crust was crunchy but not hard. Perfect crunchiness. And that comment is coming from a soft dough lover. We bought 16” cheese and one slice of pepperoni. They are almost New york size. They use good cheese. We ordered mozzarella sticks. Delicious. Perfect mozzarella sticks consistency. Came with marinara and ranch. If you are looking for your local neighborhood pizzeria this is it. I loved the mural, joining san francisco and new york! (I’m not from either but now have been to both)
Had Goodfellas Pizza slices delivered. Top-notch, very good. Lots of toppings and slices are very big.
I would go here almost everyday either to walk in and eat or order pick up since I lived across the street. Their food? Mouthwatering! No one can make burgers like they can! Pizzas either. One time, I asked if they could cut my pizza to look like a carved a pumpkin and man did they deliver! That was some time ago. Whenever I’m in the city, I always try to stop by. Love the food, atmosphere and people. The staff are really sweet and nice too! I hope this place stays open for a long long looooong while and can expand out to other location because no one can do food like they do!
I just started working around the corner from good fellas pizza a few months ago. Walking distance. Pizza is very good. Their toppings are the best, especially the meatball. I go there at least 2 or 3 times a week. Fast service, nice size televisions for games. Awesome posters on the wall. It's my go to. Still gotta try the rest of the menu. Their sandwiches and calzones look good
Will not recommend for a dine-in experience, because the place is usually occupied by homeless and very dungy. This otherwise would be a good place for families. But the 4*s are only for the food!!! Amazing pizzas...
It was my first time going in, but from now on when I visit family in Cali I will driving there!! It was so good and worth it too!!
I also love the fact you can order any of their pizza's and get it's a slice. Most places never offer that. It's usually: Cheese, Pepperoni, and if their feeling 'saucy' BOOM! Supreme. 🙄
Thank you for being different!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in San Francisco
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes