Nino’s Sicilian pizza is the real deal! I swear it was a 10 lb pizza loaded with toppings and cheese.
Crust was crispy on the out side - fresh and light on the inside.
Best pizza ever!
Best pizza in Rochester. You’re going to order for pickup(that’s your only option), the owner is going to make the pizza the same way he has for the past 40 years, when it’s done he’s going to walk it to you and show you the pizza for approval before payment. This is how it’s done. It’s delicious, the toppings are under the cheese sometimes so don’t be worried, crust is fluffy and thick-ish but you can order thin crust if you want. It’s amazing.
Very good pizza. I tried the Sicilian round pizza. Was surprised how good it was. Very good price as well. Sauce maybe a little thick but still good. Decent amount of cheese as well. What really stood out was how fresh the bread was. Like fresh baked bread from Italian bakeries in NYC growing up.Very soft on the inside and crispy on the outside. I'd definitely recommend trying this place out. I'll be back to try a regular pie soon.
I wish they had sliced here but damn… this pizza is the best in Rochester. Ordered a large and could not stop eating it. DANGEROUSLY good.
I have been waiting to try there pizza for a while. All I can say is that the pizza was worth the wait. Excellent Pie ! Sauce and crust which is the most important part of the pizza was very very tasty!! Toppings were excellent too delicious homemade Italian sausage 😋 I will definitely be coming back. Thank you guys keep up the good work!!
This review is based only on the quality of the pizza. There are no frills or extras at this place, but if you like Sicilian style pizza then your going to love this place.
Surprisingly delicious. The place certainly looks like it has been open for 50 years. The sauce on the pizza was killer though! Definitely up there for one of the best pizzas in Rochester.
Visiting Rochester from Chicago, this place is the real deal. Good food and chill vibes. Every time I come back to Roc I visit. Good stuff
We just moved in nearby and decided to tell a local pizza place. We found Nino's and it was delicious! The wings in particular were delicious. Looking forward to our next pie!
Dave Portnoy needs to stop at this gem . I've been going to Ninos since 1980. Best pizza, hands down in Rochester,NY. If you don't agree with me, I'll buy your next pizza ---- for free!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Rochester
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes