You're not going here for ambiance. You're there because the pie is fantastic. Maybe it was an off day when I went in, because they hadn't even started my order, despite being told it would be 45 minutes pick up and I showed up after an hour.
But, after at least a half hour of waiting, they brought out my pies and garlic knots (get knots... a bunch. 3 won't do. Trust me). The food was just spectacular. I like the one in perinton better because they usually have my food ready when I get there, but if I'm in Henrietta, I'm going their for pie.
I am a man that truly knows pizza. This pizza is one that stands heads above most other pizza establishments. The crust on the pizza is amazing, light, crunchy, and chewy. The toppings they do not skimp on and the cheese that is used is quality. Today I had the pepperoni pizza. Oustanding!!!
Glad we stumbled on this place yesterday. Funny thing is we were gonna go to five guys next door and we get out of the car and my son goes look dad pizza. So we decided what the heck we always love trying new pizza places. Love the fact you guys have a wide variety of slices and also a slice deal from 3-5 everyday. The pizza was amazing as well. The employees were very professional and friendly as well!!!! We don't get to Henrietta/Rochester much as we live 90 minutes away. But now whenever we have Dr appointments we know where we're going!!!!
Reminds me of the traditional pizzerias back in NYC, love the people that work there plus fast service, plus they have a variety of pizzas to choose from including garlic knots, will keep going back!
Virginia was absolutely amazing for our big group of 10+, she went above and beyond countless times. The food was great but Virginia really made the experience top notch.
I love Joe's Brooklyn Pizza. I usually get a plain slice with meatballs, but because of the pandemic they can't add toppings. So, instead I got a grandma slice and plain slice.. and I can't believe I waited to try the grandma slice! Really good slice they make there, highly recommend. All their food so far that I've tried are also great.
Anna Marie Lico-Alfano
+4
I gave 4 stars at most, because, I wanted an "everything" Pizza everything on it.. unfortunately we were missing meatball meat, anchovies, artichokes. It was skimpy. I also wanted extra cheese. For the price I paid,$40.00 I expected this pizza to be fully loaded. It was an XL. I already told him my husband is a well known NY pizza man for 35 years. Worked many pizzaria and Sbarro's as key manager, troubleshooting mgr also... The atmosphere needs to have a GOOD cleaning, my table was very wobbly. I think it was quite expensive for what we got..the bathroom was 😩 ugh. Stinky.. the ovens needed to be cleaned out, my husband said. The pizza was good though, for what ever little was on there... I was just surprised.. we are from Brooklyn, NY. But this place needs to step it up to stay on top of the game. 🍕
Best in the area. Today I had a five-star slice of cheese pizza. There's nothing better than that! And the staff are super-friendly and very professional.
The workers are very friendly and amazing. They are always super nice and some of the best! The pizza is great and always fresh and tasty, some of the best thin crust. The only problem is it never feels like the AC is on, I always want to eat at the restaurant but it's always so hot in there. It would be nice if they cooled the store down so I could sit and eat.
Food is great, love their pizzas even though they’re very pricey. Could do without the adult tantrum from the older man who works there because he doesn’t know the current promotion from get my perks.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Rochester
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes