Luther Leong
This was my second time to the Elmwood Inn and I was not disappointed. My buddy and I came out for their Friday Fish Fry and it was great! One of the very best we've had in a long time. We were seated quickly (no reservations), even though it was fairly busy (the parking lot was almost completely filled). Our server, Christine was attentive and friendly.
I had the Great Lakes Edmund Fitzgerald Porter with the beer batter Fish Fry and my buddy had the Ellicottville Blood Orange Ale with the Panko Breaded Fish Fry. We both had the onion rings and cole slaw for our sides with tartar sauce in a separate cup. The fish was well cooked, fresh made and delicious. The onion rings were also great! If you're looking for a great Fish Fry on a Friday night, you won't go wrong at the Elmwood Inn, I'd recommend you give it a try.
Robin Fang
I come here for the beer battered fish fry! So good!!! There's lots of room and seating here. Never had to wait long to be seated. I've visited here often with coworkers for lunch and we've always had a wonderful experience!
Kelly Kinard
Lisa was phenomenal! My friend had a burger with onion rings and I had the beer battered fish sandwich with coleslaw. Everything was wonderful and I would definitely return.
Will Dziura
Food is overall very good, significantly better than most other food in the area and priced mostly reasonably. Beer selection could be a bit better but is pretty standard for the area. Service is where this place shines, staff is extremely friendly and attentive (at least at the bar). Has a pretty large group of regulars and it's pretty obvious why, this place has nailed it's pub culture. Overall if you like local bars/restaurants I would definitely give it a shot.
Megan MacAnn
It's a great little place, not much to it. The food is good and that's really what matters! I never really seen it that packed in there which is good because then you get attention. I tried a few different items and everything I had was good. Nothing over the top or two fancy couple of unique items on the menu I say give it a shot! You won't be disappointed.
Dee Andersen
For the most part the food is usually good. French fries are outstanding! Today my grilled sandwich was awfully greasy but inside ingredients were delicious. Nachos ordered had cold chicken and stale tasting chips. Had it redone with fries and was good. Chicken still cold. Chicken should be replaced with chili!
Carla Kutzuba
Dinner tonight was so good. Coconut shrimp appetizer and a side of Mac n cheese. So so good! Large shrimp with a crispy coconut coating served with a zesty peanutie sauce. Mac n cheese is the creation of the Chef. I loved the white cheesey sauce!!!! Prices are very reasonable. Our server, Lisa, was awesome. Friendly and attentive.
Kellie Herrmann
We searched for haddock fish fries near Strong hospital in Rochester and the Elmwood Inn came up. They did not disappoint! We received huge pieces of beer battered haddock (skin on, though) with tastey sides (broccoli salad, coleslaw, onion rings, tartar sauce and lemon). The petite broiled haddock was very petite but very good. It's a bar and restaurant with outside patio area. Enjoy:)
Christine C
We occasionally stop here for lunch and the staff and food are always great. The fish fry's and plates are always group favorites, and the staff is always welcoming. If anyone from the Inn is reading this, please bring back the open faced roast beef sandwich.
KP Smith
This place is a hidden gem. Excellent food. Reasonable prices. Decent beer selection (although id like to see that expanded). In the bar area there are ample TVs to make everyone happy. I went with the wings, extra crispy, which were cooked to perfection. My wife did the garbage plate. She liked the plate but to my personal preference there was some slightly off about the meat hot sauce. Too much cinnamon? Anyway, like I said that personal preference because my wife thought the sauce was amazing.
We'll go back again without hesitation.
Daryl Dear Cubitt
GREAT burgers! (Never had artichokes on a burger before but sure will again.) Our server Jennifer was so pleasant & friendly.
Will be back & definitely recommend.
Don Muller
Had another delightful lunch of the deck today in beautiful weather in Western NY.
Our server, Desi was great and the food was wonderful. Portions are generous. We'll each get at least one more meal from our lunch.
Alberta Roesser
Always delicious food with exceptional and professional service. I often go early in the week and there is only one front staff and she does a superb job. I often have the grain bowl which is delicious and my husband has the Mac and cheese which is also delicious but very rich.
Joyce “Joy” Ellis
The food was delicious! We were grateful that you have a plant based/vegan option, the burger was delicious. My husband loved your many beer choices and I loved that you offer prosecco by the glass, small bottle! The service was super. And the place was very cozy comfortable, with warm hospitality. We loved it!!! The Elmwood Inn is very special to us since were there for our very first date back in 1987, we married 2 years later in 1989 and we came back last last night on our 33rd anniversary. We haven't been back in years but seeing the Facebook offer brought us back and we plan to make it a regular dinner spot!
Meredith Janmey
Cozy, calm neighborhood pub. Delightful for a family lunch outing on a rainy day. Super nice staff and very accommodating of young children.
Susan Shafer
The food is delicious; the choices are all good; the service is excellent and the ambiance is fun. We enjoy lunches and dinners here and have always been more then satisfied.
Lauren Habberfield
This is a great restaurant with fantastic food. We know we always have a great meal and atmosphere when dining here.
Carla Hernandez
My last visit there, was my "last". The food was horrible tasting and overpriced, our waitress was less than attentive on a weeknight when the place was empty!! The kitchen served two dishes both w/pasta and sauce on a flat plate, not in a bowl, waitress spilled sauce all over the table and my dining companion!! When we asked why the pasta and sauce dinner wasn't served in a bowl, she replied, "We don't have any bowls." We were shocked and she recommended we ask the owner, she said, "The owner doesn't listen to us, we tell him all the time about spilling the sauce and the complaints/suggestions of the customers, he doesn't care!!" It is all too evident that this owner indeed does not care what customers think!
Michael Fadden
Elmwood Inn never disappoints. Great fish fry, bacon burger and chicken sandwich had by the three of us. Pretzel appetizers are delicious to boot.
Ron Schutt Sr.
I go almost every week for dinner. The bar is the best seating, near the fireplace. The service is great. They remember us and always seat us in the area they know we like. The food is so homey and consistent. It is great. Being across from college town, you get some great people watching. Really an "at home" kind of vibe. I highly recommend the Blue moon filet. Enjoy!!
Monica Love
My friend and I had to find a new place to watch Sunday football after our old place had to close. This is our new Sunday home. Food is great, beer selection outstanding. Harrison is pretty great!
Heather Allen
The service is always fast and friendly, the food is delicious, I have tried many different things, ranging from appetizers, to burgers, to steaks, and fish fry's, everything has been delicious and cooked perfectly, I highly recommend the Elmwood inn
Christopher R. Martin
I love the Elmwood Inn... it is how I think it must have been to visit "Cheers" in Boston... it has that neighborhood feel and one of the best wait staffs in the City; especially Jordan and Deanna; always a smile with excellent service! Oh, and the food is always top notch!
Sean Then
Blue moon burger(extra gourmet blue cheese cream cheese). Cheese Burger plate(extra gourmet meat hot). Grilled chicken sandwich. Some of my favorite meals in town. Hands down.
Vernon VanSkiver
Had not been to this restaurant since playing baseball at Genesee Valley Park and most of the time we just went there after a game to get wings. We happened to stop in there one night on our travels, and found the food to be delicious and the service was good. Nice ambience as it is an older building, but we have been there 4 times now in the last 3 months and have had a great meal each time. Very reasonably priced as well. And, when you get to share it with your wife, even better.
Joan Polmenteer Powell
The Elmwood Inn has the best fish fry in Rochester! We go there weekly for good food, great service and amazing staff!
Geoff Powell
Victoria M. Lang
I love this place. The food,drinks, & staff are wonderful every time I visit. They have the best burgers,salads,steaks, & did I say the "Electric Lemonade is AWESOME this drink will put a smile on your face" �.
Christopher Cipoletti-Ewell
Food has been good in the past. I don't know what happened last night. The French Onion Soup tasted like bland broth with a slop of cheese. That didn't compare to the disapointing service. For an hour long meal my water was refilled once. The hostess was more focused with her phone than the obvious slurping of my poor partched tongue. The server never even asked how our meal was. I won't be back. ✌
Scott Kalb
My wife and I had a great time at the Elmwood Inn. We always have a great time there. The food and service is great as is the atmosphere. We love it!
Jane Burns
Excellent service. And food . This was my first time Eating here. I will be coming there again. Keep up the good work
Dean Gionis
Bar and service were excellent. Wings should not be served here, they clearly have never been to Buffalo. dryish with ranch dressing......
Jenn Alessi
The atmosphere is great, and the food is PHENOMENAL. I have eaten there several times, and I have NEVER had a bad meal!
Sandra Miles
Good food,and our server was very personable. She was very patient with our group of older folks.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes