Reddings Ultimate Pizza

Not the best pizza, not the worst pizza. Their regular pepperoni was really good. Prices are probably the best in town for a local place. Daily specials and pizza by the slice is a great value. Friendly service, nice location and dining room, all make for a nice experience. Definitely somewhere I will be going back to.

I have been a long time lover of Ultimate Pizza. I love supporting local businesses and this has been our go to pizza place as we live in Mary Lake. I have had very subpar experiences since they have changed ownership but tonight was the last straw. I placed my order at 4:30pm, I clearly ordered a specialty pizza, the Polynesian and had the order repeated back to me with an hour delivery time. Our pizza was delivered at 5:36. Upon opening the pizza it was not the pizza ordered, very far from it. I immediately called back and was told it would be immediately remade and delivered asap. We received the correct pizza 45 minutes later.

Has ownership changed recently? This used to be the best pizza in town. The pizza I bought there yesterday was mediocre. The so called bread strips was just a pizza crust cut into strips with some cheese on it. Prices are high - at least as much as you'll pay at Round Table or Poppy's - but not as tasty. Service is slow. When I ordered I was told my pizza would be ready for pickup in 35 minutes, but it took closer to 45. I was asked to pay for the pizza and even to leave a tip before the pizza was ever out of the oven.

Nice little pizza parlor on the west side of town I tried to get there at least once a month for a slice of pizza. So quick and easy really very good quality as well good crust tasty toppings and the selection is usually Fair, depending on what time of day you get there, so get there early and go try Redding's ultimate Pizza.

Did this place really change ownership??? That would tragic, Eric is awesome 😎 and he made sure everyone was always taken care of and happy... Truly a great person in general... I will gladly change this to a 5 star review if in fact it's the same owner and the same bomb sourdough crust as it's always been... The only way you got something without garlic was to specify you did not want it!! Sooooo good