Finally found some good pizza in Mahwah area and I am pumped. The slices are GIANT. The joint is under new management and the pizza is much better than it used to be so make sure to give it another try! The owner and workers are extremely friendly and kind. The place is clean!
THE BEST authentic New York Pizza!!!! Been away for awhile and this just brought me back. Got an extra pie to take home! Great friendly staff, great service, love, love, love!!!
I honestly go out of my way to bring people who are not from the area here so they can experience a real taste of nj pizza. It still doesn’t disappoint after going there for over 10 years. Great job!
New York Pizza is our go-to for our pizza delivery! Everything we ever ordered from there is so amazing. Large portions, delicious and usually early when they deliver! We love them so much!! Five stars!
This restaurant has some amazing food and is BYOB. The owner Steve and his Staff are a lot of fun and make great hosts. They also partner with PlateRate, so if you try this restaurant out using PlateRate (pickup, delivery, or dine in), you get a 60% credit to order again for trying the highest rated menu items on your first order, and 30% to try new highly rated menu items on future visits. Once you've tried all their best tasting food, New York Pizza and Restaurant will be one of your go to favorites you order from all the time - it is for me!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Ramsey
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes