First Bite New York Pizza

Top tier pizza. You can order a slice for a out 5 bucks and they give you a huge slice that is basically two. John Madden visited this place along with many other celebrities. They have Muslim friendly peperoni which isn't made of pork. Also, the same man has been working here for the past two decades and he deserves more attention. Highly recommended.

New York Pizza Pleasanton has unique toppings. I saw the "Gyro Pizza" and I knew I had to try it. There were gryo toppings sprinkled across the pizza with a mix of pizza's traditional toppings like tomato sauce and cheese. There were plenty of indoors seats when I visited on a Saturday night (-11:00 PM). There is also an outdoor table if preferred. Their online menu seems to have more options than their in-person menu, so be sure to take a look (or make your own). Overall, a good spot for takeout with some unique toppings. I'd swing by again to mix and match even more.

I read the reviews before I came. Some good some bad. So I decided to try it out. The look: ....Authentic. As in, a little rundown and could use a little added paint. It captures the bizarre nature of now york through bizarre choice of artwork. The service: ....authentic. As in, a little underwhelming yet hospitable. Exactly what you want and find in NYC. Dont look into this too much the staff is great. The food: unlike the negative reviews.... I found my pizza stacked with toppings, perfectly sauced, and the crispy thing crust is unlike anything I have found in New York. Nevertheless, it was next level. It was floppy like your find in the city but had a unique crispness that made it that much better. Overall for a snack or meal under $10 this is a great place to start your food journey in Almeda CA.