Pizza, service, atmosphere all great!. A couple of other great pizza spots nearby. But would strongly recommend this place!
Ezra Doval
+5
First of all, the service here is always amazing. We had a server today, don't catch her name but she was super nice and made dining in even better. Best pizza I've ever had! Other pizza places I've been to never fill me up but with just 2 slices here I'm satisfied! You never have to worry about not getting enough cheese on your pizza and the taste is super good! They also have delicious ranch! I'll be going here for pizza often! Tried their boneless wings too and were also great!
Tatiana Klochkova
+5
Short stop for the late lunch. My son had Maui special pizza. Fast and friendly service. The place gives you a unique feeling of immersion in history, takes you 50-100 years back.
Bwt. Pizza was very good!
Bradley Nakaji
+4
First time here. Looks to be an old time Italian/pizza parlor. Pizzas looked good and smelled better. We had pasta dishes and those also looked and smelled wonderful.
Not too expensive and very family orientated.
Addendum:
Went back a few months later. Still haven't tried the pizza. Pasta is too good.
The only bummer, the server assigned to us was not very attentive. Served salad and meal together. Never came back after throwing the food on the table. Just our server was not so hot. The other server in the area had twice as many tables and she was around 10 times more.
Tim D
+4
The food was very good, service ok, was very busy, and the waitress did a very good job trying to keep up. They needed more workers to help out. We will be back for sure, The pizza was great. thanks
Kim Higashi
+5
Very welcoming & friendly staff! Waiters/Waitresses knew the menu specials & were prompt on their execution b4 asked. ALL MEAT PIZZA, AH-MAZINGLY DELICIOUS & COOKED TO PERFECTION! as well as the CHICKEN WINGS W/SAUCE ON THE SIDE! 👌😋 JUICY INSIDE, CRISPY OUTSIDE,
Enjoyed the food and atmosphere so much I had to take my son the following wknd to try this place. He LOVED it as well and it is our new Mom&Son spot.
Anil Pannikkat
+4
Great atmosphere and family friendly with a nice outdoor patio. Chicken wings (BBQ, Reaper) were good. Salads were liked by people. Pizza also others in my group liked although too thick crust for my liking. Beer was inexpensive & good
saika3rd Cal
+4
Honestly, I hesitated to return the place after the pandemic, but I believe that my decision was right. I mean that I enjoyed pizza very much.
Yet, I’m still doubt the quality of the service. That’s why I can’t afford five stars.
Rachel Reeve
+5
Gay Nineties is my husband's all-time favorite pizza....I agree that it is delicious! 😋 Pizza is a little expensive here, but it is a wonderful treat.
Ava Chiao
+5
My friend Michelle and her partner Brenden said this was a traditional to go to Gay 90s Pizza after the Scottish Festival. So yesterday we were inaugurated to delicious food. This was their 4th year at the festival. Best service far according to them. Our waitress was kind and checked in with us.
The pizza was absolutely delicious. For even better pizza It could have used 5 more mins in the oven to get crust baked all the way through and crunchy roasted cheese!!
Bread was crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside. It was so flavorful by itself. The bottom of the crust is good. It’s kind like a marriage of deep dish with Sicilian thin crust.
Besides the toppings tasted fresh and the sausage was especially good. The sauce is also what made it super flavorful on Franks Special.
Read the captions for the review.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pleasanton
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes