Laid back , local tasty pizza w 2 dozen beer options. Visited late Wed evening, So no waiting. Plenty of size, type, and topping options to build what you desire. Efficient Order @ the counter and find a table. MED. Pizza came out hot and plenty for 2 adults. Plenty of amusements including pak man, pinball & air hockey to name a few. An assortment of dessert options including 6-8 ice cream flavors.
Great pizza, great environment for the family. Pizza is good. Customer service is above average and actually pretty good. Good beer selection, and has a video arcade for the kids. I’ve had almost every pizza on the menu and all have their uniqueness and haven’t had a bad one yet
I really liked this place as a date spot for my wife and me. The Otis thick crust pizza was delicious and the prices were pretty reasonable. The customer service was really good too. I really liked the relaxed atmosphere.
![4]( "Recensione")
11-13-2021: first time here - ordered to go a medium taco pie with extra meat. I got the thin crust. Good flavor and comes with salsa and sour cream (they were out of sour cream).
5-20-2023: Friday early evening dinner - first time dining inside. My wife and I struggle with wanting to see a menu -due to the line we could not see the wall menu and no paper menus were anyway near the door; so that our thoughts could be ready once at the cash register. Not an easy in and out main door. I ordered the fat boy think crust pizza which is like a cheeseburger type (not much meat was my only issue) but tasted good. My wife ordered a special pizza: pesto tomato mushroom cheese thick crust: she really like hers. We also ordered the olive bread which was excellent. A couple of fountain drinks and a few minutes they brought the food which was very fresh. I think with a few little changes customer focus could be improved. Not a fan of wobble tables or the floor. They do offer a outside eating area which looked inviting.
1st time trying this pizza. Was pretty good. It was ready when I arrived and how we ordered. The cinnamon sticks were bland though for me. We will come back and try some other pizza varieties. We had the Kujo. Might dine in too just to experience the space, looked nice. Front staff was nice and greeted me with a smile.
These photos are from past visits and not my most recent visit. But, they were good pies too. I've been to Lost Pizza several times and have always enjoyed it. We like their wings, particularly the jerk flavor. We really like their tamales. My wife likes their taco pie or we get the one with artichokes on the thin crust. Left on my own, I go with pepperoni or the loaded pies on the thicker crusts. They've got a few local beers on tap too. Always had friendly service.
Yummy pizza and food. Wings are award winning though? It was pretty good wings to me but nothing crazy. The angel hair gets soggy very fast but that’s most of their pasta options. The Greek salad was delicious though. Overall a great pizza place!
Since becoming a Florida resident about 6 months ago, finding our favorite spots has been an adventure! Stumbling upon Lost Pizza Co. is the best thing our family has come across for our pizza needs! Their Otis is Ridiculously delicious! Cheese bread-Delicious! Wings-Delicious! Their signature hot sauce available on the tables isn’t exactly hot but it is still very yummy! Tangy, a smidge sweet and if you keep putting it on your food, which does not need it, could become hot ha ha! But it is delicious!! Our family has made this place our traditional Friday spot if we decide to eat out.
I don't venture to this side of town too often but have always wanted to try the pizza here. I was not disappointed by any means. The menus were right there as you walk in, so we were able to grab one and have our order ready by the time we got to the counter. I enjoy being able to choose where you want to eat, so we got a nice window booth. The food came out timely and in order since we had an appetizer first. The Pit Boss signature pizza was a good go to for the first visit and I'm looking forward to trying the others!
I ordered online. It was about a 45 min wait which was fine because I had other things to do first. The website was easy to order from. I've had problems with other websites. The pizza was hot and ready to go when I arrived. The staff was friendly and accommodating. I had ordered a thick crust with extra cheese and banana peppers. The crust was soft but not doughy. The crust was good but very very thick. I like a decent amount of sauce to compensate for the thickness of the crust but there was only a thin layer of sauce. Maybe I needed to order extra sauce but I've never done that before. The cheese was melted to perfection and the banana peppers were browned on top and sooo good. I will try the thin crust next time or maybe they just have regular.If I order a thick crust again, I will order extra sauce or have sauce to dip it in , but that's just me.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pensacola
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes