The best 10 restaurants and places to eat in Penn Yan, May 2024

Bonny Schultz

Yogesh Yadav

Phadririan Nightbreeze

Spotted Duck

96/100 (1305 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Parking Available

Free off-street parking

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Cheap Eats

"Very cute spot for frozen custard! Made with duck eggs and the ducks are on site. Lots of tables and available seating! They had dairy free options..."

Laura Potter

"Since gaining national fame (probably international at this point), there isn't much more I could personally add as a review that isn't already..."

Cassandra Elizabeth

"This was our first time at the Spotted Duck and it was so worth the drive. As a family of 6 we got two of the large Seneca flights so we could all..."

Erica Slater

"I think I have had ice cream in every state and abroad but this was unique, smooth, creamy and just plain delicious. Served 4 kinds in glass..."

lee c

"My family heard about this place from some friends, and we were in the area for other business. Very nice little spot off the highway with decent..."

John-David Rocha

"This place was quite an experience and totally was worth the 2 hour detour our trip from Boston to Niagara Falls. Their custard was fantastic. I was..."

Daniel Kraus

"A unique experience eatting custard made from Duck Eggs. Gave the custard a richer flavor and texture. We appericated the beautiful view, variety of..."

Alexandria Jones

"We waited in line for 45 mins on a Sunday afternoon but it was overall worth it. Because of the huge crowd, some flavors weren't available. The..."

Yupawadee Galasong

"A neat little ice cream shop off the road, and it's good. Some flavors really pop for me like the coffee, chocolate, and this blue on that they have...."

Dave Ruan

"Delicious custard! They have so many fun flavors that rotate seasonally. Many flavors are gluten free. I really love the flight options so you can..."

Alyson Collins

Penn Yan Diner

83/100 (1223 ratings)

"What a great find!! Beautiful homey little Diner right in the Village, with great food and most likely the best Eggs Benedict I have ever had!! The..."

Gary Rosbrook

"We had the breakfast sandwich with home fries - real potatoes, not frozen. Breakfast was great. Coffee was very good. Excellent service and a great..."

Catherine Joseph

"Sunday 12/17/23 What a charming place! We ate at the bar and watched our meal being made. Everyone was smiling and so pleasant. Our breakfast..."

Rebecca Caudle

"Super cute for a 98 year old diner! Their omelets were good. Very cozy and antique..."

Veronica Kelly

"All the dishes we had were outstanding! The server was attentive as well. It's a retro diner as advertised and I thought it was well done and..."

Michael Schipani

"Got the Banana Crunch French Toast, food and service was excellent. There was a debate among the locals on what was better The Diner or The Wagner..."

Leigh Everett

"A small diner with terrific food, service and old time feel! We sat at the counter and had a Birds Eye view of the cooks! They do an amazing job in..."

Tim Herriven

"Great food, and super friendly staff. Well worth the stop. The only downside is that this place is SMALL. A lot of side stepping and squeezing..."

Jason B

"Such a cute place! Worth the experience and history! Food was delicious and service was good! Place is a bit crowded feeling because it's small but..."

Ashley B.

"A wonderful bit of old fashioned Americana right smack in the middle of the computer age! It was Sunday morning, we went in, they took my cell number..."

Mike Stoebe

Dunkin'

71/100 (1117 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"I of course got the Butter Pecan Crunch and it was good but the didn't have the toppings like the other locations I have gone to has them. But still..."

Kayla Pizura

"Traveling so never been to this location before. Used the drive thru, did not realize how long the line actually was & moved super slow. When we..."

Momma Bear Buckley

"Great service! I love the Pumpkin flavored Iced..."

TERESA S

"Good coffee and that's usually all I get....they don't mess up my orders so that's the big..."

Brian Gillman

"Went thru drive thru this time very quick! Very..."

C Cab

"All I can say is i love Dunkin. Can't resist it...."

Roger Rose

"We walked in with a large order for a bridal party and had a lot of specialty drink orders. No questions as the orders were rattled off. Usually we..."

Cassidy Hatch

"A wonderful surprise this morning. I ordered online and when I arrived. The kind young lady must of saw me drive in and brought me my coffee and..."

Larry Johnson

"Not a bad Dunkin'. The employees were..."

M. Zimmerman

"Had the most pleasant experience this morning while picking mobile orders for my friends and me. The staff was so friendly, and they made sure that..."

Julie McGory

Silverbird Woodfired

78/100 (1076 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Neat little place creating great food. Off the way a little on a side street but well worth turning off the main drag. Definitely want to go back and..."

Adam Schneider

"Went here on a Saturday at 5pm and the place was completely empty. Not sure why because our dinner experience was fantastic. We got two different..."

Matthew Hiserodt

"Excellent woodfire pizza! One of the best warm spinach salads ever! Generous portions. The venue is historic but very clean and has a lot of..."

William Baker

"Staying in the area stop for a bite to eat. Parking was on Street and they were pretty busy when we arrived. I had a tuna melt and sweet potato fries..."

Peg P

"I ordered Beef on Weck because I'm back in town and other states just don't have that... I gotta say... It was great. I will be stopping by here..."

J C

"Cute little hole in the wall. Our server was definitely new and could have had someone shadowing him to better assist. He seemed new but was very..."

Unicornspoop Glitter

"Had the honey bourbon bbq and blackberry bbq smoked wings, both flavors were great. Also had the White Wagtail wood fired pizza that was amazing!..."

Joleen Krusen

"Great food and friendly staff. Portion sizes are really good. Excellent coffee (lattes, cappuccinos, the works). My only complaint is that the games..."

Liz L

"This might have been the best garbage plate I've ever had. I also saw a ton of people ordering wings, too. Next time I'm there I'll have to order..."

Gino Geruntino

"This is a homey joint that takes their food seriously. You can evaluate this immediately from the menu and how it describes it salads. Most bar or..."

Elizabeth O'Meara

"I’ve been here with with dates, by my self & with family always a good time. Chilli is amazing & wait staff is friendly. Will definitely be back..."

Roberto Garcia

"Heard an ad on the radio for the woodfired pizza. Went here for lunch today. Got some staples and ordered a slice each. The servers were very..."

Jaclyn Chelenza

"Great food, excellent latte. Cozy atmosphere. You can eat on the deck on warmer days. The owners are very friendly and welcoming. This is a must try..."

Marley Man

Tavern Restaurant

82/100 (1066 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Stopped in for lunch while my dad was at the dentist. Great selection of beers, nice variety of food across the menu. Cozy family atmosphere and..."

Diana Wright

"The Tavern was a nice break from the breweries in the area. Offered your genuine bar vibes and activities which I enjoyed while I drank. Offers two..."

Matthew Cotter

"Stopped here on our way back to Buffalo from Watkins Glen. Food ordered was a burger and a ham and cheese sandwich. The food was very good. And they..."

Michael Bordonaro

"Decent drafts, good food, reasonable prices. The cheesy bread that comes with the salad is excellent. I’d definitely..."

Steve W

"Great food and service. Just a neighborhood bar We go there often after..."

Patrick Grimaldi

"Great local place. I had a grilled chicken cordon bleu sandwich that was delicious. Other patrons were..."

Paul Schieb

"The Tavern is my favorite place to go for lunch or dinner! The atmosphere is fun, the music is the perfect volume, the staff are always attentive and..."

Brittany Moore

"We like going here. The food is better than most bar food. They have a separate dining area from the..."

KC Corbitt

"The Chicken Pesto sandwich with red pepper and spinach is my ultimate fav here, it tastes like it was grilled outdoors! The homemade fries taste like..."

Rebecca FA

"James is an extraordinary cook! Big time customer service! Thank you..."

Mike Whyte

"Lively place, mostly bar type menu, very inexpensive but good portions. Juke box, billiards, fast table service. True modern day..."

Robert Lustbader

"Great beer selection! The food was ok bar food. The girls behind the bar were friendly. Love this "locals" bar. They made you feel..."

Sharon Nassar

"The best restaurant in town & great..."

Charlie Mercado

"Great spot for one of the best burgers I've had in a..."

Steve Bell

"Did not eat but a fun local bar. The people were..."

Dave Bacon

"Good..."

Rubi Bravo

"We went there randomly and were really pleased by the food and service. Everything is very authentic, this place totally deserve a visit ! Special..."

serge D'Haeyere

"Great food atmosphere was..."

David Perry

Top Of The Lake

80/100 (1015 ratings)

"Its been a long time coming for Penn Yan but we are on the rise for "the place" to go for exceptional dining and the Main Deck is another "feather in..."

Chad Peek

"We have been there twice and we enjoyed it both times. The general manager Brad, manager Will and bartender Ryan were welcoming and friendly. The..."

Brenda Pugliese

"Beautiful day to have the option of sitting outside. Nice selection of local wines and microbrews. Service was great, food was good. Wife had Fish..."

Jim Ketcham

"Nice menu and very good food.Not gourmet but nice atmosphere with reasonable pricing. They do have a deck outside with view of the lake which is very..."

Scott Lewis

"We (group of 4) got there 15 minutes before afternoon kitchen closing but hostess greeted us warmly and seated us. Waitress was prompt and gave us..."

Glenn De

"We ate here (group of 8) the night before my wedding as a family celebration. Reservations were required, as there was a sign when we arrived for..."

Kayla Hodge

"We were invited to a soft opening. This place is fabulous. The service was awesome so friendly and capable. The food was great and so tasty. The..."

Al Troisi

"Beautiful views and great atmosphere at sunset. Nice selection of local wines by the glass. The salad was limp and sad, though. My conclusion: come..."

L Wilson

"Perfect spot to stay if you are going to a WVU 🏈 game. If not, avoid it on those weekends. Rooms were spacious with full fridges and comfortable..."

Sally & Keith Prather

"Drove up from Dryden and stopped for lunch yesterday and like most places they were short staffed. We sat on the deck and the waitstaff was..."

Charlie D

"My wife and I dined at Top of the Lake for dinner on July 3. First thing first - the food was fabulous, it was so good - (we both had the Caribbean..."

Brian Tomcik

"Service was 5 star... Prices were incredibly inexpensive... Million dollar view!!!... And lastly the food was..."

Andrew Hassell

"My honey and I were traveling through the area for business and stayed at the Hampton Inn next door to the Top of the Lake Restaurant. We had been..."

Linda Sawtell

The Wagner

Wheelchair Accessible

"Came here for lunch on Wednesday and had the buffalo chicken wrap. It had a more sweet flavor then what I am used to with buffalo chicken but it was..."

Kayla Pizura

"Great location for breakfast. Service was really good. Food was great! Open early. I would definitely recommend this..."

Theodore Lindsey

"We had a large group. The service was great. The food came quickly and was..."

Cathy Dutton

"The Wagner is a local favorite for a reason! The service is always quick and friendly, with very attentive wait staff. The food comes quickly with..."

Brittany Moore

"It's been a long time since I was there last. So I had a few beers and a burger n some mushrooms. So the burger was great full of flavor and most of..."

scott fullagar

"Steak was correct temp. Server was very efficient and food came out very quickly. Also, if you look at the photo quickly, it kind of looks like a..."

Nicholous Rycroft

"Got the steak and eggs for breakfast, I've had worse cuts of meat at 5 star steak houses. Absolutely delicious! Our server was definitely on top of..."

matt pohle

"Good food, fast service, and large dining space. Perfect if your visiting for the..."

Kelsey C.

"Breakfast is good and plentiful. Service very good, atmosphere a little dated but if you like being where the locals go this is a good..."

Howard Weiner

"It has become our go-to when we are going toward Penn Yan. The food is good, the staff are friendly and the prices are..."

bill Glitch

"Unbelievable restaurant! Went on a Sunday morning. Place was packed full. We got a table tho right away. Server was awesome, was there as we sat..."

Cindy Mullaney

"You think the food at Wagner's is nothing like the food showing here that my dear and wonderful daughter made. You try it, you may just love it. God..."

Franklin Goble

"Had a quick breakfast there for the first time recently. My girlfriend and her family have always talked this place up and it lived up to the hype!..."

Chris Gee

"Best steak I have had in a long time, Finally someone that know what medium well..."

Elaine Kenney

"Great breakfast place! Fresh food, affordable prices, friendly..."

Nick K

"One of our go to places for breakfast or lunch! Good food, consistently good..."

Patrick K

"Good food, excellent service, decent prices and breakfast is the best. We always go here and will continue doing..."

Jes Yeomans

"My husband & I don't visit the town often, usually just passing through. We decided to stop for dinner at Wagners. Both ordered meatloaf. (Note: not..."

Darlene Jann

Skyline Trading Post

Wheelchair Accessible

"Great staff! Great food! Small enough to be seeing the same servers, always have specials going on for dinner, food has always been top notch...."

Dan Heusler

"Our server was phenomenal, she was attentive and polite, she may have been the only one serving. Excellent lasagna (Wednesday night special!) The..."

Tamara Mancuso

"Had a wonderful wrap on a quiet Saturday afternoon. The staff was friendly and efficient. The food was delicious. I enjoyed sitting on the patio on a..."

Nancy Attard

"in all my years of going to keuka college and Penn yan to visit, I just tried the trading post today because the Penn yan diner was super busy. we..."

darla jane sucy bragg

"Great place for breakfast! Great homey atmosphere- certainly worth a..."

Timothy Boltin

"Excellent comfort food from great people in a cozy little whole in the wall place in Keuka..."

Titan “Brazzer” Prime

"Friendly relaxing restaurant . Moderately priced. Excellent innovative chef . Serve lots of standard fare. Specials a real..."

Denise Jose

"Was looking for a place to eat before heading back to PA after a day on Keuka Lake. We were towing boats, so we needed a large parking lot. We fit..."

roni stiger

"This is a nice, clean place to eat. A nice menu as well, all the food I've had here is really good!! We had breakfast the other day 😌 a few weeks..."

Mike Radie

"I had a huge prime rib cooked to perfection on a Saturday evening. My daughters had the Trading Post special. 2 eggs any way, 2 pancakes, and bacon...."

Larry Gilbert

Water Street Wine Bar

"Great store with multiple options! Staff are friendly with fair pricing. The flow of the store is exceptional and the decor is fantastic as well...."

Jasmyne Elliott

"They have an excellent selection from local to more popular national brands, a wide variety of wines and spirits and very knowledgeable and friendly..."

Titan “Brazzer” Prime

"Gorgeous little store with tons of choices. Lots of choices for wine, whiskey, tequila, vodka, anything really. Good pricing as..."

Alix Simmons

"Friendly staff, although I really wished they would of let me use their restroom as I was an out of state visitor in their..."

Linda Miles

"They are always so welcoming and knowledgeable about all their products. I've gone there on multiple occasions to purchase gifts and their..."

kathleen mcshea

"Nice people, large selection of..."

Joanne

"Have shopped her for years . Very good customer service and..."

Bambi Smith

"Great wine shop with nice, knowledgeable employees and a wonderful..."

Sarah Blagg

"I can't say enough good things about this place. I wanted to pick out a nice prosecco for my wife and her friends and get it delivered to them. Kyle..."

Michael Scalise

"Nice store, great..."

Chuck Kenyon

La Cocina

"Excellent & friendly service! The portions are a good size, and they have so many delicious options - I've never been disappointed! They also offer..."

Trista Day

"Terrific place. Delicious food. Good service. Owner is amazing. Try the..."

Lucas Beiswenger

"Very polite and attentive. We were a large party and they seated us quickly. They brought out a free cheese enchiladas appetizer when another large..."

Susan Neary

"Margarita's and Sangria are always outstanding! Food is very authentic and reasonably priced. Our only complaint is when the place is busy(they do..."

Bill Laffin

"This was our second visit. We went on a Friday afternoon to beat the crowd. It was just as fantastic this time. The margaritas are so good! I had the..."

deb dibona

"Went here with my girlfriend, phenomenal place. Authentic mexican food and the interior is definitely a stand out. Definitely a unique place. The..."

Logan Cobb

"Great little hidden gem of a restaurant! Cute little dining area on the front porch which is a fun little spin. The carnitas are great as were the..."

Katlyn Hippensteel Eltzroth

"Food was great! Highly recommend..."

Pete Maneiro

"I have been with La Cocina for 8 years , we have grown quite a remarkable amount. We strive for the best and make things fresh from the start! The..."

Tabitha Nissen

"The food was very good and wait staff quite friendly. We were there at a very busy time and our server was quire busy but she took the time to offer..."

Nancy Howe

"La Cocina's is my favorite restaurant in Penn Yan. I've almost tried everything on the menu and each dish is excellent. Very friendly and attentive..."

Demi Morgan

"Very good! A lot of small town Mexican restaurants go the Taco Bell route---greasy food with a lot of cheese dumped on top to hide the lack of..."

Steve Litwin

"When we moved here a few years ago everyone talked about how great the food was at the Mexican restaurant in Bath. Coming from a large city all I can..."

Sarah Saunders

"It’s just a great place , decorated so nicely , Clean , owner is always there making sure everything’s ok , food is the BEST never had a bad..."

Cynthia Vaughan

The Olney Place

Wheelchair Accessible

"Great food and a little bit of everything . Staff is delightful . Easy in and out for boat fuel..."

Tia Bliss

"Great grocery, deli, and taphouse. In the back there is a bar area with a great selection of beers, with beautiful views of Keuka lake and Tvs to..."

Kapil Bhanot

"Great spot. Whole crew stopped by to grab some sandos. Heard from another guy this was the happening spot. Well, I got the Mustang and I'm here to..."

Roadblock Thompson

"We docked and got gas, then food at the Olney Place and we were delighted with both. The interior is very nice, with a good beer selection and a nice..."

Jacob Snavely

"Great spot to stop along Keuka Lake for a snack, a souvenir, a game of cornhole, a smile, or a souvenir tshirt. Nice vibe along the peaceful..."

Kevin Markman

"Sandwiches were absolutely delicious and exceeded expectations. Shop was quaint and service excellent with indoor and outdoor..."

Chris P

"I'm not sure how to categorize the Olney spot. Is it a convenience store with a bar? A general store? A deli with beer? It's hard to say. Thanks to a..."

Tyler Lund

"Our go to place on the lake for breakfast. The sticky buns and breakfast sandwiches are a staple and a must have. Very friendly and nice staff. Some..."

B.D P

"Lovely view of Keuka Lake! This store had the best potato salad EVER which was being handmade by the owner Seth when we walked in. Friendly staff,..."

Robert Faith

"This place is awesome beyond description. The food selections are good and healthy. The staffs are very welcoming and friendly towards the guests. I..."

Aji Maimaiti

"Great spot for sandwiches, souvenirs, groceries, and..."

Nick Paladino

"Came to Keuka for my birthday, as always. Decided to stop in (first time ever) for some coffee. They made me a homemade breakfast sandwich on Gluten..."

Karen Lee Marzak

"Always our favorite spot to visit every year. Consistently great food and amazing service. The owner Seth Olney knows what seems like everyone who..."

Matt Wilkins

"The first thing we do when we get to the lake is stop at the Olney place for sandwiches. We always get the Rachel aka the Turkey Reuben. Seth is..."

Zach Corum

"It’s the Olney place you need to go! It advertises as a grocery store but it’s oh so much more! The beer tap room in the back, best egg..."

EJ Plimley

"Easy to spot from the road but if you're going the speed limit you'll drive right buy it. This is my go-to place to get the best sandwiches on Keuka..."

Richard Yhip

"Craft beer, general store, great sandwiches and wraps and more. I ordered the Rachel sandwich and it was the best sandwich I've ever had, washed down..."

Andrew Little

"Exceptional service, beer selection and great sandwiches, quick and inexpensive. A great view over looking Keuka Lake on their deck. Perfect stop by..."

William Lagasse

"Best customer service on the lake! My family had to throw together an impromptu party and I reached out to Olney Place for some help. They put..."

Brian Young

Timmy G's

"Excellent dinner - meatloaf dinner with garlic mashed potatoes & French chit pork chop with melted cheddar-jack cheese with garlic mashed potatoes ..."

Sue Porubek

"One of the best crab cake sandwiches I've ever had, at an unbeatable price. The entire menu is incredibly priced, with plenty of options. The staff..."

Kyle Sanson

"Expected better as the prime rib dinner didappointing. Very fatty and chewy and tough. Garlic mashed luke warm, salad sad. Other meal was Chicken..."

Cheryl Rogers

"Got the bacon burger and fries. So delicious! My burger was cooked to my specifications and the staff is really nice and friendly! Would highly..."

Ashley B.

"The other local places I normally go when passing through were closed, but I was parked here already and saw lots of people going in, so I did as..."

Karen Lee Marzak

"Nice place for lunch. Food well prepared and hot. Coffee is fresh. My favorite is the potato soup, and they have a tasty assortment of sandwiches..."

Stephen Hartman

"Great food & Great service. Quiet atmosphere and relaxing! We were impressed with the menu and could not decide on our dinner because there were so..."

Travel Gypsy

"Valentine's Day lunch date with the hubby. Beautiful atmosphere. Fantastic food. Even heard out of towners behind us raving that "whoever's in the..."

Karen Wagar

"It was very busy when we showed up, and we had to wait a few minutes for a table, but it was worth it for the food in Penn Yan. Our salads were..."

Allison Kirsch

"Great food and attentive service! From starters to dessert you won’t be disappointed. Highly recommend the tomato gouda soup, Cobb salad, Philly..."

Kelly Hamula

"Today is my birthday, the cook,who spent many nights sry my house with my older boy....you made my birthday special, thank you so much for all 3 that..."

Lena Bean

"Best steaks and prime rib in town. Friendly efficient staff. Tim the owner is very friendly and helpful. There specials on the menu are a surprise..."

Karen Rasmussen

"Best meal I have had in forever! Had the Chicken French and my son had the Seafood Macaroni and Cheese. Both were phenomenal! Really loved it, not to..."

Candice M

"The Cobb salad is great, daily quiche specials, prime rib, local wines, great service. Something for everyone on the menu - even for the kids! They..."

Jennifer Clancy

"Nice variety of food choices at good prices. Great service. Was with a party of six and all of us thoroughly enjoyed the food. We all agreed we would..."

Michelle Sanney

"Great place! The food was awesome and the staff was very friendly and accommodating. The cocktails were spot on as well. Would definitely recommend,..."

FireflyFarm,LLC

Cam's New York Pizzeria

Wheelchair Accessible

"There is only one pizza place on this corner. It is Cam’s New York Pizzeria… just FYI as Google currently has it on their map as 2 different..."

M.E. Schmelzer

"Vacationing up here from Pennsylvania, had trouble finding a place to eat on a Monday evening that was open. This was one of the few places that was..."

Skibibbles

"Was in the mood for real buffalo wings (we’re from Pittsburgh). Did not disappoint. We got hot and mild and they were both very good. Definitely..."

Jude Lovic

"Great slice of pie ! My number 2 for local. Always on point, crisp chewy good cheese great crust. If anyone is wondering? My number 1 only makes..."

Jason Smith

"Always the best pizza in town! Cam's will deliver up to 8 miles, have the coolest slice-of-the-day which is always a fun surprise, and their thin and..."

Brittany Moore

"Super yummy, fast service. I grab lunch order 4 slides to bring to our kids Pre-K picnic at the park, I walked in and out it's so quick🍕. I have..."

Christopher Galletta Stevens

"Tried a 14 inch pizza yesterday. Great pie, great service. value for two..."

Robert Lustbader

"100% correct order, on time. Delicious pizza when you're looking for that classic NY slice or pie, plenty of options... wings are always good and..."

Mark B.

"Just don't buy their sheet pizzas. The pizza pies are..."

Amanda McCormick

"Not a bad place. I brought the kids and my wife here the pizza was not bad as far as price I believe it was $3.10 for a slice of cheese and like..."

Caleb Bulriss

"Very good pizza. We requested no cheese for our own dietary reasons and they were happy to do so. No 'key' for no cheese pizza so no price difference..."

Jeff Goodhart

"Awesome!!! On my top 2 next to Anillios in corning...pizza is like real NYC..."

Debbie Hogan

"Cam’s pizzeria has amazing food and i would definitely keep ordering from here..."

Amanda Smith

"Bianca specialty pizza was absolutely delicious. Staff was extremely professional. Worth checking them out. Dough was amazing and they didn't spare..."

Christopher Graham

"Fantastic pizza, the wings are awesome! We were visiting 2 nights, we ordered the first night, it was so good we ended up ordering again the second..."

Candice M

"The way of the classic New York pizzeria is fading into memory as pizza chains spread across the country. Thusly, it was truly good to see that this..."

Boudicca Walsh

"Great pizza. What I think of when I want Great..."

Mark Wheary

Oak Leaf Cafe

Wheelchair Accessible

Accepts American Express

"Stopped in for breakfast while camping in Keuka State Park. Amazing fruit smoothies, the raspberry was delicious! Even stopped in again for breakfast..."

poisoned_record

"Highly recommend!!! Love the zucchini panini and we tried the zucchini chowder soup ☺️ plus my husband enjoyed his mocha..."

Jennifer Conway

"I loved this place! The food and coffee were very good, the service was fast and the people friendly. After breakfast we shopped around in the..."

Holly Pealo

"This little store and cafe is always a delightful experience! It’s wildly popular for good reason, always clean and bright and busy! It’s located..."

Brittany Moore

"I ordered the July Special, Peach Panini. It was super good!! I was a little skeptic at first, but thought I’d give it a try since it is very..."

Curtis Cressman

"Everytime I visit Watkins Glenn I always start my day at Oak Leaf Cafe. The food and coffee is absolutely exquisite. A must have. I always feel like..."

Justin Conner

"Had Buffalo Chicken wrap. It's very good. Not too spicy, yet there's enough spicy there so the sandwich is not..."

Laurie Mathews

"Great little grocery store and cafe. I frequently stop here when in the area. Normally it's a great experience and I enjoy the Cafe immensely. This..."

John Butler

"It was definitely worth the try,the service and food were really good. Will be going back again..."

Zak Keller

"I have had trouble with gift cards for a couple years there but food and service is very..."

Donna Vozenilek

"Maybe one of my favourite spots to eat in the Finger Lakes area. If I could I would fly up every morning( home is Austin) to grab a freshly made..."

taylor franklin

"I LOVE it here :) Best coffee in town. The girls are lovely. They are polite, knowledgeable and work really hard! It's always clean and..."

Bev Cummings

"A very quaint cafe and bake shop with a very not so quaint , quite amazing grocery store attached. Food at the cafe was great. Staff were..."

Erik Stoneham

"Came all the way to Seneca from Cambridge UK for a holiday, and I'd definitely come back. Good food, good price and great..."

Geoffrey Smith

"Very clean place with friendly staff and good..."

Brittany

"I was surprised, I expected the usual country store fare, farmer style. When I walked in, it reminded me of a high end sandwich shop like one would..."

Buddy Chasteen

"Delicious food. Ham & potatoe chowder is so good. Chicken salad sandwich was perfection. Enjoyed the store. Bought alot of goodies. Going to get back..."

Marlene Greenall

"We occasionally come to Oak Leaf and order from the menu….. they have a short menu, but it’s the right amount to choose from. I love their..."

Cheryl Ambrosone

"My wife, daughter and I dined in with picky snacks from general store and a fry pie from the bakery, which was the BEST baked good I have ever had...."

John Coppa

Mac's Dairy Bar

Wheelchair Accessible

Cheap Eats

"Fabulously rich Hershey’s ice cream. All the standard flavors plus wild concoctions like Banana Peanut Butter Moose tracks which is as yellow as..."

Josh Wright

"We love getting ice cream and playing putt putt at Mac's. If you're headed to Oak Hill, be sure to add Mac's as a stop. It's less than 5 min up the..."

Tai Jackson

"Great place to get ice cream or play miniature gulf! Plenty of sitting..."

Chris Roosa

"Their ice cream is always so divine and there are many options to choose from! I love how it's away from the town and more secluded with decent..."

Andi

"Mac's has Hershey ice cream, great selections. And a small but really quite fun mini..."

Steve Delahunty

"This is an amazing place! We enjoyed the Strawberry Dole Whip! Will definitely go back..."

Joe C.

"It was wonderful, a beautiful sitting area under the shade trees, staff is very sweet , and the ice cream is awesome, of..."

Glorianne Schuttler

"Hands down this is one of the most adorable ice cream shops you can go to. Where else can you see the Amish come by in a buggy while you're getting..."

Lisamarie

"Great hometown ice cream. The prices here are great. They only take cash. They do have an ATM on site in the ATM only charges a $1 fee which is..."

Caleb Bulriss

"Definitely a local favorite and the ice cream is very..."

David Perry

"Cash only but there are lots of options and the ice cream is..."

Addison Dodge

"The best ice cream in Yates Co. You get your money's worth..."

Colleen Riviello

"There are so many options for ice cream, sundaes, or even milk shakes. They only take..."

Mackenzie Dodge

"The pumpkin ice cream is outrageously delicious!! Tastes like very cold pumpkin pie on a cone. (My "4-legged child" loved it too! She is a..."

Renate Eichelberger

"I grew up going to Mac's ice cream. I visited recently and man has it changed on the outside. There is plenty of parking spots, picnic benches to sit..."

Rebecca Anderson

"Excellent place to stop for ice cream. We always stop when we are in the..."

John Reynolds

"Cool little place that had a ton of flavors and vegan options (dole). Right by the town and friendly..."

Matthew Moll

"Fun-shaped building? Got it. Ice cream for all tastes and diets (including vegan/dairy-free)? Got it. Play area for kids? Got it. Mini putt-putt?..."

A Place for Little Sprouts to Grow

"We really like their monthly custard flavors. Good outdoor seating. If you time it right you can watch the kids across the street playing games at..."

Rhonda Pennington

Mustang Pub

"We stopped here for drinks after dinner. Fun place. Karaoke was entertaining. Bartender hustled and took care of me and my hot..."

John Evans

"It's a bar, so that is the surroundings you will have. We were surprised by the menu. Our orders were great and served very fast. We would definitely..."

Jeanne M

"Local bar atmosphere. Friendly staff. We had the burgers and they were..."

Mark C

"Loved the trivia experience, even though we didn't win. Very fair..."

Lothar Lothar

"Stopped in to grab dinner and watch some of the Superbowl before heading back to our hotel. The food was great (the wings were HUGE, and so..."

Bren R

"Comfort food with good portions and a large selection of..."

Douglas Baird

"Great food and service. Also delicious..."

earl woolard

"Camping at Keuka Lake SP and came into town for a drink, bite to eat and free wifi. Had the hot wings and they were awesome. We have a favorite..."

Petra Catteau

"The waitress was super kind with us. Besides they have the Tuesday chicken wings day that you have 12 wings for just 8$ with a wide range of sauces...."

David Escobar

"I've had two great meals here during Wednesday Trivia night. The service is very good - friendly and attentive. I ordered a special sandwich and they..."

Jennifer Clancy

Taco Bell

"I have always had nothing but good experiences here. The employees are very kind, patient, and helpful. The food is always made with care. I have..."

Behind The Veil

"If tonight had been my first experience here I would have given them 3 stars due to the lengthy time it took for the drive through line to move, it..."

Brittany Moore

"Penn Yan Taco Bell is one of the top two locations in all of the Finger Lakes in my opinion, with the second being Canandaigua. The food is always..."

Cassandra Elizabeth

"I pulled away from the drive through and my order was completely messed up. I stopped went inside and without any argument the manager, I wish I..."

Chris

"Had to wait for someone to notice me standing there so I can place my order!!! But after that the service was good and the food was great!! Clean..."

Phadririan Nightbreeze

"This location is the best taco Bell I've ever been to, clean fast and kind and they take their time to make it..."

Cindy Clark

"The food was good, atleast what I had but the workers seemed happy, the only bad thing is that they don't serve be breakfast like they say in the..."

Julienn Francisco

"By far the best taco bell I have ever had. The lady who took our order was so nice, asked how our day was, just great service overall. The food..."

Stephanie kunes

"Wait was kind of long. Food was ok. What you would..."

Sandra Felice Felice

"Me and my roommates went through the drive thru late at night and they didn’t have chips and cheese and offered to replace it with something else..."

Cierra

"This location is top notch. Other fast food places ought to take notes. They make you feel like you matter and they are thorough and show..."

AM Communications

Amity Coffee

"The best coffee spot in Penn Yan, and Yates County. So says I. Great place to set up and get some work or reading done. Nice selection of coffee..."

Steve Delahunty

"This place was super cute! The coffee was really good and service was pretty quick. All payment methods are accepted (Apple pay, cash, card, etc). We..."

Anna Bassett

"Camping in Keuka Lake State Park. Decided to go out for coffee and a light breakfast in the morning. I got the raspberry and cream croissant and it..."

poisoned_record

"I was in town just for the weekend and I always love trying local coffee shops. I was BLOWN away with this business. The interior is really cozy and..."

K B

"Friendly service and kind vibes. Also had among the best croissants I’ve ever had. Plenty of buttery, flaky, light layers. Got bacon, egg, and..."

Lizette N

"A ‘must add to the itinerary’ if visiting the Finger Lakes. Come for the coffee, stay for the breakfast. The egg & cheese croissant and the..."

Jennifer “Jen” Maltba

"Lovely coffee shop! My cortado was good, but the real star of the show was the maple pecan scone- absolutely delicious. The interior of the shop had..."

Gabe Hart

"Passing through. Needed a coffee and a snack. This seemed to be the best place to stop in town. IT WAS!!! Coffee was excellent, and the pastries..."

Jason Kanisloupus

"Super cute coffee shop! The latte and cappuccino were..."

Veronica Kelly

"Excellent breakfast following a wine tour the day before. Amity provided a delicious and much needed caffeine boost, with awesome pastries to fill us..."

Shark Man

Main Deck

Mark's Pizzeria

Wheelchair Accessible

"I ordered for a whole volleyball team and Mark’s Pizzeria was excellent. I called and made a last minute change from pickup to delivery and they..."

Sydney Pellman

"Great pizza! If you love Mark's dough then you already know. If you haven't been, Mark's has some pretty fluffy dough. It's super tasty, great flavor..."

Seth S

"Delivery driver came all the way out to our construction site. Very impressed with service and food. Will order from there..."

Myah Lupo

"Thank you for delivering to me out in the middle of nowhere, you can count on the cheese pizza. Subs and calzones are also huge and delicious!..."

Mark B.

"Great service, the pizza is mediocre at best. It's not the worst pizza I've ever had. We enjoyed the cheesy bread sticks much..."

Terri Mori

"Mark's isn't my FAVORITE pizza place but it is still very good and not expensive whatsoever! Also, kudos to the delivery driver on Christmas Eve who..."

Gwenykka Smith

"McKayla was amazing, as a district manager for Verizon Wireless I appreciate good service, and she went above and..."

Marco Cartwright

"We enjoy Mark's Pizzeria. Had to grab a quick dinner one busy night with work and other activities. Pizza was good. Buffalo chicken macaroni and..."

Patrick K

"Very friendly staff! We got 2 of their "pan" pizzas and and an order of cheesy garlicbread. One was pepperoni and sausage the other was 1/2..."

Mitchell Rohrbaugh

"Visiting NY from TX and this is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! Love the crust, just the right amount of sauce, even the leftovers were..."

Emma Broussard

"Awesome food every..."

Jackie Meyers

"Stayed in Penn Yan on business. Found Mark's Pizzeria. Ordered a Calzone and Garden Salad the first night; Wings, Garden Salad and a Slice of Pizza..."

David Enser

Flour Shop Cafe & Bakery

"Friendly Staff. Great Food and Coffee. A Couple Tables outside, We sat..."

Joseph Rutkowski

"Stopped in on Monday and got a latte and a breakfast sandwich. Food and coffee were excellent, service was..."

776football

"Excellent, friendly service and fantastic food!! My wife and I had panini sandwiches: She had the tomato and mozzarella with pesto on ciabatta. I had..."

Randy Knapp

"Had the Greek breakfast wrap and it was awesome! My daughter was bummed that they didn't have any regular cinnamon rolls left until she realized that..."

Jennifer Clancy

"Friendly small-town atmosphere. Excellent bakery items. I highly recommend the cinnamon sugar donut muffins and the huge cinnamon buns with maple..."

Linda Berger

"There aren't enough positive adjectives to describe this cafe/bakery. The available baked goods rotate regularly, always giving you a new, fresh, and..."

Mark Detwiler

"This place is a little different with their sandwiches. In a very good way! I ordered a Turkey, cranberry mayonnaise club. It was delicious. I have..."

Joan Watson

"The cinnamon rolls on Saturday are to die for! Make sure you get there early, especially in the summer, or else they're gone. I wished they'd make..."

Manda Willette

"We always love this little cafe - a truly local business that takes good care of its customers. Great coffee, great sandwiches, and the best..."

Brian Shoemaker

"The Flour Shop make my wedding cake and cupcakes for our wedding. The cake (chocolate with vanilla cream cheese frosting) was the best cake I've ever..."

Jeanine Almon

Wheelchair Accessible

"The BBQ shack is the place to be! Andy his hospitality is through the roof! The food was literally the best we had on our three weeks cross-country..."

Jasper Allert

"One of my favorite places to pick up a fantastic family meal. Love the lunch and dinner combos. Last week we ordered ahead and they had two pulled..."

25HalfordFamily

"We stayed in Penn Yan 2 years ago and had brisket here twice and it was fantastic. My wife and I have been trying brisket at other places while we..."

Mike Link

"Food was great. I had ribs and the wife had the brisket. Coleslaw and Mac salad were as expected. In time I hope they can dress the place up a..."

Dacks

"This place has good BBQ. My only complaint is the portion size of their sides. My example is, the "Assorted Family Combo" is supposed to feed four..."

W

"Went there for dinner, and the food was incredible!! The pulled pork sandwich was the best I've ever had with tender pork and crispy bacon...."

Laura Alishauskas

"Always looking to try local places when I travel, and this place is a diamond in the rough. Great food, and service, portions great staff helpful and..."

Jennifer Stout

"Got the garbage plate with meatsauce, Mac salad, home fries and cheese with bacon! Super good. Extremely huge portion. Pulled pork sando my buddy..."

Roadblock Thompson

"We saw the good reviews online and thought we had to stop in. Their food is absolutely incredible, very affordable for the portion size. You have to..."

Sean ODell

"Just finished a Chicken Barbecue that my surprised me with..with macaroni and pasta salad..Excellent Excellent..don't change anything and keep up the..."

Chuck Hall

Angel's Family Restaurant

Wheelchair Accessible

"The food is good diner breakfast food. My pancake was great. Angel Muffin is an egg cheese sausage sandwich very good. Hash browns excellent The..."

Susan Knorr

"Old school diner/restaurant. Basics and all good. Get pancakes or sausage with biscuits. Get the rhubarb..."

Steve Delahunty

"Lovely family diner located right in downtown Penn Yan. Parking was easy right on the street, if not you can park further up and enjoy the short..."

Holly Wilson

"A tidy, simple place to get breakfast. The waitstaff was friendly a quick, the food was hot and plenty and everything came correct. The coffee was..."

Brianna Siegrist

"Angel's is a very old diner in Penn Yan. I don't know how old the place really is, but there is an old menu board with eggs for 30 cents and wheat..."

Gary Wurstner

"We travel alot around the US and dine in local restaurants wherever the road takes us. Today we found ourselves in PennYann Ny. We found this..."

Roger Rose

"Small diner with great food. The home fries were crispy, just like I requested. I would definitely go..."

Ralph Westerbeck

"Great classic American diner with good food and friendly service. I enjoyed all the old photos and decorations around the place. It looks like it has..."

Zach D

"Great food and very friendly staff every time you visit they treat you like..."

Norman Swarts

"Food was excellent ,Service was quick. Was very enjoyable..."

Richard R

"Food was perfect! The chili was very hearty and flavorful. I got the patty melt on rye and man were they generous with the butter. The made from..."

Marla Ginter

"Wonderful breakfast with a hometown feel. Cheryl is a delightful server and it's always a pleasure to see how hers Donna & Angel. Great value for..."

Molly & Wayne Butler

"This was a place that my parents used to go to while they were dating! It's a small, locally owned business and because of that, you get great..."

Jallyn Walrath

"Excellent food I had a fantastic cheeseburger and..."

New Customer

"The food is amazing and the service is wonderful. Everyone is really friendly and accommodating. Reasonable prices and great staff. I ordered the..."

Lisa Sim

"We've been going to this place for over 20 years when in town. Wonderful home cooking, owner is so friendly and welcoming. Atmosphere cozy, kind of..."

Lynn Hilton

"Great food, great prices, great service. My family was visiting the area for a few days and decided it wasn't worth trying to find a different place...."

Austin Munn

Union Block

Wheelchair Accessible

"We went to celebrate my son’s 30th birthday and had an amazing experience from the minute we walked through the door. With the stone walls and old..."

Robin Martin

"I was looking for a restaurant while traveling through Penn Yan, and I found Union Block. The reviews say it all. The food is fantastic as well as..."

RH Erie

"We had a delicious meal and great service at Union Block Italian in Penn Yan. Fresh pasta and salad dressings made in house. A small bistro with..."

Dee Anderson

"The waitress Juanita was wonderful! We had spinach lasagna and a glass of wine each. The moscato was extremely good and I kind of wish I had a second..."

D “Shellsabub” H

"Italian American classics worth every calorie. The garlic bread was TO DIE FOR. Clams with white wine and garlic were incredible. Fresh Caesar wedge...."

Elizabeth Shen

"Great food! Service was great! Great bar selection! Really nice vibe inside and cute outside..."

Justin Miller

"Excellent atmosphere and staff. Foid was very good, although the long sauce was..."

Daniel Bechard

"Great staff! Team work, will oiled machine. Old Fashioned, there's a drink with Violet Liquor, the bar tender is crafty as well. Dinner was great...."

daniel miller

"My chicken picatta was perfect and large portions for take out. The capers was not salty or had too much lemon. It was perfect. The mash was so..."

Katie Wu

"Delicious food clean excellent service. My husband and I spent the weekend in Penn yan NY and this resturant was minutes away from our Motel. When we..."

Cindy Madar

"1st time at Union Block. It was our 1st anniversary together and celebrated here. The food was good and the service was excellent. Definitely..."

Michael Schultz

"I lived in Northern NJ and have been missing the great restaurants of the NYC area. No more. Union Block ranks up there with the best of them. ..."

C C

"Great locally owned Italian restaurant. Cozy atmosphere and great outdoor dining area overlooking the Keuka Outlet. Food was fantastic and great..."

greg musser

"Very unique spot located on the canal, nice patio, great bar, best garlic bread I’ve ever had. The staff is great, the food even better! Definitely..."

Dylan Douenias

"The food was good but not great. I did not care for the pasta sauce. It was the first time there it was a long ride from Victor where we live . Do..."

Eleanore Freeze

"The food and service were excellent! The restaurant was recommended by a friend who had previously travelled to the Finger Lakes region and we..."

Keith Huthmacher

"Excellent, my carbonara pasta was delicious. A fun, lively spot. Prices were just..."

Peggy Klus

"Delicious food, great wine, and friendly staff. Wonderful place for a lovely..."

Michele Elias

Parker's Grille & Tap House

Reset

There are 56 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Penn Yan restaurants

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Justin Klosek

Sallie Griner

Julienn Francisco

Roger Rose

Dale69

andy sallavanti

Stacy Romaine

Reinaldo Ocasio

Southern Lightning

Lisa Reagan

Meddy Jacques

Buddy Chasteen

Brad Golden

Kristine Crocker

Jo “Sweetjo”

Josh Wright

Robert Druker

Bergen Nelson

Shawn Garman

K OBR

Marion NYC

Kelly Diss

Yvette Cordone

Mary Krencik

Steve Bell

Don Barnes

Thomas Lederach

Steve Bagnato (nissanlord)

Doug Burr

Daniel Bechard

Mary Krencik

Tim Herriven

Edwin Presley

Mike O

Matthew Hiserodt

Laura Grimme

Jesse Hoover

Roy G Biv

Vince Tersegno

Benjamin Simpson

Nikki Lee

Sue Bills

Joshua Kobielski

Kenneth Pace

Stacey Petersen

Gary Phillips

Johnna Ingram

Quentin Bubnis

edgar curtis

DR K

Harlan Wenger

Bonny Schultz

Yogesh Yadav

Phadririan Nightbreeze

Laura Potter

Cassandra Elizabeth

Erica Slater

lee c

John-David Rocha

Daniel Kraus

Alexandria Jones

Yupawadee Galasong

Dave Ruan

Alyson Collins

Gary Rosbrook

Catherine Joseph

Rebecca Caudle

Veronica Kelly